Hypergraph Clustering Based on PageRank

Yuuki Takai, Atsushi Miyauchi, Masahiro Ikeda, Yuichi Yoshida

Abstract

Hypergraph clustering is essential for analyzing higher-order relationships in complex networks, yet existing methods often force a trade-off between theoretical rigor and practical scalability. This paper introduces the first practical hypergraph clustering algorithms with theoretical guarantees on cluster conductance. By generalizing Personalized PageRank (PPR) to hypergraphs and utilizing an efficient diffusion-based solver, the authors provide local and global clustering tools that are significantly faster than previous theoretical approaches and more accurate than common heuristics.

Introduction

In network analysis, identifying clusters—groups of entities with dense internal connections and sparse external ones—is a fundamental task. While standard graphs represent binary relationships, many real-world scenarios involve higher-order relations, such as co-authorship among multiple researchers. These are best modeled as hypergraphs, where a single "hyperedge" can connect any number of vertices.

Clustering hypergraphs is significantly more challenging than clustering regular graphs. Most existing tools are either fast heuristics lacking mathematical guarantees or theoretically sound spectral methods that are too computationally expensive for large-scale datasets. This research bridges the gap by developing an algorithm that is both fast and backed by a "Cheeger-like" theoretical guarantee on conductance, a standard metric for cluster quality.

Methodology

The authors' approach is built upon Personalized PageRank (PPR). In a standard graph, PPR represents the probability of a random walker being at a specific vertex. Extending this to hypergraphs requires several technical innovations:

  • Non-linear Hypergraph Laplacian: The authors utilize a non-linear, set-valued Laplacian operator, which captures the complex structure of hyperedges more accurately than standard matrix-based Laplacians.
  • Diffusion-based Computation: Rather than using slow optimization solvers, the PPR calculation is treated as a diffusion process. The authors solve the underlying differential equation using the Euler method, incorporating "sparsification" to maintain computational efficiency by ignoring negligible values.
  • Local and Global Algorithms: The local algorithm finds a cluster around a specific "seed" vertex, while the global version identifies the best overall cluster by strategically applying the local method across the hypergraph.
Comparison of a hypergraph structure and its graph expansion representation.

A key insight of this work is that working directly on the hypergraph structure preserves original relationship data that is often lost or distorted when using traditional clique or star expansions.

Experimental Evaluation

The algorithms were evaluated on real-world hypergraphs including co-authorship networks (DBLP, arXiv), social groups (YouTube), and knowledge bases (DBpedia). These datasets ranged from dozens to over 250,000 vertices.

Key Results

  • Superior Quality: The proposed algorithm consistently identified clusters with lower conductance than standard expansion baselines (CLIQUE and STAR).
  • Scalability: The local algorithm proved highly scalable. On the largest datasets, such as DBpedia Genre, the CLIQUE expansion method failed due to memory constraints, while the authors' algorithm completed in seconds.
  • Global Performance: The global algorithm outperformed hMETIS, a popular industry-standard heuristic, in cluster quality across nearly all tested datasets.
Conductance results on DBpedia datasets showing the impact of parameters T and Δ on cluster quality.

As shown in the experimental results, the efficiency and quality of the clustering are sensitive to the time step ($\Delta$) and total time ($T$) parameters of the diffusion process. Finding the optimal configuration currently requires some empirical tuning.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that PPR-based diffusion is a powerful and practical tool for hypergraph clustering. By avoiding the information loss of graph expansions and the complexity of traditional theoretical solvers, the authors provide a scalable solution for high-order network analysis. Future work will focus on further reducing the cost of global searches and automating parameter selection to make these tools even more accessible for large-scale applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

A hypergraph is a useful combinatorial object to model ternary or higher-order relations among entities. Clustering hypergraphs is a fundamental task in network analysis. In this study, we develop two clustering algorithms based on personalized PageRank on hypergraphs. The first one is local in the sense that its goal is to find a tightly connected vertex set with a bounded volume including a specified vertex. The second one is global in the sense that its goal is to find a tightly connected vertex set. For both algorithms, we discuss theoretical guarantees on the conductance of the output vertex set. Also, we experimentally demonstrate that our clustering algorithms outperform existing methods in terms of both the solution quality and running time. To the best of our knowledge, ours are the first practical algorithms for hypergraphs with theoretical guarantees on the conductance of the output set.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{takai2020hypergraph,
  author = {Yuuki Takai and Atsushi Miyauchi and Masahiro Ikeda and Yuichi Yoshida},
  title = {{Hypergraph Clustering Based on PageRank}},
  booktitle = {ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Zh1u9iUB8u},
}
Figure