Flow evolution in particle-laden Rayleigh-Bénard convection

Dai ShiarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract A theoretical analysis is carried out to study flow evolution inside the laminar Rayleigh-Bénard convection system laden with small particles. By describing particle dynamics and particle heat as sources of drag and heat respectively, the physics of particle impact on the flow evolution is studied. It is found that due to the relative velocity of the particulate phase to the fluid phase, particles work as a superimposed moment on the whole flow, attenuating the flow intensity. When the relative temperature of the particulate phase to the fluid phase occurs, particles act like a superimposed moment of buoyancy force on the whole flow, causing alterations in both flow intensity and flow direction.

Introduction

Rayleigh-Bénard (RB) convection is a fundamental phenomenon in fluid dynamics, observed in systems ranging from boiling water to atmospheric circulation and the Earth's mantle. When small particles are added to this system, the resulting "particle-laden flow" introduces complex two-way coupling between the fluid and particulate phases. While previous research established that particles can enhance or hinder heat transfer, the exact theoretical mechanism governing how they alter the evolution and direction of the flow remained unclear. This paper addresses this gap by investigating how particles trigger flow reversals and attenuation.

Schematic of the particle-laden Rayleigh-Bénard convection system with dimensions and boundary conditions.

Theoretical Methodology

The study employs an Euler-Euler viewpoint, treating the particles as a continuous phase. The core innovation is a "space-averaging ideology" used to simplify the governing equations. By taking the curl of the momentum equation and integrating it over a circular control volume $S(r)$ in the flow's cross-section, the author transforms complex partial differential equations into a system of five solvable ordinary differential equations. This approach allows for the isolation of the specific "moments" (torques) that particles exert on the bulk fluid motion.

Circular control volume $S(r)$ and its decomposition into left ($S_L$) and right ($S_R$) regions for analyzing buoyancy moments.

Key Insights and Results

The analysis identifies two distinct ways particles "steer" the flow:

  • Momentum Coupling (The "Brake" Effect): When particles move at a different velocity than the fluid, they create drag. This drag acts as a "superimposed moment" that consistently opposes the fluid's rotation. This results in flow attenuation—a reduction in velocity—but never a change in direction. The degree of attenuation depends on the solid volume fraction and the particle response time.
  • Thermal Coupling (The "Steering" Effect): Temperature differences between the particles and the fluid create a "superimposed moment of buoyancy force." Unlike drag, this thermal torque can act in the same or opposite direction as the fluid's natural buoyancy.

The model demonstrates that if the thermal torque generated by the particles is sufficiently strong and opposes the fluid's momentum, it can force the entire convective cell to stop and restart in the opposite direction. This provides a clear theoretical explanation for the "flow reversals" observed in particle-laden systems. The influence of these effects becomes more pronounced as the solid volume fraction, density ratio, or particle heat capacity increases.

Conclusion

This theoretical framework successfully reduces the complex interactions of particle-laden RB convection into a solvable system. By identifying the separate roles of momentum and thermal coupling, the study explains how particles can either slow down or completely flip the direction of convective circulation. While limited to the laminar regime and assuming uniform particle distributions, this work provides a foundation for future research into turbulent flows and non-uniform particle clustering.

Summary updated

Abstract

A theoretical analysis is carried out to study flow evolution inside the laminar Rayleigh-Bénard convection system laden with small particles. By describing particle dynamics and particle heat as sources of drag and heat respectively, the physics of particle impact on the flow evolution is studied. It is found that due to the relative velocity of the particulate phase to the fluid phase, particles work as a superimposed moment on the whole flow, attenuating the flow intensity. When the relative temperature of the particulate phase to the fluid phase occurs, particles act like a superimposed moment of buoyancy force on the whole flow, causing alterations in both flow intensity and flow direction.
BibTeX
@misc{shi2023flow,
  author = {Dai Shi},
  title = {{Flow evolution in particle-laden Rayleigh-Bénard convection}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2310.07308},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07308},
}
Figure