Higher order hesitant fuzzy choquet integral operator and its application to multiple criteria decision making

Bahram Farhadinia, Uwe Aickelin, Hadi Akbarzadeh Khorshidi

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy Choquet Integral Operator" (HOHF-CI) designed to handle complex decision-making scenarios where criteria are not only important but also interact with each other. The authors demonstrate its effectiveness in a practical energy policy selection problem and compare it favorably against existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional decision-making methods often struggle when the factors (criteria) influencing a decision are not independent. Aggregating information using simple additive rules becomes illogical in such cases. This paper addresses this by proposing a new operator that can model these interdependencies. Furthermore, it tackles the challenge of representing expert opinions that are inherently uncertain and can be expressed in various fuzzy forms, going beyond simple numerical ranges. The authors introduce the "Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy Set" (HOHFS) to capture this rich, multi-faceted uncertainty and then build their operator upon this framework.

Methods

The core contribution is the Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy Choquet Integral Operator (HOHF-CI). This operator builds upon the Choquet Integral, a well-established tool for aggregating information that accounts for interactions between criteria using fuzzy measures. The novelty lies in its application to Higher Order Hesitant Fuzzy Sets (HOHFS). HOHFSs are an extension of hesitant fuzzy sets, allowing membership degrees to be represented by a collection of generalized fuzzy sets (not just crisp numbers). The HOHF-CI aggregates these HOHFSs, considering both the importance of individual criteria and their complex interrelationships. The paper also defines score functions for HOHFEs and HOHFSs to enable comparison and ranking of alternatives.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper presents two case studies with self-generated data for demonstration.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Independence: The paper emphasizes that real-world decision-making rarely involves independent criteria. The HOHF-CI explicitly models these interactions, making it more suitable for complex scenarios.
  • Rich Uncertainty Representation: HOHFS provides a powerful way to represent expert opinions that are not only uncertain but can also be expressed in diverse fuzzy forms (e.g., intuitionistic fuzzy sets, type-2 fuzzy sets, etc.). This is a significant advancement over simpler fuzzy set representations.
  • Unified Framework: The HOHF-CI offers a unified approach to handle various types of fuzzy information and their interactions within a single decision-making framework.
  • Practical Applicability: The paper demonstrates the operator's utility in a real-world energy policy selection problem, showcasing its ability to provide meaningful rankings.

Key Results

The paper successfully develops and defines the HOHF Choquet integral operator and discusses its aggregation properties. A practical example of selecting an energy policy demonstrates the operator's ability to aggregate HOHFEs and rank alternatives. The results show that the proposed technique can effectively handle complex decision-making problems with uncertain and interacting criteria. A comparative analysis with other techniques in a second case study (using TODIM) suggests that the proposed method is efficient and provides a suitable ranking.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the application potentials of HOHFS are diverse and suggest future work in other domains such as clustering, pattern recognition, and image processing. They also plan to explore other aggregation operators within the higher order hesitant fuzzy setting for MCDM. While the paper demonstrates the operator's effectiveness, a more extensive comparative analysis with a wider range of existing techniques and datasets could further solidify its advantages.

Summary updated

Abstract

Generally, the criteria involved in a decision making problem are interactive or inter- dependent, and therefore aggregating them by the use of traditional operators which are based on additive measures is not logical. This verifies that we have to implement fuzzy measures for modelling the interaction phenomena among the criteria. On the other hand, based on the recent extension of hesitant fuzzy set, called higher order hesitant fuzzy set (HOHFS) which allows the membership of a given element to be defined in forms of several possible generalized types of fuzzy set, we encourage to propose the higher order hesitant fuzzy (HOHF) Choquet integral operator. This concept not only considers the importance of the higher order hesitant fuzzy arguments, but also it can reflect the correlations among those arguments. Then, a detailed discussion on the aggregation properties of the HOHF Choquet integral operator will be presented. To enhance the application of HOHF Choquet integral operator in decision making, we first assess the appropriate energy policy for the socio-economic development. Then, the efficiency of the proposed HOHF Choquet integral operator-based technique over a number of exiting techniques is further verified by employing another decision making problem associated with the technique of TODIM (an acronym in Portuguese of Interactive and Multicriteria Decision Making).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{farhadinia2021higher,
  author = {Bahram Farhadinia and Uwe Aickelin and Hadi Akbarzadeh Khorshidi},
  title = {{Higher order hesitant fuzzy choquet integral operator and its application to multiple criteria decision making}},
  booktitle = {Minerva Access (University of Melbourne)},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.22111/ijfs.2021.5868},
}
Figure