Hybrid Analog and Digital Beamforming for mmWave OFDM Large-Scale Antenna Arrays

Foad Sohrabi, Wei Yu

This paper, authored by Foad Sohrabi and Wei Yu from the University of Toronto, addresses a critical bottleneck in the rollout of 5G and 6G millimeter-wave (mmWave) communications: the high cost and power consumption of massive antenna arrays.

TL;DR

The researchers propose a hybrid beamforming architecture that combines a high-dimensional analog stage with a low-dimensional digital stage to achieve near-optimal performance in wideband mmWave systems. By using a novel heuristic algorithm that designs the analog hardware based on the average channel characteristics across all frequencies, they demonstrate that systems can reach "fully-digital" performance levels using significantly fewer power-hungry radio frequency (RF) chains.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In mmWave communications, large antenna arrays are necessary to overcome high signal path loss. However, the "gold standard" approach—fully-digital beamforming—requires a dedicated RF chain (converters, mixers, power amps) for every single antenna. For an array of 64 or 128 antennas, this is prohibitively expensive and energy-intensive.

Hybrid beamforming offers a compromise: a small number of RF chains are connected to a large number of antennas via a network of simple analog phase shifters. The challenge is twofold:

  1. The Wideband Constraint: In modern OFDM systems (like 5G), the analog phase shifters are "dumb"—they must be set to a single state for the entire frequency band, even though the wireless channel changes across different subcarriers.
  2. Hardware Topology: Designing algorithms that work for both "fully-connected" (every RF chain hits every antenna) and "partially-connected" (RF chains hit specific sub-arrays) architectures.

Methods

The authors develop a decoupled design strategy for both Single-User MIMO (SU-MIMO) and Multi-User MISO (MU-MISO) scenarios:

  • Asymptotic Analysis: They first prove mathematically that as the number of antennas goes to infinity, a hybrid system with a limited number of RF chains can perfectly match a fully-digital system due to the inherent "sparsity" of mmWave channels (signals only travel along a few paths).
  • The "Average Covariance" Heuristic: For practical systems, they propose designing the analog beamformer based on the average of the channel covariance matrices across all OFDM subcarriers. This captures the dominant spatial directions of the channel that are common to the entire frequency band.
  • Iterative Coordinate Descent: They use an iterative algorithm to solve the non-convex problem of setting phase shifters (which have a "constant modulus" constraint—you can change the phase, but not the amplitude).
  • Digital Refinement: Once the analog stage is fixed, the digital stage is optimized per subcarrier using standard techniques like water-filling (for SU-MIMO) or WMMSE (for MU-MISO) to handle inter-user interference.

Datasets

As a theoretical communications paper, it does not use a static dataset. Instead, the authors evaluate their methods using a Stochastic Geometric Channel Model.

  • Parameters: They simulate a mmWave environment with a specific number of scattering clusters (typically 5–15) and paths per cluster.
  • Configurations: They test various antenna geometries (e.g., 64x32 MIMO) and compare their results against existing benchmarks in the literature (specifically the work of El Ayach et al. and Alkhateeb et al.).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sparsity is the Enabler: The "aha moment" is that mmWave channels are spatially sparse. Because the signal only arrives from a few angles, you don't actually need a unique digital signal for every antenna; a few "beams" (RF chains) are enough to capture almost all the available energy.
  • Analog for the "Macro," Digital for the "Micro": The analog stage should handle the broad spatial directions (which stay constant across frequencies), while the digital stage handles the frequency-specific fading and interference cancellation.
  • Unified Design: The proposed algorithm is "architecture-agnostic," meaning it provides a single framework that works for both high-performance fully-connected arrays and low-power partially-connected arrays.

Key Results

  • Near-Optimal Efficiency: In a 64x32 SU-MIMO setup, the proposed hybrid algorithm achieved spectral efficiency nearly identical to the optimal fully-digital system while using only a fraction of the RF chains.
  • Performance Gains: The heuristic outperformed previous state-of-the-art hybrid designs by roughly 2dB, particularly in scenarios where the number of antennas is not "infinitely" large.
  • Multi-User Success: For MU-MISO, the algorithm showed that with just 16 RF chains at a base station serving 4 users, the system could match the performance of a fully-digital 64-antenna base station.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Perfect CSI Assumption: The study assumes the base station has "Perfect Channel State Information" (it knows exactly what the channel looks like). In reality, estimating these channels is difficult, especially with limited RF chains.
  • Hardware Impairments: While the authors briefly discuss low-resolution phase shifters (e.g., 1-bit or 2-bit resolution), the primary math assumes infinite resolution.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future work should focus on user scheduling—deciding which users to group together to best exploit the common analog beams.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hybrid analog and digital beamforming is a promising candidate for large-scale millimeter wave (mmWave) multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) systems because of its ability to significantly reduce the hardware complexity of the conventional fully digital beamforming schemes while being capable of approaching the performance of fully digital schemes. Most of the prior work on hybrid beamforming considers frequency-flat channels. However, broadband mmWave systems are frequency-selective. In broadband systems, it is desirable to design common analog beamformer for the entire band while employing different digital (baseband) beamformers in different frequency sub-bands. This paper considers the hybrid beamforming design for systems with orthogonal frequency division multiplexing modulation. First, for a single-user MIMO (SU-MIMO) system where the hybrid beamforming architecture is employed at both transmitter and receiver, we show that hybrid beamforming with a small number of radio frequency (RF) chains can asymptotically approach the performance of fully digital beamforming for a sufficiently large number of transceiver antennas due to the sparse nature of the mmWave channels. For systems with a practical number of antennas, we then propose a unified heuristic design for two different hybrid beamforming structures, the fully connected and the partially connected structures, to maximize the overall spectral efficiency of an mmWave MIMO system. Numerical results are provided to show that the proposed algorithm outperforms the existing hybrid beamforming methods, and for the fully connected architecture, the proposed algorithm can achieve spectral efficiency very close to that of the optimal fully digital beamforming but with much fewer RF chains. Second, for the multiuser multiple-input single-output case, we propose a heuristic hybrid percoding design to maximize the weighted sum rate in the downlink and show numerically that the proposed algorithm with practical number of RF chains can already approach the performance of fully digital beamforming.
BibTeX
@article{sohrabi2017hybrid,
  author = {Foad Sohrabi and Wei Yu},
  title = {{Hybrid Analog and Digital Beamforming for mmWave OFDM Large-Scale Antenna Arrays}},
  journal = {IEEE J. Sel. Areas Commun.},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=0vXGuocpbp8},
}

Loading related content...

Figure