Gravity determines the direction of nerve roots sedimentation in the lumbar spinal canal

Jun Yang, Zhiyun Feng, Nian Chen, Zhenhua Hong, Yongyu Zheng, Yang Jiang, Tingjie Zhou, Xin Yao, Taifeng Xu, Linting ZhangResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the role of gravity in the sedimentation of lumbar spine nerve roots using multi-positional magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. Analyzing 56 patients with back pain, researchers compared conventional supine MRIs with prone and lateral positions. The results confirmed that nerve roots typically follow the direction of gravity, settling at the lowest point of the dural sac. However, in patients with a positive sedimentation sign (SedSign)—often associated with lumbar spinal stenosis—nerve roots frequently failed to sediment, suggesting mechanical tension or canal narrowing. These findings validate the SedSign as a reliable indicator of lumbar pathology.

Introduction

Lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS) is a common cause of debilitating back pain and mobility issues, characterized by the narrowing of the spinal canal. A key diagnostic tool in MRI evaluation is the "sedimentation sign" (SedSign). In a healthy lumbar spine, gravity causes nerve roots to sink to the dorsal (back) side of the dural sac when a patient is in a supine position. A "positive" SedSign occurs when these roots remain suspended or dispersed, failing to settle. While clinically useful, the underlying mechanism—specifically whether gravity is the primary driver—has been a subject of debate. This study aims to clarify the role of gravity by observing nerve root behavior across different body orientations.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective study of 56 patients (31 men, 25 women) selected from the Sanmen Hospital database. All participants had previously undergone standard supine MRIs and were recalled for additional imaging in prone (lying on the stomach) or lateral (lying on the side) positions.

The cohort was categorized into two groups based on initial supine scans: 31 patients with a positive SedSign and 25 with a negative SedSign. Imaging was performed using a 1.5T scanner with T2-weighted axial and sagittal sequences. To ensure the nerve roots had adequate time to settle, patients were required to stand for three minutes before transitioning to the new posture for imaging. Two independent orthopedic surgeons evaluated the scans using Barz’s criteria, with a senior radiologist resolving any conflicts.

Results and Clinical Correlation

The study revealed significant demographic and clinical differences between the two groups. Patients in the positive SedSign group were notably older, with a mean age of 67.5 years compared to 51.6 years in the negative group. Furthermore, clinical diagnoses were strongly correlated with SedSign status.

Patient demographics and clinical diagnoses categorized by Sedimentation Sign (SedSign) status.

As shown in the table above, all 31 patients with a positive SedSign had confirmed spinal pathologies such as lumbar spinal stenosis or disc herniation. In contrast, 72% of the negative SedSign group suffered from non-specific back pain without significant canal involvement.

The Impact of Gravity

The multi-positional imaging provided definitive evidence for the gravity hypothesis. In 85.7% of the total cohort (48/56), nerve roots followed gravity when the patient moved from a supine to a prone position, sinking to the ventral (front) side of the dural sac. In the lateral position subset, all five patients showed nerve roots subsiding to the dependent (lower) side of the canal.

However, the "positive SedSign" group showed a marked resistance to this gravitational pull.

Comparison of nerve root movement in prone MR images between negative and positive SedSign groups.

While only one patient (4%) in the negative group failed to show ventral sedimentation in the prone position, seven patients (22.6%) in the positive group had nerve roots that remained sequestered at the dorsal side (P < 0.001).

Discussion

The findings confirm that gravity is the default force governing nerve root position in the lumbar spinal canal. The failure of nerve roots to sediment in positive SedSign cases suggests that mechanical forces—such as high tension from disc herniation or severe crowding from stenosis—override the relatively weak force of gravity. This reinforces the SedSign not just as a visual curiosity, but as a functional marker of significant mechanical interference within the spinal canal.

The age disparity between groups further supports the link between SedSign and degenerative spinal conditions, which typically progress with age. The study demonstrates that when the spinal canal is healthy, nerve roots move freely with gravity; when they don't, it is a strong signal of underlying pathology.

Conclusion and Limitations

This study concludes that nerve root sedimentation follows the direction of gravity, and a positive SedSign is a reliable MR indicator of lumbar pathology involving the spinal canal.

Despite these insights, the study has limitations, including a relatively small sample size and the absence of an asymptomatic control group. Future research should aim to correlate SedSign findings with functional clinical outcomes, such as walking distance and symptom duration, and utilize axial imaging through the vertebral pedicle level to further refine diagnostic accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Objectives: To investigate the role of gravity in the sedimentation of lumbar spine nerve roots using magnetic resonance (MR) imaging of various body positions. Methods: A total of 56 patients, who suffered from back pain and underwent conventional supine lumbar spine MR imaging, were selected from sanmen hospital database. All the patients were called back to our hospital to perform MR imaging in prone position or lateral position. Furthermore, the sedimentation sign (SedSign) was determined based on the suspension of the nerve roots in the dural sac on cross-sectional MR images, and 31 cases were rated as positive and another 25 cases were negative. Results: The mean age of negative SedSign group was significantly younger than that of positive SedSign group (51.7±8.7 vs 68.4±10.5, P&lt;0.05). The constitutions of clinical diagnosis were significantly different between patients with a positive SedSign and those with a negative SedSign (P&lt;0.001). Overall, nerve roots of the vast majority of patients (48/56, 85.7%) subsided to the ventral side of the dural sac on the prone MR images, although that of 8 (14.3%) patients remain stay in the dorsal side of dural sac. Nerve roots of only one patient with negative SedSign did not settle to the ventral dural sac, while this phenomenon occurred in 7 patients in positive SedSign group (4% vs 22.6%, P&lt;0.001). In addition, the nerve roots of all the five patients subsided to the left side of dural sac on lateral position MR images. Conclusions: The nerve roots sedimentation followed the direction of gravity. Positive SedSign may be a MR sign of lumbar pathology involved the spinal canal.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2021gravity,
  author = {Jun Yang and Zhiyun Feng and Nian Chen and Zhenhua Hong and Yongyu Zheng and Yang Jiang and Tingjie Zhou and Xin Yao and Taifeng Xu and Linting Zhang},
  title = {{Gravity determines the direction of nerve roots sedimentation in the lumbar spinal canal}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-54612/v3},
}
Figure