Abstract
A mathematical model to study the flow evolution in Rayleigh-Bénard (RB) convection laden with finite-sized particles after a flow perturbation is developed with an Euler-Lagrange viewpoint. A linear analysis is conducted by combining the averaged flow-scale momentum equation with the averaged particle-scale heat exchange equation. A flow mode of regular oscillation, which is triggered by the heat exchange process between every single particle and its surrounding fluid element, is predicted by this model. Three time scales, namely $\tau_f$, $\tau_p$, and $\Delta t$, are shown to be involved in the heat exchange process, giving significance to the temperature distribution inside the single particle. By assuming $\tau_f / \tau_p \gg 1$, the detailed correlation between the oscillation period and $\kappa_p / \kappa_f$ is established, suggesting a flow mode transition with the change of heat diffusivity ratio of particle to fluid.
Introduction
Rayleigh-Bénard (RB) convection, characterized by fluid motion driven by a temperature gradient between a hot lower boundary and a cold upper boundary, serves as a fundamental model in fluid dynamics. The introduction of solid particles into such systems—forming particle-laden flows—significantly alters heat transfer characteristics. Traditional "point-particle" models assume particles are infinitesimal with uniform internal temperatures. However, in practical applications like fluidized bed reactors or solar collectors, the finite size of particles cannot be ignored. These simplified models often overpredict the Nusselt number because they neglect the time required for heat to diffuse through a particle's volume. This study addresses this gap by developing a theoretical model that accounts for the internal thermal evolution of finite-sized particles and its impact on flow stability.
Mathematical Modeling and Physical Setup
The research employs an Euler-Lagrange framework to couple the bulk fluid's momentum with the buoyancy changes induced by inter-phase heat exchange.
The physical domain consists of a cell of height $l$ and width $b$, with gravity $g$ acting downwards. Particles of diameter $d_p$ are distributed within the fluid. To simplify the complex flow dynamics, the 2D vorticity equation is integrated over a circular control volume $S(r)$ bounded by $\Gamma(r)$, yielding a curve-averaged flow velocity.
A key innovation of this model is treating the internal temperature change of each particle as a 1D heat conduction problem (a Cauchy problem), rather than assuming thermal uniformity. This allows for the identification of three critical time scales: $\Delta t$ (the time interval for inter-phase heat exchange), $\tau_p$ (the thermal relaxation time within the particle), and $\tau_f$ (the thermal diffusion time through the surrounding fluid).
Thermal Regimes and Flow Oscillations
The model identifies that the transition from a state of rest to regular oscillation is triggered by the imbalance of fluid temperature between the left and right sides of the system, a direct consequence of how particles absorb or release heat. The resulting flow behavior is categorized into three distinct regimes based on the relationship between $\tau_p$ and $\Delta t$:
- Regime I ($\tau_p > \Delta t$): Internal heat diffusion is slow. In this regime, the oscillation period decreases as the particle's thermal conductivity increases.
- Regime II ($\tau_p < \Delta t$): Internal heat diffusion is fast. Here, the oscillation period surprisingly increases with higher thermal conductivity.
- Regime III ($\tau_p \sim \Delta t$): A transition state where the oscillation period reaches its minimum value.
Key Results and Validation
The linear analysis yields specific scaling laws for the oscillation period ($\tau$). In Regime I, $\tau$ scales as $(\lambda_p/\lambda_f)^{-1/2}$, while in Regime II, it scales as $(\lambda_p/\lambda_f)^{1/4}$. The model predicts the shortest oscillation period occurs at a thermal conductivity ratio ($\lambda_p/\lambda_f$) of approximately 60.
Validation against numerical simulation data from Takeuchi et al. (2013) shows excellent agreement, particularly for conductivity ratios greater than 10. The study also highlights a phase lag between the fluid's simple harmonic motion and the particles' motion due to drag forces.
Conclusion and Future Work
This work provides a theoretical foundation for understanding how finite-sized particles drive oscillatory transitions in convection by accounting for internal thermal gradients. While highly effective for high-conductivity particles ($\tau_f \gg \tau_p$), future research aims to extend this analysis to cases where fluid and particle thermal diffusivities are comparable and to explore non-linear regimes in turbulent particle-laden flows.
Summary updated