Force quantification and simulation of pedicle screw tract palpation using direct visuo-haptic volume rendering

Esther I. Zoller, Balázs Faludi, Nicolas Gerig, Gregory F. Jost, Philippe C. Cattin, Georg Rauter

Abstract

Pedicle screw placement is a critical step in spinal fusion surgery, where misplacement can lead to severe neurological complications. Surgeons rely on "palpation"—using a probe to feel the integrity of the drilled tract—to ensure no breaches have occurred. This study introduces a novel VR simulator that utilizes direct visuo-haptic volume rendering to provide realistic tactile feedback without manual segmentation of CT data. By quantifying the forces applied by neurosurgeons during real-world palpation of boar vertebrae, the authors established a benchmark for simulation accuracy. The resulting system maintains high haptic update rates and captures the subtle tactile cues necessary for surgical training.

Introduction

In spinal fusion surgeries, approximately 5% of pedicle screws are misplaced. To mitigate this risk, surgeons perform palpation, using a ball-tipped probe to detect breaches in the bony walls of the screw tract. Mastering this "tactile signature" typically requires years of clinical experience. While virtual reality (VR) simulators offer a safe training environment, traditional methods often require "segmentation"—the labor-intensive process of converting medical images into 3D meshes. This research addresses the lack of quantitative force data in palpation and proposes a simulation method that operates directly on raw CT data.

Methods and Experimental Setup

The study employed a two-phase methodology to bridge the gap between physical reality and virtual simulation.

Force Quantification

To establish a ground truth, a standard pedicle probe was instrumented with a 6-axis force/torque sensor and motion capture markers. Two neurosurgeons performed palpation on a fresh lumbar spine from a young boar, a common surrogate for human bone due to its structural similarities. This setup allowed for the precise recording of movement patterns and force profiles (N and Nm) at a 100 Hz sampling rate.

Experimental setup for force quantification, featuring an instrumented probe and a boar vertebra specimen.

Direct Visuo-Haptic Volume Rendering

The simulator calculates haptic forces based on the opacity gradient of CT voxels rather than a geometric mesh. When the virtual probe encounters high-density regions (bone), the system generates a resistive force proportional to the density change. To account for instrument flexibility, a cantilever beam model iteratively calculates probe deformation, ensuring visual and tactile consistency.

Key Results

The physical experiments revealed that surgeons utilize distinct motions: a "sweeping" motion for tract walls and a "tapping" motion for the anterior wall. The maximum longitudinal force recorded was 7.78 N, with a maximum bending torque of 0.13 Nm.

Frequency distribution of forces and torques recorded during palpation by two neurosurgeons.

In simulation trials, the system maintained a haptic update rate of 1–1.8 kHz, providing the necessary stiffness for a convincing bone-like feel. While the force distributions in VR mirrored real-world patterns, surgeons tended to be "heavy-handed" in the simulator, applying significantly higher mean forces (e.g., ~1.91 N in VR vs. ~0.31 N in reality). This discrepancy may stem from the high transparency of haptic devices or occasional "snagging" on porous bone structures in the CT data.

Discussion and Future Work

The direct volume rendering approach successfully bypasses the "uncanny valley" of mesh-based collisions, where probes might glitch through thin surfaces. However, limitations remain, such as artificial oscillations when the probe tip interacts with cancellous (porous) bone. Future research will focus on expanding the surgeon cohort, simulating various bone pathologies (e.g., osteoporosis), and integrating real-time voxel removal to simulate the drilling process itself.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a feasibility study for the visuo-haptic simulation of pedicle screw tract palpation in virtual reality, using an approach that requires no manual processing or segmentation of the volumetric medical data set.
BibTeX
@article{zoller2020force,
  author = {Esther I. Zoller and Balázs Faludi and Nicolas Gerig and Gregory F. Jost and Philippe C. Cattin and Georg Rauter},
  title = {{Force quantification and simulation of pedicle screw tract palpation using direct visuo-haptic volume rendering}},
  journal = {Int. J. Comput. Assist. Radiol. Surg},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/s11548-020-02258-0},
}
Figure