Quasi-geostrophy against the wall

Antoine VenailleJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: Coasts are obstructions to the classical derivation of continuously stratified quasigeostrophic equations, due to possible resonances between slow internal coastally trapped Kelvin waves and anticyclones. [Deremble et al Ocean Modelling 2017] proposed a coupled model between a quasigeostrophic interior and boundary layer Kelvin wave dynamics. We revisit the derivation of this model, paying particular attention to conservation laws. We find that quasigeostrophic energy is conserved despite the existence of Kelvin wave shocks in the boundary layer. The effect of those shocks is to change the global distribution of potential vorticity, and, consequently the interior flow structure. In that respect, we show that there is an active control of the boundary region on the interior flow.

Introduction: The Coastal Disruption of QG Theory

In geophysical fluid dynamics, Quasi-Geostrophy (QG) is the foundational model used to describe the slow, large-scale evolution of the atmosphere and oceans. Standard QG theory relies on a "frequency gap"—a clear separation between slow geostrophic motions, such as eddies, and fast inertia-gravity waves. This separation allows for a simplified description of the fluid's evolution by filtering out high-frequency noise.

However, coastal boundaries disrupt this machinery. Along a vertical wall, internal Kelvin waves can propagate. These waves are trapped against the coast and, crucially, can be slow enough to overlap with geostrophic frequencies, filling the gap that standard QG theory assumes is empty. This overlap allows for resonances and nonlinear interactions—specifically the formation of shocks—that standard models ignore.

Dispersion relations illustrating the frequency gap in standard QG (a) and its closure by coastal Kelvin waves (b, c).

This study provides a rigorous mathematical re-evaluation of how these coastal boundaries disrupt standard theory, clarifying how coastal processes affect global conservation laws and fundamentally reshape the flow in the ocean's interior.

Methodology

The study employs a multi-step theoretical derivation to link interior and boundary dynamics:

  • Asymptotic Expansion: The derivation uses a small-parameter expansion based on the Rossby number ($Ro \ll 1$), representing the ratio of inertial to Coriolis forces.
  • Layered Shallow Water Model: To track the conservation of Potential Vorticity (PV)—a fundamental quantity akin to angular momentum—the study utilizes a multiple-layer shallow water model rather than a continuously stratified fluid.
  • Boundary Layer Analysis: The domain is partitioned into an "interior" governed by standard QG and a narrow "boundary layer" near the wall governed by nonlinear Kelvin wave dynamics. The thickness of this boundary layer scales linearly with the Rossby number ($Ro$).
  • Shock Theory: Rotating hydraulics theory is applied to model how Kelvin waves form shocks, which are treated as localized sources that inject PV into the interior flow.

Key Insights: Energy and Active Control

The Energy Paradox

In many physical systems, shocks are synonymous with energy dissipation. Surprisingly, this research proves that QG energy is conserved in the limit of a vanishing Rossby number ($dE^g/dt = 0$). While shocks do dissipate energy locally, the boundary layer is so thin ($O(Ro)$) that its net contribution to the global energy balance vanishes as $Ro \to 0$.

Cyclone-Anticyclone Asymmetry and Boundary Control

Coastal shocks act as "one-way" producers of vorticity, specifically generating cyclones. This explains the observed bias toward cyclonic structures in coastal regions compared to the open ocean. Furthermore, the boundary is not a passive container; by injecting potential vorticity into the interior, the coast actively reshapes large-scale circulation patterns far from the wall.

Symmetry Breaking

Standard QG in an unbounded domain is time-reversible. The presence of a wall and the resulting unidirectional Kelvin waves break this symmetry, bringing the reduced model closer to the underlying Boussinesq physics.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While this study establishes a self-consistent set of equations linking interior QG advection with boundary-layer wave evolution, several questions remain. The conclusion that energy is conserved holds only in the asymptotic limit ($Ro \to 0$); in real-world oceans with small but finite $Ro$, these coastal processes likely act as a significant energy sink.

Additionally, the current model is purely inviscid and ignores the "no-slip" condition and viscous boundary layers (like Ekman layers) that exist in real fluids. Future work should explore how these factors, along with the long-term validity of asymptotic assumptions, influence the active control of boundaries on global ocean circulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coasts are obstructions to the classical derivation of continuously stratified quasigeostrophic equations, due to possible resonances between slow internal coastally trapped Kelvin waves and anticyclones. [Deremble et al Ocean Modelling 2017] proposed a coupled model between a quasigeostrophic interior and boundary layer Kelvin wave dynamics. We revisit the derivation of this model, paying particular attention to conservation laws. We find that quasigeostrophic energy is conserved despite the existence of Kelvin wave shocks in the boundary layer. The effect of those shocks is to change the global distribution of potential vorticity, and, consequently the interior flow structure. In that respect, we show that there is an active control of the boundary region on the interior flow.
BibTeX
@article{venaille2020quasi,
  author = {Antoine Venaille},
  title = {{Quasi-geostrophy against the wall}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1017/jfm.2020.287},
}
Figure