Anomalous-hydrodynamic analysis of charge-dependent elliptic flow in heavy-ion collisions

Masaru Hongo, Yuji Hirono, Tetsufumi Hirano

TL;DR

This paper presents the first fully non-linear numerical simulations of anomalous hydrodynamics in heavy-ion collisions. The authors find that while the previously proposed signal for anomalous transport (a linear dependence of charge-dependent elliptic flow on charge asymmetry) is not robust, the intercept of this relationship at zero charge asymmetry is a sensitive indicator of these exotic transport phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heavy-ion collisions, like those at RHIC and LHC, create a state of matter called the quark-gluon plasma (QGP). This plasma is known to behave like a nearly perfect fluid. However, under the extreme conditions of these collisions, particularly the strong magnetic fields generated, quantum anomalies can lead to unusual transport phenomena. One such phenomenon is the chiral magnetic effect (CME), which predicts the generation of electric currents along magnetic fields due to the QGP's properties.

While theoretical studies have explored these anomalous transport effects, experimental verification has been challenging due to a lack of precise theoretical predictions. Previous work suggested that the charge-dependent elliptic flow, specifically its linear dependence on the net charge asymmetry, could be a smoking gun for these effects. However, this paper aims to rigorously test this hypothesis using a more sophisticated approach: fully non-linear numerical simulations of anomalous hydrodynamics. This is crucial because previous studies often relied on linearized approximations, which may not capture the full complexity of the QGP's evolution.

Methods

The core of this work is the development and application of a novel numerical code for simulating anomalous hydrodynamics in (3+1) dimensions. This code incorporates the effects of quantum anomalies, specifically the triangle anomaly, into the hydrodynamic equations governing the QGP. The authors use a simplified equation of state (ideal gas for massless quarks and gluons) for computational tractability, arguing it preserves the essential features of anomalous transport.

They implement a specific parametrization for the time evolution of electromagnetic fields, mimicking those expected in off-central heavy-ion collisions. The initial conditions for the fluid are set to represent a hot, dense QGP, with an initial axial charge density of zero and a controlled initial vector charge chemical potential to vary the net charge asymmetry. The final particle distributions are calculated using the Cooper-Frye formula, which describes particle emission from a freezeout hypersurface.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chiral Magnetic Wave (CMW) and Quadrupole Deformation: The simulations demonstrate that even without an initial net vector charge, anomalous transport effects (driven by the axial anomaly and CME) can generate a charge quadrupole deformation in the QGP. This is a significant finding, suggesting that such deformations are not solely tied to initial conditions from lower-energy collisions.
  • Revisiting the Signal for Anomalous Transport: The paper critically re-evaluates the proposed signal for anomalous transport: the linear dependence of the charge-dependent elliptic flow difference ($\Delta v_2^\pm$) on the net charge asymmetry ($A_\pm$). Their simulations show that this linear trend can persist even when anomalous transport effects are switched off (by setting the anomaly constant $C=0$). This implies that the slope of this relationship is not a robust indicator of anomalous transport.
  • The Intercept as a Robust Signal: Crucially, the authors find that the intercept of the $\Delta v_2^\pm$ versus $A_\pm$ plot at $A_\pm = 0$ is sensitive to anomalous transport effects. When anomalies are present, this intercept is finite and positive, whereas it is zero in the absence of anomalies. This provides a more reliable experimental observable for detecting these phenomena.
  • Sensitivity to Magnetic Field Dynamics: The magnitude of the intercept is also found to depend on the duration of the magnetic field, offering a potential avenue to infer the dynamics of electromagnetic fields in the QGP from experimental measurements.

Key Results

  • The first fully non-linear numerical simulations of anomalous hydrodynamics in (3+1) dimensions were performed.
  • A charge quadrupole deformation in the QGP was shown to be generated by anomalous transport effects, even with zero initial vector charge.
  • The linear dependence of $\Delta v_2^\pm$ on $A_\pm$ was found to be present even without anomalous transport, indicating it's not a robust signal.
  • The intercept of the $\Delta v_2^\pm$ vs. $A_\pm$ plot at $A_\pm=0$ was identified as a robust signal for anomalous transport effects, being finite and positive when anomalies are active and zero otherwise.
  • The intercept's magnitude was shown to decrease significantly when the electric field is turned off, highlighting the interplay between electric and magnetic fields and the anomaly.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Neglect of Conductive Current: The study did not include the conductive current, which can also contribute to charge quadrupole deformation.
  • Neglect of Back Reaction: The back reaction of the matter on the electromagnetic fields was not considered. This means the duration of magnetic fields was treated as a parameter, rather than being dynamically determined.
  • QCD Sphalerons: The effects of QCD sphalerons, which can reduce axial charge, were not included.
  • Simplified Equation of State: While justified for capturing essential features, the ideal gas equation of state is a simplification.
  • Quantum Statistics and Mass Effects: The slope parameter ($r_e$) was found to be sensitive to quantum statistics (fermions vs. bosons) and particle mass, suggesting that a more comprehensive study incorporating these factors and finite $p_T$ cuts is needed for a complete understanding of charge-dependent elliptic flow.

Future work should focus on incorporating these missing effects to provide even more precise predictions for experimental observables. The development of a numerical code for anomalous hydrodynamics opens up new avenues for studying these fascinating phenomena in the extreme conditions of heavy-ion collisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Anomalous hydrodynamics is a low-energy effective theory that captures effects of quantum anomalies. We develop a numerical code of anomalous hydrodynamics and apply it to dynamics of heavy-ion collisions, where anomalous transports are expected to occur. This is the first attempt to perform fully non-linear numerical simulations of anomalous hydrodynamics. We discuss implications of the simulations for possible experimental observations of anomalous transport effects. From analyses of the charge-dependent elliptic flow parameters ($v_2^\pm$) as a function of the net charge asymmetry $A_\pm$, we find that the linear dependence of $\Delta v_2^\pm \equiv v_2^- - v_2^+$ on the net charge asymmetry $A_\pm$ cannot be regarded as a robust signal of anomalous transports, contrary to previous studies. We, however, find that the intercept $\Delta v_2^\pm(A_\pm=0)$ is sensitive to anomalous transport effects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hongo2017anomalous,
  author = {Masaru Hongo and Yuji Hirono and Tetsufumi Hirano},
  title = {{Anomalous-hydrodynamic analysis of charge-dependent elliptic flow in heavy-ion collisions}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2017.10.028},
}
Figure