Frequency Shifts and Depth Dependence of Premotor Beta Band Activity during Perceptual Decision-Making

Chandramouli Chandrasekaran, Iliana E. Bray, Krishna V. Shenoy

Abstract

Neural activity in the premotor and motor cortices shows prominent structure in the beta frequency range (13-30 Hz). Currently, the behavioral relevance of this beta band activity (BBA) is debated. The underlying source of motor BBA and how it changes as a function of cortical depth are also not completely understood. Here, we addressed these unresolved questions by investigating BBA recorded using laminar electrodes in the dorsal premotor cortex of 2 male rhesus macaques performing a visual reaction time (RT) reach discrimination task. We observed robust BBA before and after the onset of the visual stimulus but not during the arm movement. While poststimulus BBA was positively correlated with RT throughout the beta frequency range, prestimulus correlation varied by frequency. Low beta frequencies (∼12-20 Hz) were positively correlated with RT, and high beta frequencies (∼22-30 Hz) were negatively correlated with RT. Analysis and simulations suggested that these frequency-dependent correlations could emerge due to a shift in the component frequencies of the prestimulus BBA as a function of RT, such that faster RTs are accompanied by greater power in high beta frequencies. We also observed a laminar dependence of BBA, with deeper electrodes demonstrating stronger power in low beta frequencies both prestimulus and poststimulus. The heterogeneous nature of BBA and the changing relationship between BBA and RT in different task epochs may be a sign of the differential network dynamics involved in cue expectation, decision-making, motor preparation, and movement execution.

Introduction: The Beta Band Debate

For decades, neuroscientists have observed prominent oscillations in the "beta" range (13–30 Hz) within the motor and premotor cortices. However, the functional role of this Beta Band Activity (BBA) remains a subject of intense debate. Is it a "clear to send" signal for movement, a marker of active suppression (holding still), or a reflection of attentional state?

Figure 1: Three hypotheses regarding the relationship between beta band activity (BBA) and reaction time (RT).

Furthermore, the physical origin of these signals within the cortical column is unclear. Most studies treat the beta band as a uniform block of activity, but this research investigates whether BBA is actually composed of heterogeneous sub-components that relate differently to behavior and reside in different layers of the brain.

Methods and Experimental Paradigm

The researchers recorded neural activity from the dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) of two rhesus macaques while they performed a visual reaction time (RT) reach discrimination task.

Figure 5: The visual reaction time reach discrimination task paradigm, highlighting the pre-stimulus and post-stimulus epochs.

Key technical aspects included:

  • Laminar Recording: 16-channel "U-probes" were used to record Local Field Potentials (LFPs) simultaneously across different cortical layers (surface to ~2.4 mm).
  • Spectral Analysis: Multitaper power spectra and wavelet analysis resolved changes in beta power over time and frequency.
  • Correlation Modeling: Partial Spearman correlations linked BBA power to reaction times while controlling for visual stimulus difficulty (coherence).
  • Simulations: Synthetic LFP signals tested whether observed correlations were due to power changes or a shift in the signal's center frequency.

Key Insights

Beta is Not Monolithic

The study's most significant finding is that BBA behaves differently depending on the specific frequency. In the "prestimulus" phase (before the cue appears), low beta (12–20 Hz) and high beta (22–30 Hz) have opposite relationships with reaction time.

The Frequency Shift Hypothesis

Rather than just having "more" or "less" beta, the brain seems to shift the peak of the beta oscillation. Faster reaction times were associated with a shift toward higher frequencies.

Laminar Specialization

Beta power is not uniform across the cortex. Deeper electrodes (corresponding to Layer V) showed significantly stronger power in the low beta range compared to superficial layers. This suggests that different layers might be responsible for different "flavors" of beta.

Ruling out "Postural Holding"

Because BBA correlated with reaction times even during periods where the monkeys were already holding still, the authors could rule out the hypothesis that beta is simply a byproduct of maintaining a physical posture.

Key Results

  • Prestimulus Correlations: Low beta power was positively correlated with RT (more power = slower reach), while high beta power was negatively correlated with RT (more power = faster reach).
  • Poststimulus Uniformity: Once the stimulus appeared, the relationship changed; power across the entire beta range became positively correlated with RT.
  • Depth Dependence: Deeper cortical layers exhibited significantly higher power in the 10–20 Hz range compared to superficial layers ($p < 6.8 \times 10^{-16}$).
  • Peak Frequency Shift: Faster RT trials had a median peak frequency approximately 0.57 Hz higher than slower trials ($p = 0.001$).

Limitations and Future Directions

While LFP provides a population-level view, it is a spatially averaged signal. Future work should integrate single-unit spiking data to see how individual neurons contribute to these laminar beta shifts.

Additionally, this study is correlational. To prove causality, future research would need to use tools like optogenetics or electrical microstimulation to artificially shift the beta frequency and observe the impact on reaction time. Finally, the authors suggest that "beta" might be better understood as a series of transient "bursts" rather than a sustained oscillation, requiring single-trial analysis methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neural activity in the premotor and motor cortices shows prominent structure in the beta frequency range (13-30 Hz). Currently, the behavioral relevance of this beta band activity (BBA) is debated. The underlying source of motor BBA and how it changes as a function of cortical depth are also not completely understood. Here, we addressed these unresolved questions by investigating BBA recorded using laminar electrodes in the dorsal premotor cortex of 2 male rhesus macaques performing a visual reaction time (RT) reach discrimination task. We observed robust BBA before and after the onset of the visual stimulus but not during the arm movement. While poststimulus BBA was positively correlated with RT throughout the beta frequency range, prestimulus correlation varied by frequency. Low beta frequencies (∼12-20 Hz) were positively correlated with RT, and high beta frequencies (∼22-30 Hz) were negatively correlated with RT. Analysis and simulations suggested that these frequency-dependent correlations could emerge due to a shift in the component frequencies of the prestimulus BBA as a function of RT, such that faster RTs are accompanied by greater power in high beta frequencies. We also observed a laminar dependence of BBA, with deeper electrodes demonstrating stronger power in low beta frequencies both prestimulus and poststimulus. The heterogeneous nature of BBA and the changing relationship between BBA and RT in different task epochs may be a sign of the differential network dynamics involved in cue expectation, decision-making, motor preparation, and movement execution.<b>SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT</b> Beta band activity (BBA) has been implicated in motor tasks, in disease states, and as a potential signal for brain-machine interfaces. However, the behavioral relevance of BBA and its laminar organization in premotor cortex have not been completely elucidated. Here we addressed these unresolved issues using simultaneous recordings from multiple cortical layers of the premotor cortex of monkeys performing a decision-making task. Our key finding is that BBA is not a monolithic signal. Instead, BBA consists of at least two frequency bands. The relationship between BBA and eventual behavior, such as reaction time, also dynamically changes depending on task epoch. We also provide further evidence that BBA is laminarly organized, with greater power in deeper electrodes for low beta frequencies.
BibTeX
@article{chandrasekaran2019frequency,
  author = {Chandramouli Chandrasekaran and Iliana E. Bray and Krishna V. Shenoy},
  title = {{Frequency Shifts and Depth Dependence of Premotor Beta Band Activity during Perceptual Decision-Making}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.1066-18.2018},
}
Figure