Abstract
The exploration of a two-dimensional wind-driven ocean model with no-slip boundaries reveals the existence of a turbulent asymptotic regime where energy dissipation becomes independent of fluid viscosity. This asymptotic flow represents an out-of-equilibrium state, characterized by a vigorous two-dimensional vortex gas superimposed onto a western-intensified gyre. The properties of the vortex gas are elucidated through scaling analysis for detached Prandtl boundary layers, providing a rationalization for the observed anomalous dissipation. The asymptotic regime demonstrates that boundary instabilities alone can be strong enough to evacuate wind-injected energy from the large-scale oceanic circulation.
Introduction: The Dissipation Puzzle in 2D Fluids
In classical 3D turbulence, energy cascades from large scales to small scales until it is dissipated by viscosity, leading to the "zeroth law of turbulence." However, 2D turbulence typically exhibits an inverse energy cascade, where energy flows upward to larger scales. For oceanography, this creates a paradox: the wind constantly pumps energy into large-scale gyres, yet if the ocean were purely 2D, this energy would accumulate indefinitely.
To address this, researchers employed a rigid-lid barotropic quasigeostrophic model on a square domain using the beta-plane approximation. Crucially, they enforced no-slip boundary conditions ($u=v=0$ at the walls), allowing for the formation of intense shear layers. Using high-resolution simulations (up to $8192 \times 8192$ grid points), they mapped the transition from laminar flow to a highly nonlinear regime.
The Vortex Gas and Boundary Layer Detachment
In the low-viscosity limit, the flow transforms into what the authors call a "vortex gas"—a dense population of intense, small-scale cyclonic and anticyclonic vortices. This state is not uniform; it is driven by the instability of the "Prandtl sublayer" at the no-slip boundaries. As the flow intensifies, this sublayer detaches from the wall and rolls up into the vortices that characterize the turbulent state.
Despite the chaotic nature of the vortex gas, the time-averaged flow (as seen in Figure 1B) maintains the classic western-intensified gyre structure. This indicates that boundary instabilities can effectively balance wind-driven energy input without destroying the large-scale circulation.
Results: The Zeroth Law of Turbulence
The most significant finding is the emergence of "anomalous dissipation." As viscosity ($ u^*$) decreases, the boundary layer becomes increasingly unstable, producing more and smaller vortices. This process ensures that the total energy dissipation rate $\langle \epsilon \rangle$ remains constant, effectively recovering the "zeroth law" in a 2D system.
As shown in Figure 6, while the contribution of the mean flow to dissipation decreases with lower viscosity, the contribution from fluctuations (the vortex gas) increases to compensate. The total dissipation eventually plateaus, demonstrating independence from viscosity. Furthermore, the total energy of the vortex gas follows a specific scaling law: $E \sim \nu^{*-1/2} \beta^{*-5/3}$.
Discussion and Future Directions
While this 2D model provides a robust mechanism for energy evacuation via boundary processes, real oceans are 3D and stratified. In a 3D environment, these vortices would likely interact with bottom topography or undergo baroclinic instabilities. Future work will involve testing whether the energy flux toward fine scales remains governed by these large-scale boundary processes in more complex 3D ocean models.
Summary updated