entorno próximo. Educación patrimonial y memoria histórica en la educación primaria

María Martínez Blanco, Tania Riveiro Rodríguez, Andrés AlmansaClío 2019 · DOI

Abstract

This article presents the results of a case study centered on the implementation of a didactic program in a primary school. The program consisted of two distinct didactic actions during two teacher-training internship periods. The first was conducted with two 6th-grade groups over five sessions, and the second with two 5th-grade groups over four sessions, involving a total of 53 students. The chosen theme was the Spanish Civil War, combining historical knowledge with emotional engagement. Observations from the student teacher and thematic analysis of student interventions and productions demonstrate how the symbiosis between critical heritage education—grounded in memory as a way of understanding the landscape—and contextualized field trips reinforces civic-social skills in students.

Introduction: Moving Beyond the "Monumentalist" Bias

Traditional heritage education in primary schools often suffers from a "monumentalist" bias, focusing strictly on artistic or archaeological value while ignoring the intangible, the local, and the conflictive. History is frequently taught as a detached series of dates and facts, leaving students disconnected from the historical memory of their own communities. This study addresses the gap between theoretical advancements in "critical heritage education" and actual classroom practice, tackling the challenge of teaching sensitive topics like the Spanish Civil War to children aged 10-12. The goal is to move beyond traditional memorization to build "critical citizens" who can relate the past to their present environment.

Methodology

The researchers employed a qualitative case study framework during a teacher-training internship (prácticum) at a school in Galicia, Spain. The intervention involved 53 students and was divided into two phases:

  • Phase 1 (6th Grade): Focused on a local Jesuit College that served as a concentration camp during the Civil War.
  • Phase 2 (5th Grade): Focused on a local monastery that functioned as a prison.

The didactic design was rooted in critical pedagogy, utilizing primary source analysis (such as letters from executed teachers and prisoner graffiti), audiovisual integration (local documentaries and the Nomes e Voces database), and contextualized excursions. These field trips were designed as planned pedagogical tools to "resignify" local spaces rather than mere leisure activities.

The Empathetic Bridge: Primary Sources and Emotional Engagement

A key insight from the study is the role of emotional primary sources as a catalyst for historical thinking. By analyzing poignant documents—such as a farewell letter from a teacher to his mother before his execution—students moved from viewing history as an abstract concept to a lived reality. This "empathetic bridge" prompted deep inquiry, with students asking questions that connected the historical figures to their own lives and their teachers.

Resignifying the Local Landscape

Before the intervention, students often viewed local historical sites as "just old buildings" or playgrounds. Through the program, they "resignified" these spaces as sites of human suffering and historical importance. This shift broke the "tourist gaze," moving focus from aesthetic beauty to "hidden" or "uncomfortable" heritage. The qualitative analysis showed that students who typically struggled with traditional, memorization-based learning became highly active and engaged when the curriculum shifted to inquiry-based, emotional, and local topics.

Results and Civic Impact

The study observed several significant outcomes:

  1. Shift in Perception: Students transitioned from seeing Social Sciences as "boring" to expressing regret when lessons ended.
  2. Critical Inquiry: Students became active researchers, with some even visiting local mass graves with their families outside of school hours.
  3. Civic Competence: Students developed a critical attitude toward the neglect of local heritage, frequently suggesting that memorials or plaques should be installed to ensure the public understands the history of these sites.
  4. Inclusive Participation: The study noted deep engagement across genders, particularly regarding the emotional and historical aspects of the project.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The results evidence that a symbiosis between critical heritage education and contextualized local exploration reinforces civic-social skills. However, the authors note that for this model to succeed on a larger scale, there must be a greater emphasis on "critical heritage" in university teacher-training programs. Future work should explore how this "nearby surrounding" approach can be applied to other "difficult" topics, such as gender violence or labor exploitation, to continue fostering critical citizenship in young learners.

Summary updated

Abstract

Este artículo muestra los resultados de un estudio de caso centrado en la puesta en marcha de un programa didáctico en un centro de primaria. El programa constó de dos actuaciones didácticas distintas en dos períodos de prácticum de magisterio. La primera se realizó con 2 grupos de 6º durante 5 sesiones y la segunda con 2 grupos de 5º durante 4 sesiones. Participaron 53 estudiantes. El tema escogido fue la Guerra Civil. Se combinaron conocimientos y emociones. De las observaciones de la docente en prácticas, así como del análisis temático realizado sobre las intervenciones y producciones del alumnado, se evidencia cómo la simbiosis entre una educación patrimonial crítica, asentada sobre la memoria como forma de entender el paisaje, y la realización de salidas contextualizadas al entorno, refuerzan en el alumnado destrezas cívico-sociales.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{blanco2019entorno,
  author = {María Martínez Blanco and Tania Riveiro Rodríguez and Andrés Almansa},
  title = {{entorno próximo. Educación patrimonial y memoria histórica en la educación primaria}},
  booktitle = {Clío},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.26754/ojs\_clio/clio.2019458653},
}
Figure