Abstract This paper deals with the development of professional skills on the part of trainee teachers carrying out work in the primary classroom on elements of heritage found in nearby landscapes, especially those which provoke conflicting points of view, such as sites associated with the Spanish Civil War. This research is qualitative and interpretive in nature and has made the ethnographic model compatible with the case study on the basis of an incidental sample of primary teachers working collaboratively. The data analysed is mainly taken from teaching practice carried out in the primary classroom, although the trainee teachers' prior experience at university has been taken into account. We have observed that the teachers who assumed and learned to develop a critical model of heritage, incorporating rational and emotional dimensions into the construction of identities, were able to successfully transmit these dimensions to their pupils, who, in turn, developed basic social skills in a successful way.
Introduction
Traditional heritage education has long been criticized for its focus on the "monumental" and the "aesthetic"—the so-called "pretty" history that reinforces a sanitized, pre-determined national identity. This "banal" approach often treats students as passive consumers of culture rather than active participants in society. This research, published in Estudios Pedagógicos, explores an alternative: a counter-hegemonic approach to heritage education that utilizes "uncomfortable" or conflicting local history to foster professional growth in trainee teachers and civic engagement in primary students.
The Problem: Beyond Banal Heritage
The authors identify a significant gap in teacher training: the preparation required to handle "conflicting" landscapes. In many educational settings, heritage is viewed through a consumerist lens—for example, seeing a local beach solely as a recreation spot rather than a site of ecological or historical significance. By avoiding sites associated with political violence, social struggle, or environmental disasters, educators miss the opportunity to build inclusive, democratic identities. The challenge lies in moving toward a "critical model" where heritage is understood as a social construction used to navigate complex modern realities.
Methodology
The study employed a qualitative, interpretive approach, blending ethnographic methods with longitudinal case studies. The researchers followed two cohorts of trainee teachers from the University of Santiago de Compostela (Lugo Campus) during their practicum in rural primary schools in Galicia, Spain.
The research was organized into two distinct phases:
- Block 1 (2013-2015): Focused on local landscapes. Trainee teachers were tasked with identifying sites to show visitors, tracking their evolution from selecting "banal" locations (like shopping malls) to reasoned heritage sites.
- Block 2 (2015-2017): Focused specifically on "conflicting heritage," using a local memorial for victims of the Spanish Civil War as the primary pedagogical tool.
Data was gathered through observation diaries, individual teacher narratives, and student-produced materials, including collaborative Wikis and video-recorded classroom performances.
Key Insights: The Rational-Emotional Balance
A central finding of the study is that heritage does not reside in the object itself, but in the relationship people establish with it. Effective education must facilitate "appropriation"—the process of making history one's own. This requires a delicate balance between rational analysis and emotional empathy.
While purely rational history can feel disconnected, purely emotional history risks becoming sentimental or dangerous. The researchers observed an "aha moment" when students used empathy for historical victims to fuel a rational critique of modern injustices. By questioning dominant, sanitized versions of history, trainee teachers improved their professional competence, learning to manage classroom conflict and navigate institutional resistance—skills the authors argue are essential for modern educators.
Results and Civic Appropriation
The impact on primary students (ages 8-12) was measurable and significant:
- Shift in Values: In the first block, the preference for "consumerist" sites (e.g., malls) dropped from over 90% in initial narratives to less than 50% in final assessments. Conversely, interest in reasoned heritage sites rose from under 25% to approximately 60%.
- Identity Construction: In the second block, students who were initially unaware of a local Civil War memorial eventually "appropriated" it. They moved from ignorance to proposing the memorial as the town's most important landmark because it represented fundamental human rights.
- Engagement through Collaboration: The use of digital Wikis and the creation of a play about the Civil War saw students voluntarily sacrificing recess time to work on their projects, demonstrating high levels of engagement and the development of democratic consensus-building skills.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The study highlights that when teachers adopt a critical model of heritage, they can successfully transmit complex social dimensions to their pupils. However, the researchers also noted significant institutional resistance; some school administrations feared "conflicting" topics, forcing teachers to work in a state of semi-clandestinity.
This highlights a pressing need for systemic support for critical history. The authors suggest that future research should continue to refine how "uncomfortable" history can be used to build democratic citizenship in increasingly polarized societies, with preliminary work already expanding into even more challenging environments, such as prisons.
Summary updated