First Numerical Simulations of Anomalous Hydrodynamics

Masaru Hongo, Yuji Hirono, Tetsufumi Hirano

Abstract: Anomalous hydrodynamics is a low-energy effective theory that captures the effects of quantum anomalies. We develop a numerical code for anomalous hydrodynamics and apply it to the dynamics of heavy-ion collisions, where anomalous transports are expected to occur. This is the first attempt to perform fully non-linear numerical simulations of anomalous hydrodynamics. We discuss the implications of these simulations for possible experimental observations of anomalous transport effects, specifically focusing on the analysis of charge-dependent elliptic flow parameters.

TL;DR

Researchers have performed the first fully non-linear (3+1)D numerical simulations of anomalous hydrodynamics to model heavy-ion collisions. Their findings challenge the current experimental "smoking gun" for the Chiral Magnetic Wave, showing that the commonly cited slope parameter is unreliable, while pointing to the intercept at zero charge asymmetry as a much more robust signal for quantum anomalies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the extreme conditions of heavy-ion collisions (like those at RHIC or the LHC), quarks and gluons form a "perfect fluid" known as the Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP). Because these collisions involve rapidly moving charged nuclei, they generate some of the strongest magnetic fields in the universe.

Schematic of the electromagnetic fields and charge separation in a heavy-ion collision.

Theory suggests these fields, combined with quantum anomalies (breaks in classical symmetry), should trigger "anomalous transport" effects like the Chiral Magnetic Effect (CME). A major predicted consequence is the Chiral Magnetic Wave (CMW), which should cause a specific charge-dependent deformation in the flow of particles. Until now, scientists relied on simplified, linearized models to predict these signals. This paper addresses the need for a realistic, non-linear dynamical simulation to determine which experimental observables actually prove the existence of these quantum anomalies.

Methods

The authors developed a custom numerical code to solve (3+1)-dimensional anomalous hydrodynamic equations. Key technical aspects include:

  • Non-linear Dynamics: Unlike previous studies that linearized equations around a static background, this work simulates the full, non-linear expansion of the fluid.
  • Coordinate System: They used expanding "Milne" coordinates ($\tau, x, y, \eta_s$), which are standard for relativistic heavy-ion physics to account for longitudinal expansion.
  • Constitutive Equations: They incorporated terms for the Chiral Magnetic Effect and Chiral Separation Effect directly into the fluid's conservation laws.
  • Freezeout: To compare with experiments, they used the Cooper-Frye formula to transition from fluid cells to individual particles (pions and protons) at a specific temperature (160 MeV).

Datasets

This is a theoretical/computational study, so it does not use a training dataset. However, the simulation parameters (like temperature profiles and particle multiplicities) were carefully calibrated to match experimental data from the STAR Collaboration at RHIC.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spontaneous Quadrupoles: Even if the system starts with zero net charge, the interplay between the magnetic field and the anomaly source term automatically generates a "charge quadrupole"—a specific spatial arrangement of positive and negative charges.
Spatial distribution of charge density $n$ and axial charge density $n_5$ showing the formation of a charge quadrupole.
  • The "Slope" Problem: Previously, experimentalists looked at the slope ($r_e$) of the difference in elliptic flow ($\Delta v_2$) versus charge asymmetry ($A_\pm$) as evidence for the CMW. This paper reveals that this slope is not a robust signal because it can be produced by the basic quantum statistics (Bose-Einstein vs. Fermi-Dirac) of the particles, even without any anomalies present.
  • The Intercept as a New Signal: The authors found that while the slope is "noisy," the intercept (the value of $\Delta v_2$ when the net charge asymmetry is exactly zero) is highly sensitive to anomalous transport. If the intercept is non-zero and positive, it provides a much cleaner signal for the Chiral Magnetic Wave.

Key Results

  • Linearity: The simulations confirmed a linear relationship between $\Delta v_2$ and $A_\pm$ across all tested conditions, matching the qualitative trend seen in experimental data.
  • Quantifying the Intercept: In the absence of anomalies ($C=0$), the intercept $\Delta v_2(A_\pm = 0)$ is zero. With anomalies, the intercept becomes finite and positive.
  • Magnetic Field Duration: The magnitude of the intercept is directly tied to how long the magnetic field lasts ($\tau_B$). A longer-lived field results in a larger, more detectable intercept.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several simplifications that could be refined in future iterations:

  1. Conductive Current: The study neglected the electrical conductivity of the QGP, which also contributes to charge deformation.
  2. Back-reaction: The simulation assumes the magnetic field is an external "background" and doesn't account for how the fluid's own motion might modify that field.
  3. QCD Sphalerons: These are topological fluctuations in the vacuum that can "wash out" axial charge; they were not included in this initial model.
  4. Vorticity: The "Chiral Vortical Effect" (transport induced by fluid rotation) was omitted due to technical numerical difficulties but is a known factor in off-central collisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Anomalous hydrodynamics is a low-energy effective theory that captures effects of quantum anomalies. We develop a numerical code of anomalous hydrodynamics and apply it to dynamics of heavy-ion collisions, where anomalous transports are expected to occur. This is the first attempt to perform fully non-linear numerical simulations of anomalous hydrodynamics. We discuss implications of the simulations for possible experimental observations of anomalous transport effects. From analyses of the charge-dependent elliptic flow parameters (v ±
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hongo2017first,
  author = {Masaru Hongo and Yuji Hirono and Tetsufumi Hirano},
  title = {{First Numerical Simulations of Anomalous Hydrodynamics}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2017.10.028},
}

Loading related content...

Figure