Bifurcation analysis of two-dimensional Rayleigh-Bénard convection using deflation

Nicolas Boullé, Vassilios Dallas, Patrick E. FarrellarXiv 2021 · arXiv

Introduction

Rayleigh–Bénard convection (RBC)—the buoyancy-driven flow of fluid heated from below—serves as a fundamental model for diverse phenomena, from atmospheric circulation to mantle convection. A central challenge in studying RBC is characterizing its "solution landscape": the set of all possible steady-state flow patterns for a given set of parameters. As the Rayleigh number ($Ra$), representing the thermal driving force, increases, the system undergoes a series of bifurcations, transitioning from a quiescent state to complex, multi-cellular rolls and eventually to turbulence.

Traditional numerical continuation methods are effective at tracking a single solution branch as parameters vary. However, they often fail to detect "disconnected branches"—solution states that exist in isolation and cannot be reached through continuous deformation of a known state. This paper utilizes a novel technique, deflated continuation, to systematically uncover these hidden states in 2D RBC.

Numerical Methodology: Deflated Continuation

The authors solve the steady-state Oberbeck–Boussinesq equations in a 2D square domain with no-slip boundaries using the Firedrake finite element library. To overcome the limitations of standard solvers, they employ deflated continuation. This algorithm works by finding a solution using Newton's method and then applying a "deflation operator" to the governing equations. This operator effectively removes the discovered solution from the search space, forcing the solver to converge to a different, previously unknown steady state.

By iteratively deflating known solutions and using the eigenmodes of the trivial (no-flow) state as initial guesses, the researchers can map out a much larger portion of the bifurcation diagram than previously possible.

Mapping the Solution Landscape

The study identifies the first ten primary bifurcations where the quiescent fluid state becomes unstable and gives way to convective rolls. These critical Rayleigh numbers range from $Ra_c^{(1)} \approx 2,586$ to $Ra_c^{(10)} \approx 94,543$.

Visualizations of the first ten primary bifurcation flow patterns, showing the transition from simple rolls to complex multi-cellular structures.

At a higher Rayleigh number of $Ra = 10^5$, the algorithm discovered 43 distinct solution branches. When accounting for the physical symmetries of the system (mirror and Boussinesq symmetries), this number expands to 129 possible steady states. Many of these branches are disconnected from the primary branch, forming an "archipelago" of solutions that would be invisible to standard methods.

Heat Transfer Efficiency and Flow Reversals

A key metric for evaluating these convective states is the Nusselt number ($Nu$), which measures the efficiency of heat transfer relative to pure conduction. The bifurcation diagram illustrates how $Nu$ evolves with $Ra$ for various discovered branches.

Bifurcation diagram showing the Nusselt number ($Nu$) as a function of the Rayleigh number ($Ra$) for twelve distinct solution branches. Note the complex intersections and the "S-shaped" curve of Branch 11.

One of the most significant findings is the discovery of Branch 11. This branch exhibits an S-shaped curve characterized by hysteresis, meaning the system can support multiple stable states at the same $Ra$ and may "jump" between them. The flow patterns associated with Branch 11 closely resemble the large-scale circulations observed in turbulent flow reversal experiments. These disconnected branches likely serve as the "skeleton" of phase space, guiding the system's behavior even when the steady states themselves are unstable.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

By successfully applying deflated continuation to 2D Rayleigh–Bénard convection, the authors have revealed a far more complex solution landscape than previously understood. The discovery of numerous disconnected branches provides a structural explanation for complex phenomena like flow reversals in turbulent systems.

Future work will involve extending these methods to three-dimensional geometries and higher Rayleigh numbers. While 2D models provide valuable insights, 3D convection introduces additional degrees of freedom and complex structures, such as twisting rolls, that are essential for a complete understanding of high-$Ra$ turbulence.

Summary updated

Abstract

We perform a bifurcation analysis of the steady states of Rayleigh--B\'enard convection with no-slip boundary conditions in two dimensions using a numerical method called deflated continuation. By combining this method with an initialisation strategy based on the eigenmodes of the conducting state, we are able to discover multiple solutions to this non-linear problem, including disconnected branches of the bifurcation diagram, without the need for any prior knowledge of the solutions. One of the disconnected branches we find contains an S-shaped curve with hysteresis, which is the origin of a flow pattern that may be related to the dynamics of flow reversals in the turbulent regime. Linear stability analysis is also performed to analyse the steady and unsteady regimes of the solutions in the parameter space and to characterise the type of instabilities.
BibTeX
@misc{boulle2021bifurcation,
  author = {Nicolas Boullé and Vassilios Dallas and Patrick E. Farrell},
  title = {{Bifurcation analysis of two-dimensional Rayleigh-Bénard convection using deflation}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2102.10576},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.10576},
}
Figure