GamePad: A Learning Environment for Theorem Proving

Daniel Huang, Prafulla Dhariwal, Dawn Song, Ilya Sutskever

Theorem proving is considered a "grand challenge" for artificial intelligence because it demands a combination of rigorous symbolic reasoning and high-level mathematical intuition. While Automated Theorem Provers (ATPs) excel at brute-force logic, they often struggle with the complex, multi-step proofs required in advanced mathematics or software verification.

To address this, researchers introduced GamePad, a framework designed to bridge the gap between machine learning and formal logic by providing a Python-based learning environment for the Coq theorem prover. By offering structured access to human-constructed proofs, GamePad enables models to learn "mathematical intuition" for tasks like predicting the next proof step or estimating how close a proof is to completion.

The Challenge of Interactive Theorem Proving

Interactive Theorem Provers (ITPs) like Coq allow humans to guide the proof process using "tactics"—commands that transform the current goal into simpler sub-goals. However, applying machine learning to automate these tactics has historically been difficult due to three main hurdles:

  1. Data Access: Extracting clean, structured data from ITPs requires heavy engineering.
  2. Representation: Mathematical terms are not simple text sequences; they are Abstract Syntax Trees (ASTs) that involve complex rules like variable renaming (alpha-equivalence).
  3. Scale: Real-world proofs involve thousands of intermediate states and massive expression trees that can easily overwhelm standard neural networks.
A Coq proof and its corresponding proof tree representation in GamePad.

The GamePad Environment and Methods

To overcome these challenges, the authors developed GamePad by patching the Coq interpreter to log every intermediate proof state and exposing a Python API for interaction.

Key technical innovations in GamePad include:

  • Structured Embeddings: Instead of treating mathematical expressions as flat text, the system uses Recursive Neural Networks (TreeLSTMs and GRUs) to process the ASTs of mathematical terms.
  • Interpreter-Inspired Embeddings: To handle the fact that variable names are arbitrary (e.g., $x+y$ is structurally identical to $a+b$), the authors introduced a novel technique. When the model encounters a bound variable, it samples a random vector to represent it. This ensures the model learns the structure of the binding rather than memorizing specific variable names.
  • Engineering Optimizations: To handle proofs with thousands of nodes, the team implemented embedding sharing (memoizing the representation of sub-expressions) and dynamic batching. These optimizations were critical for scaling to real-world datasets.

Datasets and Key Insights

The paper evaluates GamePad on two distinct datasets:

  1. Algebraic Rewrites: A synthetic "toy" dataset of 400 unique theorems involving basic algebraic simplifications (e.g., $b \oplus (e \oplus m) = b$), used to test end-to-end proof synthesis.
  2. Feit-Thompson Theorem: A massive, real-world formalization of a landmark result in group theory containing 1,602 lemmas and over 83,000 proof states. This represents the "gold standard" of human-written formal mathematics.

Unlike many ATP tasks that operate without human supervision, GamePad focuses on supervised learning from expert-constructed proofs to capture the "style" of human mathematicians. The authors framed the question of "how close are we to finishing?" as a classification task (Close, Medium, Far) called Position Evaluation, which acts as a proxy for a value function in reinforcement learning. They also found that "mid-level" representations—which remove some bookkeeping but keep implicit arguments—are the sweet spot for learning, as they are close enough to human logic to be learnable but formal enough to be machine-checkable.

Key Results

The models were evaluated on their ability to predict the state of the proof and the next logical step.

Model performance on position evaluation (Pos) and tactic prediction (Tac) tasks.
  • Performance: The TreeLSTM model outperformed baselines (SVMs and standard GRUs) on position evaluation, achieving 68.44% accuracy on the complex Feit-Thompson dataset.
  • Tactic Prediction: Models achieved roughly 60% accuracy in predicting the correct next tactic to use.
  • Speedup: The engineering optimizations (embedding sharing and dynamic batching) proved mandatory, providing a staggering 190x speedup on GPUs compared to unoptimized baselines when processing large proof trees.
  • Synthesis: On the algebraic rewrite problem, the model successfully synthesized 14 out of 50 complete proofs using a simple greedy search, demonstrating that the learned models can actively "drive" the prover.

Limitations and Future Work

While GamePad represents a significant step forward, challenges remain. Although models were good at picking the type of tactic (e.g., "rewrite"), they struggled to predict the specific arguments for that tactic (e.g., "rewrite using this specific hypothesis"), with recall hovering around 25%. Furthermore, the models currently cannot handle the have tactic, which requires a human to conjecture a brand-new intermediate lemma—a task requiring significant creative insight.

The current work relies on greedy search for proof synthesis. The authors suggest that future work should integrate GamePad with Monte-Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) or Reinforcement Learning to explore the proof space more effectively.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we introduce a system called GamePad that can be used to explore the application of machine learning methods to theorem proving in the Coq proof assistant. Interactive theorem provers such as Coq enable users to construct machine-checkable proofs in a step-by-step manner. Hence, they provide an opportunity to explore theorem proving with human supervision. We use GamePad to synthesize proofs for a simple algebraic rewrite problem and train baseline models for a formalization of the Feit-Thompson theorem. We address position evaluation (i.e., predict the number of proof steps left) and tactic prediction (i.e., predict the next proof step) tasks, which arise naturally in tactic-based theorem proving.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2019gamepad,
  author = {Daniel Huang and Prafulla Dhariwal and Dawn Song and Ilya Sutskever},
  title = {{GamePad: A Learning Environment for Theorem Proving}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Learning Representations},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=k2aHUXosFpY},
}
Figure