ISSLS PRIZE in Clinical Science 2023: comparison of degenerative MRI features of the intervertebral disc between those with and without chronic low back pain. An exploratory study of two large female populations using automated annotation

Amir Jamaludin, Timor Kadir, Andrew Zisserman, Iain W. McCall, Frances M. K. Williams, H. Lang, E Buchanan, J Urban, Jeremy FairbankEuropean 2023 · DOI

Abstract: Diagnostic: individual cross-sectional studies with consistently applied reference standard and blinding.

Introduction

The "MRI paradox" has long challenged spinal medicine: the frequent lack of correlation between radiological findings and clinical symptoms. Many individuals with severe disc degeneration remain asymptomatic, while others with debilitating chronic low back pain (cLBP) present with "normal" scans. This discrepancy is often attributed to the heterogeneity of study designs, subjective radiologist interpretations, and varying definitions of pain. This study, awarded the 2023 ISSLS Prize in Clinical Science, sought to address these issues by using an automated, standardized approach to analyze large-scale MRI data across three distinct cohorts.

Methods

The researchers employed SpineNet, a validated deep-learning system, to perform automated annotation of lumbar MRIs. This tool standardized the analysis by re-grading all discs using the Pfirrmann scale (1–5) and identifying binary features such as herniation, central canal stenosis, Modic changes, and endplate defects. By removing human subjectivity, the team could reliably compare "big data" across different populations.

The study focused exclusively on female populations to avoid sex bias, utilizing three datasets:

  1. Genodisc: 874 symptomatic cLBP patients from six EU countries.
  2. OSCLMRIC: 763 symptomatic cLBP patients from a UK triage service.
  3. TwinsUK: 701 asymptomatic subjects (no back pain in the previous 3 months) serving as the control group.

Results: Anatomical Specificity and the Age Factor

A primary finding was the anatomical concentration of symptomatic changes. Significant differences in Pfirrmann grading between symptomatic and asymptomatic groups were almost exclusively found in the caudal (lower) lumbar discs (L4/L5 and L5/S1).

Comparison of caudal disc degeneration between symptomatic and asymptomatic groups.

In contrast, the rostral (upper) lumbar discs (L1/2 and L2/3) showed nearly identical degenerative patterns across both symptomatic and asymptomatic groups. This suggests that upper lumbar degeneration may be a more general feature of aging rather than a specific driver of chronic pain.

Comparison of rostral disc degeneration between symptomatic and asymptomatic groups.

The study also highlighted the strong influence of age. While severe degeneration (Pfirrmann 4–5) was a strong predictor of pain in younger subjects—with an Odds Ratio greater than 3.0 for those under 50—the "imaging gap" narrowed significantly in older populations as degenerative changes became nearly universal by age 70.

The "Clean Scan" Mystery

Despite the correlations found, approximately 30% of symptomatic patients under age 50 had minimal or no identifiable degenerative features on MRI. This suggests that for a large subset of patients, the source of pain is either invisible to standard T2 MRI or is driven by non-structural factors such as neuroplasticity or psychosocial influences.

Conclusion

By leveraging AI for standardized annotation, this study clarifies that while disc degeneration is ubiquitous with age, its clinical significance is highly dependent on anatomical location. The findings underscore the importance of focusing on the lower lumbar spine in clinical assessments and suggest that future research should explore advanced imaging sequences to identify the "hidden" causes of pain in patients with structurally normal scans.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diagnostic: individual cross-sectional studies with consistently applied reference standard and blinding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jamaludin2023issls,
  author = {Amir Jamaludin and Timor Kadir and Andrew Zisserman and Iain W. McCall and Frances M. K. Williams and H. Lang and E Buchanan and J Urban and Jeremy Fairbank},
  title = {{ISSLS PRIZE in Clinical Science 2023: comparison of degenerative MRI features of the intervertebral disc between those with and without chronic low back pain. An exploratory study of two large female populations using automated annotation}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/s00586-023-07604-9},
}
Figure