Generating Extractive Summaries of Scientific Paradigms

Vahed Qazvinian, Dragomir R. Radev, Saif Mohammad, Bonnie J. Dorr, David M. Zajic, Michael Whidby, Taesun Moon

TL;DR

This paper introduces C-LexRank, a novel method for automatically generating extractive summaries of scientific articles by leveraging citation sentences. It demonstrates that citation sentences contain unique, valuable information not always present in abstracts or full papers, and that C-LexRank outperforms other methods in capturing diverse contributions for more comprehensive summaries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's rapidly expanding scientific landscape, researchers face the daunting task of keeping up with vast amounts of technical literature. This challenge is amplified by the increasing need for cross-disciplinary understanding. Traditional summarization methods often rely on abstracts or full papers, but this paper argues that citation sentences—the text where one paper references another—hold crucial, often overlooked, information about a paper's contributions. The authors aim to harness this citation-based information to create more effective and informative technical summaries.

Methods

The core of this work is the C-LexRank algorithm. It operates in three main steps:

  1. Citation Summary Network Construction: The system models a set of sentences that cite a specific paper as a network. Each sentence is a vertex, and edges represent the semantic relatedness between sentences, quantified by cosine similarity using TF-IDF vectors.
  2. Community Structure Detection: C-LexRank exploits the "small-world" property of these citation networks. It uses a modularity-based clustering algorithm (Clauset, Newman, & Moore, 2004) to identify communities of sentences that discuss similar contributions (factoids) of the cited paper.
  3. Salient Vertex Extraction (Ranking): Within each detected community, C-LexRank uses LexRank (Erkan & Radev, 2004) to assign salience scores to sentences. The algorithm then selects sentences from different communities, prioritizing those from larger communities first, to ensure a diverse coverage of the paper's contributions. This approach aims to capture different "factoids" or key contributions.

The paper also compares C-LexRank against several baseline methods, including:

  • Random: Sentences are chosen randomly.
  • LexRank: A standard graph-based summarization method applied to the entire citation network without community detection.
  • MMR (Maximal Marginal Relevance): A diversity-focused greedy algorithm.
  • DivRank: A state-of-the-art graph-based method leveraging diversity.
  • MASCS (Multiple Alternate Sentence Compression Summarizer): A system that uses sentence compression.
  • C-RR: A variant of C-LexRank that selects sentences randomly from clusters instead of using salience scores.

Datasets

The study utilizes several datasets:

  • ACL Anthology Network (AAN): A corpus of over 18,000 papers from the Computational Linguistics community.
  • Specific NLP Topics: Six sets of papers were extracted from AAN, each focusing on a different NLP topic (Dependency Parsing, Phrase-based Machine Translation, Text Summarization, Question Answering, Textual Entailment, and Conditional Random Fields). For each topic, the 5 highest-cited papers were selected.
  • Question Answering (QA) and Dependency Parsing (DP) Datasets: Two specific sets of papers were compiled: 10 papers for QA and 16 for DP. Citation sentences and abstracts for these papers were also collected.
  • Gold Standard Data: Manually created gold standard data was developed for the QA and DP datasets, including:
  • Nugget Annotations: Three annotators identified important "factoids" or contributions from citation sentences and abstracts.
  • Expert Summaries: Four NLP researchers wrote 250-word summaries for QA and DP datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Citations as a Rich Source: The most significant insight is that citation sentences contain unique information that is crucial for technical summarization and is often not present or easily extractable from abstracts or the full papers themselves.
  • Complementary Perspectives: Abstracts offer an author-centric view, while citations provide an external, community-validated perspective on a paper's contributions. Combining these offers a more balanced and comprehensive understanding.
  • Community Structure for Diversity: The paper highlights the effectiveness of community detection in citation networks. Clustering sentences that discuss similar contributions allows for the selection of diverse sentences, leading to more comprehensive summaries that cover a wider range of a paper's impact.
  • Salience within Communities Matters: The comparison between C-LexRank and C-RR (random selection from clusters) demonstrates that using LexRank to identify salient sentences within each community is crucial for generating high-quality summaries.

Key Results

  • C-LexRank Performance: C-LexRank consistently outperformed other methods, including diversity-focused ones like MMR and DivRank, as well as LexRank, in generating summaries with higher pyramid scores for both 100- and 200-word summaries.
  • Citation vs. Abstract vs. Full Paper: Evaluation using pyramid scores showed that summaries generated from citation sentences often outperformed those from abstracts and full papers, especially when evaluated against citation nuggets. Conversely, abstract-based summaries performed better when evaluated against abstract nuggets. This reinforces the idea of unique, summary-amenable information in each source.
  • MASCS Strengths: MASCS, a system employing sentence compression, performed best in some specific ROUGE evaluations, suggesting its effectiveness in capturing overlapping information, though C-LexRank and LexRank were better at producing unigrams and bigrams expected in a summary.
  • Inter-Annotator Agreement: The study found substantial agreement between human annotators when identifying contributions (factoids) using trigram nuggets, indicating the task's feasibility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fluency: The paper acknowledges that current work focuses on extracting diverse factoid-rich summaries, but the fluency of the produced summaries has been largely ignored.
  • Redundancy Detection: The authors plan to address redundancy detection as an integral component of future work, given the overlapping content between abstracts and citation sentences.
  • Combining Sources: Future work aims to generate summaries using both citation sentences and abstracts together as input.
  • Post-processing: The authors intend to employ post-processing techniques like reference scope extraction and sentence simplification to enhance readability and cohesiveness.
  • Visualization: Combining summarization and bibliometric techniques with visualization methods is proposed for creating iterative technical survey tools.
  • User Feedback: Incorporating user feedback is also a planned direction to improve summary generation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Researchers and scientists increasingly find themselves in the position of having to quickly understand large amounts of technical material. Our goal is to effectively serve this need by using bibliometric text mining and summarization techniques to generate summaries of scientific literature. We show how we can use citations to produce automatically generated, readily consumable, technical extractive summaries. We first propose C-LexRank, a model for summarizing single scientific articles based on citations, which employs community detection and extracts salient information-rich sentences. Next, we further extend our experiments to summarize a set of papers, which cover the same scientific topic. We generate extractive summaries of a set of Question Answering (QA) and Dependency Parsing (DP) papers, their abstracts, and their citation sentences and show that citations have unique information amenable to creating a summary.
BibTeX
@article{qazvinian2013generating,
  author = {Vahed Qazvinian and Dragomir R. Radev and Saif Mohammad and Bonnie J. Dorr and David M. Zajic and Michael Whidby and Taesun Moon},
  title = {{Generating Extractive Summaries of Scientific Paradigms}},
  journal = {J. Artif. Intell. Res.},
  year = {2013},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=yXN5pVjEuI3},
}
Figure