Age and disc degeneration in low back pain: automated analysis enables a magnetic resonance imaging comparison of large cross-sectional cohorts of symptomatic and asymptomatic subjects

Amir Jamaludin, Timor Kadir, Andrew Zisserman, Iain W. McCall, Frances M. K. Williams, H. Lang, E Buchanan, J Urban, Jeremy FairbankmedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Chronic low back pain (LBP) is a leading cause of global disability, yet its diagnosis remains notoriously difficult. For decades, the clinical utility of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been a subject of intense debate. While MRIs often reveal structural issues like disc degeneration, these same features are frequently observed in individuals without any pain. This overlap has led to a prevailing clinical consensus that spinal MRIs are of limited diagnostic value, as they appear to lack the specificity required to distinguish between normal aging and pathological conditions.

However, this consensus often overlooks the nuances of age and spinal anatomy. Previous studies have been hampered by the subjectivity of human radiologists and the difficulty of analyzing large datasets consistently. This study addresses these limitations by utilizing an automated AI tool to perform an objective, large-scale comparison of symptomatic and asymptomatic populations, aiming to determine if structural defects correlate with pain when evaluated through a standardized lens.

Methodology

To ensure consistency across thousands of images, the researchers employed SpineNet, a verified automated machine-learning system for MRI analysis. SpineNet can analyze a spinal image in approximately five seconds—a task that typically takes a human radiologist 30 minutes—eliminating the variability inherent in subjective grading.

Study Design and Cohorts

The study focused on a large cross-sectional cohort of females aged 30–80, categorized into three groups:

  • Asymptomatic Group (TwinsUK): 701 females with no reported back pain in the preceding three months.
  • Symptomatic Group (OSCLMRIC): 763 females referred to secondary-care spinal triage for chronic low back pain (>3 months).
  • Validation Group (Genodisc): An additional 756 symptomatic females used to confirm the trends observed in the primary symptomatic group.

Annotation and Grading

SpineNet re-annotated all sagittal T2-weighted MRIs using standardized metrics:

  • Disc Degeneration: Graded on the Pfirrmann scale (1–5, where 5 represents severe degeneration).
  • Binary Features: Presence or absence of disc herniation, central canal stenosis, marrow signs (Modic changes), and endplate defects.
  • Spatial Stratification: Data were analyzed separately for the upper lumbar spine (L1–L3) and the lower lumbar spine (L4–S1).

Key Insights

The Importance of Spinal Level and Age

The study reveals that the correlation between structural degeneration and pain is highly dependent on the specific spinal level. In the upper lumbar spine (L1–L3), the prevalence of features like herniation and stenosis was low and statistically similar between pained and pain-free individuals. However, in the lower lumbar spine (L4–S1), the differences were stark. For subjects under 50, severe disc degeneration (Pfirrmann grades 4 and 5) was three to four times more prevalent in symptomatic patients than in the asymptomatic cohort.

Vindicating the Clinical Use of MRI

The findings challenge the idea that "everyone has degenerate discs." While mild degeneration is common with age, severe structural defects are significantly more frequent in those suffering from chronic pain. For example, in the 40–49 age bracket, approximately 30% of symptomatic lower lumbar discs showed herniation, compared to only 9% in the asymptomatic group. Similarly, marrow changes were present in 32% of symptomatic discs versus 11% of asymptomatic ones.

The "Clean MRI" Phenotype

One of the most significant findings was that 30% of younger symptomatic patients (<50 years) exhibited minimal to no disc degeneration and zero identified structural features. This suggests that chronic low back pain is not a monolithic condition. Instead, it likely comprises at least two distinct categories: one driven by mechanical/structural failure and another driven by non-structural factors, such as chemical inflammation, psychosocial influences, or augmented central pain processing.

Discussion and Clinical Impact

By providing definitive data on age-related degeneration, this study demonstrates that MRI can be a powerful tool for clinical stratification. Rather than dismissing scans as non-specific, clinicians can use them to differentiate between patients with clear structural pathology and those whose pain may stem from other pathways.

Limitations

The study's focus on a female-only cohort may limit its generalizability to men. Additionally, the symptomatic patients were drawn from secondary care, potentially representing a more severe subset of the population. The use of supine (lying down) MRIs also means that load-induced structural failures, which might only appear when a patient is standing, were not captured.

Future Directions

Automated MRI analysis provides a pathway for more personalized medicine in back pain treatment. Future research could incorporate axially loaded (standing) MRIs to further investigate the 30% of patients with "clean" scans. By stratifying patients based on objective imaging data, researchers can better target treatments and investigate the underlying mechanisms of pain in both structural and non-structural cases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Objectives We aimed to improve understanding of the role of imaging in diagnosis of low back pain by determining the prevalence of age-related disc degeneration in asymptomatic and symptomatic subjects. Spinal MRIs of symptomatic and asymptomatic subjects were re-annotated onto the same objective grading system and prevalence of degenerative changes compared. Methods In an exploratory cross-sectional study, we compared the prevalence of disc degeneration between two large groups of anonymised females, 30-80yrs, viz a symptomatic group with chronic back pain (724) and an asymptomatic (701) group. We used a verified automated MRI annotation system to re-annotate their spinal MRIs and report degeneration on the Pfirrmann (1-5) scale, and other degenerative changes (herniation, endplate defects, marrow signs, spinal stenosis) as binary present/absent. Results Severe degenerative changes were significantly more prevalent in discs of symptomatics than asymptomatics in the lower (L4-S1) but not the upper (L1-L3) lumbar discs in subjects &lt;60years. We found high co-existence of several degenerative features in both populations. Degeneration was minimal in around 30% of symptomatics &lt; 50years. Conclusions Automated MRI provides a valuable means of rapidly comparing large MRI datasets. Here, through directly comparing MRI annotations on the same objective scales it enabled us to detect significant age and spinal-level related differences in the prevalence of degenerative features between asymptomatic and symptomatic populations. By distinguishing between symptomatics whose discs have structural defects, and symptomatics with minimal degenerative changes, MRI could provide a means of clinical stratification, and provide a useful pathway to investigate possible pain sources. Key messages What is already known about this subject? Even though intervertebral disc degeneration, and degenerative changes such as disc herniations, are strongly associated with low back pain, the importance of disc degeneration in development of low back pain is questioned because these degenerative changes are seen in both those with and those without low back pain; spinal MRIs are thus thought to be of little clinical value. What does this study add? The study provides the first data on age-related degeneration in those without pain and shows the significant differences in prevalence between age-related and symptom-related disc degeneration. The study provides definitive data showing that severe disc degeneration is directly implicated in a significant proportion of those with chronic low back pain, with the association with pain strongly dependent on age and spinal level How might this impact on clinical practice or future developments? The study shows that even though severe disc degeneration is strongly associated with low back pain, 30% of younger (&lt;50yrs) chronic low back pain patients have no evident disc degeneration detected by MRI, which is important information (currently not used) for clinicians in directing treatments (and perhaps a clearer reason for the proper use of scans). The study provides important information for those working on mechanisms, as it enables stratification between pathways of pain arising from structural defects in the disc, and those pain pathways in discs with no such structural change.
BibTeX
@misc{jamaludin2021age,
  author = {Amir Jamaludin and Timor Kadir and Andrew Zisserman and Iain W. McCall and Frances M. K. Williams and H. Lang and E Buchanan and J Urban and Jeremy Fairbank},
  title = {{Age and disc degeneration in low back pain: automated analysis enables a magnetic resonance imaging comparison of large cross-sectional cohorts of symptomatic and asymptomatic subjects}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.11.08.21265571},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure