Framing Lifetime Income

Jeffrey R. Brown, Jeffrey R. Kling, Sendhil Mullainathan, Marian V. Wrobel

Abstract

We provide evidence that individuals optimize imperfectly when making annuity decisions, and this result is not driven by loss aversion. Life annuities are more attractive when presented in a consumption frame than in an investment frame. Highlighting the purchase price in the consumption frame does not alter this result. The level of habitual spending has little interaction with preferences for annuities in the consumption frame. In an investment frame, consumers prefer annuities with principal guarantees; this result is similar for guarantee amounts below, at, and above the purchase price. We discuss implications for the retirement services industry and its regulators.

Introduction: The Annuity Puzzle

In standard neoclassical economics, the "Annuity Puzzle" refers to the stark disconnect between theory and reality: while risk-averse individuals should logically convert significant wealth into life annuities to hedge against outliving their savings, voluntary annuitization remains rare. Traditional explanations often assume "revealed preference"—that consumers are optimizing perfectly but find annuities unattractive due to high fees, inflation risk, or a desire to leave bequests.

This research challenges that assumption, investigating whether the puzzle is actually a "Framing Puzzle." By testing the hypothesis of imperfect optimization, the authors explore how the psychological context of the decision—whether viewed as an investment or a consumption tool—dictates consumer choice more than the underlying financial math.

Methodology

The researchers conducted two large-scale internet surveys (Survey 1: n=673; Survey 2: n=3,382) targeting individuals over age 50. Using a "forced-choice" experimental design, respondents compared the financial decisions of two fictitious individuals to determine who made the better choice. Participants were randomly assigned to different frames:

  • Consumption Frame: Focused on "spending" and "payments," emphasizing the monthly money available until death.
  • Investment Frame: Focused on "investing," "earnings," and "returns," emphasizing account balances and estate value.

The study further tested "reference points" to evaluate loss aversion, including the impact of explicitly stating the $100,000 purchase price, introducing habitual spending targets, and offering principal protection guarantees.

Key Findings: The Power of Framing

The results reveal that framing is the dominant factor in annuity preference. When shifted from an investment mindset to a consumption mindset, the annuity transforms from a "risky bet on your life" into "insurance against poverty."

The Framing Gap

In the Investment Frame, only 21% of respondents preferred a life annuity over a traditional savings account. However, in the Consumption Frame, preference skyrocketed to 72%. This dramatic shift suggests that the language of investment—focusing on returns and the risk of "losing" principal upon early death—is what primarily drives consumers away.

Robustness and Reference Points

The preference for annuities in the consumption frame proved remarkably robust:

  • Price Transparency: Explicitly mentioning the $100,000 purchase price (a potential "loss" reference point) only slightly lowered preference to 68%, a statistically insignificant change. This suggests that the investment language itself, rather than just the mention of cost, is the deterrent.
  • Principal Protection: In the investment frame, adding a guarantee to return the initial $100,000 investment (even if it reduced monthly payouts) doubled the preference rate to 47%. Interestingly, the exact amount of the guarantee mattered less than the existence of the protection itself.
  • Habitual Spending: Setting a "habitual" spending level that the annuity could cover ($1,200) increased preference to 80%, though this dropped back to 72% when the target exceeded the annuity's payout.

Discussion and Policy Implications

The findings suggest that the low demand for annuities is not necessarily a rational rejection of the product's value, but a byproduct of how these products are marketed and disclosed. Consumers struggle to translate a lump sum (investment frame) into a sustainable lifetime stream of income (consumption frame).

For the retirement services industry and regulators, the implications are significant. Shifting the focus of retirement planning from "wealth accumulation" to "income security" could improve consumer decision-making. For instance, 401(k) plans might be more effective if they reported balances as "monthly income projections" rather than just total account values. By aligning the presentation of retirement products with a consumption-oriented mindset, policymakers can help individuals better manage the financial risks of longevity.

Summary updated

Abstract

We provide evidence that individuals optimize imperfectly when making annuity decisions, and this result is not driven by loss aversion. Life annuities are more attractive when presented in a consumption frame than in an investment frame. Highlighting the purchase price in the consumption frame does not alter this result. The level of habitual spending has little interaction with preferences for annuities in the consumption frame. In an investment frame, consumers prefer annuities with principal guarantees; this result is similar for guarantee amounts below, at, and above the purchase price. We discuss implications for the retirement services industry and its regulators. We thank Abby Sussman for exceptional research assistance. An earlier draft of this paper, co-authored with Garth Wiens, was circulated under the title “Framing, Reference Points, and Preferences for Life Annuities. ” We are grateful to the Pew Charitable Trusts, MacArthur Foundation, the Mott Foundation, and the TIAA-CREF Research Institute for financial support. The views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as those of any of the organizations that funded this research or with whom the authors are affiliated. Financial disclosure: Jeffrey R. Brown serves as a Trustee for TIAA and has received compensation as a speaker from companies that sell retirement income products
BibTeX
@article{brown2013framing,
  author = {Jeffrey R. Brown and Jeffrey R. Kling and Sendhil Mullainathan and Marian V. Wrobel},
  title = {{Framing Lifetime Income}},
  journal = {The Journal of Retirement},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3905/jor.2013.1.1.027},
}
Figure