Generative Locally Linear Embedding

Benyamin Ghojogh, Ali Ghodsi, Fakhri Karray, Mark CrowleyarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

Abstract

Locally Linear Embedding (LLE) is a nonlinear spectral dimensionality reduction and manifold learning method. It has two main steps which are linear reconstruction and linear embedding of points in the input space and embedding space, respectively. In this work, we propose two novel generative versions of LLE, named Generative LLE (GLLE), whose linear reconstruction steps are stochastic rather than deterministic. GLLE assumes that every data point is caused by its linear reconstruction weights as latent factors. The proposed GLLE algorithms can generate various LLE embeddings stochastically while all the generated embeddings relate to the original LLE embedding. We propose two versions for stochastic linear reconstruction, one using expectation maximization and another with direct sampling from a derived distribution by optimization. The proposed GLLE methods are closely related to and inspired by variational inference, factor analysis, and probabilistic principal component analysis. Our simulations show that the proposed GLLE methods work effectively in unfolding and generating submanifolds of data.

Introduction

Locally Linear Embedding (LLE) is a fundamental technique in manifold learning, designed to "unroll" high-dimensional data into a lower-dimensional space while preserving local neighborhood structures. Traditionally, LLE is a deterministic algorithm: for a given input, it produces a single, fixed embedding. However, this deterministic nature fails to account for the inherent uncertainty in the reconstruction process and does not allow for the exploration of manifold variations.

Generative Locally Linear Embedding (GLLE) addresses this by reformulating LLE within a probabilistic framework. By bridging spectral methods with generative models like Factor Analysis and Variational Inference, GLLE enables the stochastic generation of multiple valid manifold embeddings, providing a richer perspective on the underlying data structure.

Methodology

The primary innovation of GLLE is the introduction of a stochastic linear reconstruction step. Instead of calculating deterministic weights, GLLE treats reconstruction weights as latent factors in a probabilistic graphical model.

Probabilistic graphical model for GLLE where weights $w_i$ are latent factors causing data points $x_i$.

The authors propose two implementations:

  1. GLLE with Expectation-Maximization (EM): This approach models each data point as being "caused" by its weights. It employs the EM algorithm to estimate the Maximum Likelihood of the weight distributions, utilizing a diagonal covariance matrix relaxation to maintain computational tractability.
  2. GLLE with Direct Sampling: A more efficient alternative that initializes a distribution based on standard LLE results. It optimizes for reconstruction error in both input and embedding spaces simultaneously, then samples weights directly from the resulting Gaussian distribution.

Following the sampling of stochastic weights, the final embedding is obtained by solving a standard LLE eigenvalue problem.

Experimental Setup

The performance of GLLE was evaluated on four classic 3D synthetic manifolds, each consisting of 5,000 points: the S-curve, the Swiss roll, a Swiss roll with a hole (to test handling of discontinuities), and a severed bowl. These datasets provide standard benchmarks for assessing a model's ability to unfold complex nonlinear structures.

Results and Discussion

Both GLLE variants successfully unfolded the test manifolds with high precision. A key finding is the "generative" nature of the model; by sampling from the weight distributions, GLLE produces a "cloud" of related embeddings.

Stochastic embeddings generated by GLLE across different covariance scaling parameters.

The experiments demonstrated that:

  • Stochasticity provides insight: Multiple generated embeddings reveal which regions of a manifold are stable and which are more ambiguous.
  • Interpretability: The EM-based version often produced "narrower" embeddings, which can be more interpretable by highlighting the most informative manifold directions.
  • Robustness: The algorithm remains effective even when the variance of sampled weights is scaled, maintaining the core topological structure.

Conclusion

GLLE successfully transforms LLE into a generative tool, offering a theoretically grounded way to explore uncertainty in manifold learning. While more computationally intensive than standard LLE and currently tested primarily on synthetic data, it opens new avenues for applying probabilistic inference to spectral dimensionality reduction. Future work will focus on scaling these methods to high-dimensional real-world datasets and further optimizing parameter selection.

Summary updated

Abstract

Locally Linear Embedding (LLE) is a nonlinear spectral dimensionality reduction and manifold learning method. It has two main steps which are linear reconstruction and linear embedding of points in the input space and embedding space, respectively. In this work, we propose two novel generative versions of LLE, named Generative LLE (GLLE), whose linear reconstruction steps are stochastic rather than deterministic. GLLE assumes that every data point is caused by its linear reconstruction weights as latent factors. The proposed GLLE algorithms can generate various LLE embeddings stochastically while all the generated embeddings relate to the original LLE embedding. We propose two versions for stochastic linear reconstruction, one using expectation maximization and another with direct sampling from a derived distribution by optimization. The proposed GLLE methods are closely related to and inspired by variational inference, factor analysis, and probabilistic principal component analysis. Our simulations show that the proposed GLLE methods work effectively in unfolding and generating submanifolds of data.
BibTeX
@misc{ghojogh2021generative,
  author = {Benyamin Ghojogh and Ali Ghodsi and Fakhri Karray and Mark Crowley},
  title = {{Generative Locally Linear Embedding}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2104.01525},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.01525},
}
Figure