Laminar differences in decision-related neural activity in dorsal premotor cortex

Chandramouli Chandrasekaran, Diogo Peixoto, William T. Newsome, Krishna V. ShenoyNature Communications 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) is a critical hub for somatomotor decision-making. While its general role is established, the internal laminar organization of decision-related signals has remained unclear. This study investigates the temporal dynamics and spatial distribution of neural activity across PMd layers in macaques performing a color discrimination task. We identify a functional continuum of neurons: "Increased" neurons, primarily in superficial layers, exhibit activity patterns consistent with evidence accumulation (decision variables). In contrast, "Decreased" and "Perimovement" neurons, more prevalent in deeper layers, are associated with action execution. These findings reveal a laminar hierarchy where decision-related processing in superficial layers precedes motor-related signals in deeper layers.

Introduction

When faced with a choice—such as deciding whether to brake or accelerate at a traffic light—the brain must transform sensory evidence into a motor plan. The dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) is central to this "somatomotor decision" process. However, the cortex is not a uniform block; it is organized into distinct layers (laminae) with specific input-output profiles. Understanding how decision-making labor is divided among these layers is essential for mapping the brain's computational architecture.

Methods and Experimental Design

Researchers recorded neural activity from two rhesus macaques (Monkeys T and O) using linear multi-contact electrodes (U-probes). These 16-channel probes allowed for simultaneous recording across the cortical depth of the PMd, providing a vertical slice of activity.

The monkeys performed a visual discrimination task where they viewed a checkerboard of red and green squares and were required to reach for a target matching the dominant color. The difficulty was varied by changing the "color coherence" (the ratio of red to green squares).

Overview of the experimental task, behavioral metrics, and laminar recording setup in the PMd.

The team categorized neurons based on a "Visuomotor Continuum Index," which measured how firing rates correlated with reaction times (RT). They also employed Drift Diffusion Models (DDM) and Urgency Gating Models (UGM) to link behavioral metrics (speed and accuracy) to neural firing patterns.

Key Insights: The Laminar "Layer Cake"

The study revealed that PMd neurons are organized along a functional spectrum rather than being a homogeneous population.

1. The Visuomotor Spectrum

Neurons in the PMd exist on a bidirectional continuum.

  • Increased Neurons (51.6%): These cells ramp up their firing rates ~150 ms after stimulus onset. Their activity levels correlate with choice, stimulus difficulty, and reaction time—the hallmarks of a "decision variable."
  • Decreased Neurons (14.15%): These cells reduce their firing rates after the stimulus appears.
  • Perimovement Neurons (34.25%): These cells remain quiet during the decision phase and only fire ~150 ms before the physical reach begins.

2. Anatomical Distribution

A striking finding was the physical segregation of these functional types. "Increased" neurons (the "thinkers") were significantly more concentrated in the superficial layers (Layers 2/3). Conversely, "Decreased" and "Perimovement" neurons (the "doers") were found more frequently in the deeper layers (Layers 5/6). A cubic regression showed a strong relationship ($R^2 = 0.87$) between cortical depth and the visuomotor index.

3. Temporal Flow

Information does not appear everywhere at once. Choice-related signals emerged in the superficial layers approximately 15.5 ms earlier than in the deep layers. This suggests a top-down flow of information within the PMd, where the decision is formed in superficial layers before being passed to deeper layers for execution.

Results and Behavioral Correlation

The behavioral data, comprising over 237,000 trials, confirmed that the monkeys' performance was highly sensitive to stimulus difficulty. Psychometric curves showed that accuracy improved as color coherence increased.

Psychometric curves demonstrating the monkeys' choice behavior as a function of stimulus difficulty.

Neural population decoding further supported the laminar difference: the "discrimination time" (the point at which a choice can be predicted from neural activity) was consistently shorter in the superficial layers compared to the deep layers.

Discussion and Limitations

This research provides a clear anatomical framework for PMd function. It suggests that superficial layers integrate sensory evidence to reach a decision, while deeper layers manage the transition to motor output.

However, the study is primarily correlational. While the timing suggests a superficial-to-deep flow, further research using causal interventions (like optogenetics) is needed to prove that superficial activity drives deep-layer responses. Additionally, the specific role of "Decreased" neurons—perhaps acting as a "brake" on movement until the decision is finalized—remains an intriguing area for future study.

Conclusion

By mapping the functional properties of neurons to their physical location in the cortical layers, this study moves us closer to a circuit-level understanding of how the brain makes choices. The PMd is not just a motor area; it is a sophisticated, layered processor that bridges the gap between seeing and doing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dorsal premotor cortex is implicated in somatomotor decisions. However, we do not understand the temporal patterns and laminar organization of decision-related firing rates in dorsal premotor cortex. We recorded neurons from dorsal premotor cortex of monkeys performing a visual discrimination task with reaches as the behavioral report. We show that these neurons can be organized along a bidirectional visuomotor continuum based on task-related firing rates. "Increased" neurons at one end of the continuum increased their firing rates ~150 ms after stimulus onset and these firing rates covaried systematically with choice, stimulus difficulty, and reaction time-characteristics of a candidate decision variable. "Decreased" neurons at the other end of the continuum reduced their firing rate after stimulus onset, while "perimovement" neurons at the center of the continuum responded only ~150 ms before movement initiation. These neurons did not show decision variable-like characteristics. "Increased" neurons were more prevalent in superficial layers of dorsal premotor cortex; deeper layers contained more "decreased" and "perimovement" neurons. These results suggest a laminar organization for decision-related responses in dorsal premotor cortex.Dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) is thought to be involved in making somatomotor decisions. Chandrasekaran et al. investigated the temporal response dynamics of PMd neurons across cortical layers and show stronger and earlier decision-related responses in the superficial layers and more action execution-related signals in the deeper layers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chandrasekaran2017laminar,
  author = {Chandramouli Chandrasekaran and Diogo Peixoto and William T. Newsome and Krishna V. Shenoy},
  title = {{Laminar differences in decision-related neural activity in dorsal premotor cortex}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-017-00715-0},
}
Figure