Higher order hesitant fuzzy Choquet integral operator and its application to multiple criteria decision making

B. Farhadinia, Uwe Aickelin, Ha Khorshidi

Abstract

In complex Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) environments, evaluation criteria are rarely independent. Traditional aggregation operators, which rely on additive measures, often fail to capture the synergies or redundancies between these criteria. This paper introduces the Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy (HOHF) Choquet integral operator, a novel framework that combines the flexibility of Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy Sets (HOHFS) with the non-additive modeling power of the Choquet integral. By allowing membership values to be expressed through various generalized fuzzy types, this operator accounts for both the inherent hesitation of decision-makers and the interactive nature of evaluation criteria. The effectiveness of the approach is demonstrated through an energy policy selection case study and a comparative benchmarking analysis against existing MCDM techniques.

Introduction

Decision-making in the real world is seldom a matter of simple weighted averages. When evaluating complex alternatives—such as national energy policies or corporate investment projects—the criteria involved (e.g., environmental impact, economic cost, and technological feasibility) often exhibit interdependence. For instance, the importance of "technological feasibility" might change depending on the "economic cost" already allocated to a project.

Standard additive operators assume independence, which can lead to skewed results. Furthermore, decision-makers often struggle to provide precise numerical values, exhibiting "hesitation" that is better represented by sets of values or interval-valued fuzzy sets. This paper addresses these challenges by proposing a higher-order hesitant fuzzy approach integrated with the Choquet integral.

The Problem: Interdependence and Hesitation

Traditional Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) faces two primary hurdles:

  1. Criterion Interaction: Improving one criterion may automatically influence another. Standard models cannot represent scenarios where "the whole is greater (or less) than the sum of its parts."
  2. Information Uncertainty: Existing Hesitant Fuzzy Sets (HFS) are often too rigid. Decision-makers may want to express their evaluations using diverse formats—such as triangular fuzzy numbers, intervals, or intuitionistic fuzzy sets—simultaneously.

Methodology

1. Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy Sets (HOHFS)

The authors utilize HOHFS as a mathematical "umbrella." Unlike standard fuzzy sets that use a single membership value, HOHFS allows membership to be defined by a set of "Generalized Type" fuzzy sets. This flexibility allows the operator to reduce to a standard fuzzy set, an interval-valued set, or a type-2 fuzzy set depending on the specific data provided by the experts.

2. The Choquet Integral and Fuzzy Measures

To handle interaction, the authors employ the Choquet integral, a non-additive aggregation tool. Instead of simple static weights, it uses fuzzy measures to assign importance to every possible subset of criteria. This allows the model to capture synergies (positive interaction) and redundancies (negative interaction) between criteria.

3. The HOHF Choquet Integral Operator

By merging these two concepts, the authors define the HOHF Choquet integral operator. The workflow involves:

  • Definition: Formalizing the operator to handle higher-order fuzzy arguments.
  • Ranking: Implementing a score function to rank HOHF elements, a necessary step for the Choquet integral's sorting process.
  • Property Verification: The authors mathematically prove that the operator maintains essential properties, including idempotency (consistent output for identical inputs), monotonicity (improved inputs yield improved outputs), and boundedness.

Case Studies and Validation

Energy Policy Selection

The model was first applied to a socio-economic development problem: selecting the most appropriate energy policy among five alternatives ($y_1$ to $y_5$) based on four criteria: technological, environmental, socio-political, and economic. The HOHF Choquet integral successfully aggregated the complex, hesitant evaluations provided by experts, identifying project $y_5$ as the optimal choice.

Benchmarking and Performance

To verify the efficiency of the proposed method, the authors compared it against 10 existing MCDM techniques (including various hesitant fuzzy and TODIM-based methods) using a benchmark investment project selection problem.

Using a "dominance-vector" algorithm to measure consistency with collective preference, the results showed that the HOHF Choquet integral operator achieved a distance value of 0. This indicates perfect consistency with the collective majority rule, outperforming several traditional hesitant fuzzy methods that failed to account for criterion interaction.

Conclusion

The Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy Choquet integral operator provides a robust framework for decision-making under uncertainty. By moving beyond additive measures, it offers a more realistic representation of how criteria interact in complex systems.

While the model is highly flexible, it does face computational complexity challenges; defining fuzzy measures for $n$ criteria requires determining the importance of $2^n$ subsets. Future research will focus on simplifying these estimations and exploring the application of HOHF frameworks in pattern recognition, image processing, and automated clustering.

Summary updated

Abstract

Generally, the criteria involved in a decision making problem are interactive or inter-dependent, and therefore aggregating them by the use of traditional operators which are based on additive measures is not logical. This verifies that we have to implement fuzzy measures for modelling the interaction phenomena among the criteria.On the other hand, based on the recent extension of hesitant fuzzy set, called higher order hesitant fuzzy set (HOHFS) which allows the membership of a given element to be defined in forms of several possible generalized types of fuzzy set, we encourage to propose the higher order hesitant fuzzy (HOHF) Choquet integral operator. This concept not only considers the importance of the higher order hesitant fuzzy arguments, but also it can reflect the correlations among those arguments. Then,a detailed discussion on the aggregation properties of the HOHF Choquet integral operator will be presented.To enhance the application of HOHF Choquet integral operator in decision making, we first assess the appropriate energy policy for the socio-economic development. Then, the efficiency of the proposed HOHF Choquet integral operator-based technique over a number of exiting techniques is further verified by employing another decision making problem associated with the technique of TODIM (an acronym in Portuguese of Interactive and Multicriteria Decision Making).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{farhadinia2021higher,
  author = {B. Farhadinia and Uwe Aickelin and HA Khorshidi},
  title = {{Higher order hesitant fuzzy Choquet integral operator and its application to multiple criteria decision making}},
  booktitle = {Minerva Access (University of Melbourne)},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.22111/ijfs.2021.5868},
}
Figure