Abstract
Models created using the novel methodology realistically reproduce the haptic properties during a trocar placement into the vertebral body. The models are compatible with conventional x-ray imaging. Because the models correspond to real patient CT data, those can alternatively be used in simulation environments that simulate fluoroscopy or CT image guidance to produce highly realistic, radiation-free imaging output.
Introduction
Surgical training for complex procedures like pedicle screw placement or trocar insertion requires high-fidelity environments. While cadavers offer realistic haptic feedback, they are costly, logistically challenging, and present biohazard risks. Synthetic models often fail to replicate the distinct transition from the hard cortical shell to the porous cancellous interior of human bone. This research addresses these limitations by optimizing Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) parameters to create patient-specific, haptically accurate bone analogs derived from CT data.
Methodology
The development process utilized an iterative optimization loop involving two surgical experts with 10 and 33 years of experience. The researchers compared generalized pedicle models against "real-shaped" models generated directly from patient CT scans.
Key parameters adjusted during the prototyping phase included:
- Material Selection: Testing different polymer combinations (labeled W and P) to simulate varying bone densities.
- Perimeters (PER): Adjusting the number of outer shells to simulate the thickness and hardness of cortical bone.
- Infill Density (DENS): Modifying the internal 3D honeycomb structure to mimic the resistance of cancellous (spongy) bone.
Experts evaluated the models using a 7-point Likert scale and provided qualitative feedback on hardness (H) and softness (s/S) to guide subsequent iterations.
Key Insights
A critical discovery was the impact of printing direction. Printing in the anterior-posterior (AP) direction resulted in an "open" honeycomb structure along the insertion path, causing the trocar to drop through without resistance. This suggests that haptic realism is as dependent on internal geometric orientation as it is on material properties. Furthermore, the study demonstrated that geometry can serve as a proxy for density; by increasing the number of perimeters, the researchers could make a softer material feel like realistic cortical bone.
Results and Evaluation
The iterative approach led to significant improvements in haptic fidelity. While the first iteration produced models that were often rated as "too hard" or "too soft," the second iteration successfully dialed in parameters for a more realistic feel.
As shown in the evaluation table, Model 7 in Iteration 2 (Material W/W, 4 perimeters, 30% infill) achieved the highest mean score of 5.0/7.0, indicating a high level of haptic realism. The models also proved fully compatible with conventional X-ray imaging, enabling radiation-free simulation of image-guided procedures.
Conclusion and Future Work
This methodology provides a viable path for creating anatomically and haptically accurate surgical training models. While the current models use synthetic soft tissue (gel wax and foam rubber), future refinement of the "entry feel" through these layers could improve the overall simulation. Additionally, integrating these models into "virtual fluoroscopy" environments will allow for realistic, radiation-free navigation training.
Summary updated