Fast beam stacking using rf barriers

Weiren Chou, D. Capista, Jim E. Griffin, K.y. Ng, D. Wildman

TL;DR

Researchers at Fermilab have successfully demonstrated a "fast beam stacking" technique that uses RF barriers to double the proton beam intensity in the Main Injector. By using stationary and moving rectangular RF pulses to manipulate beam drift, they managed to pack 12 Booster pulses into the space normally occupied by six, providing a path toward significantly higher beam power for neutrino experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In high-energy physics, beam power is king. At the time of this research, the Fermilab Main Injector (MI) was limited by how many "pulses" of protons it could accept from the Booster accelerator. Under normal operation, the MI could only take 6 or 7 pulses because of the time required for injection and the physical space each pulse occupied in the ring.

To support the NOvA experiment and other high-intensity projects, Fermilab needed a way to increase the number of protons delivered to targets. While "slip stacking" (a method of overlapping beams) was already being studied, this paper explores an alternative: using RF barriers to physically compress and "fold" the beam, allowing for a much higher packing density of particles.

Methods

The team installed two specialized barrier RF systems in the Main Injector. Unlike traditional RF systems that use sine waves to create "buckets" for particles, these systems generate 8 kV rectangular pulses at 90 kHz.

The "Fast Stacking" process works through three main components:

  1. Momentum Offset: The injected beam is intentionally given a momentum offset ($\Delta p/p = -0.196\%$) by shifting the injection RF frequency. Because of the "slip factor" in the accelerator, particles with different momenta travel at different speeds, causing the beam to drift.
  2. Stationary Barrier: A fixed RF pulse acts as a "reflecting wall," preventing earlier injected pulses from drifting into space reserved for later ones.
  3. Moving Barrier: A second RF pulse moves at a specific speed (0.8 $\mu$s per Booster cycle) to reduce the momentum spread and help "stack" the incoming pulses tightly against the stationary barrier.

By timing these barriers, the researchers could reduce the spacing between consecutive pulses from the standard 1.6 $\mu$s down to 0.8 $\mu$s.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, the "data" consists of real-time beam measurements from the Fermilab Main Injector. The authors evaluated the system using:

  • Mountain View plots: Oscilloscope-style traces showing the longitudinal profile of the beam over multiple turns.
  • Intensity monitors: Measuring the number of protons successfully injected and accelerated.
  • Pulse counts: Experiments were conducted with 8, 10, and 12 injected pulses to verify the stacking efficiency.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Slip Factor Lever: A clever insight was managing the frequency shift between two different machines. Because the "slip factor" (how speed changes with momentum) has opposite signs in the Booster and the Main Injector, a higher RF frequency at injection has opposite effects on beam energy in each machine. The net change is what creates the necessary drift for stacking.
  • Fast vs. Slow Stacking: Unlike "slow" stacking, which relies on adiabatic (gradual) compression, this "fast" method uses the natural drift of a momentum-offset beam, making the process much more efficient for high-rep-rate operations.
  • The Barrier as a Diagnostic: The researchers realized that an RF barrier can act as a "sieve." If you know the voltage (height) of the barrier, you can determine the beam's momentum spread by lowering the voltage until particles start "leaking" over the wall.

Key Results

  • Doubled Capacity: The system successfully injected 12 Booster pulses into the Main Injector, compared to the standard 6 or 7.
  • Compression Efficiency: In one test, the total width of 6 stacked pulses was reduced to just 5.5 $\mu$s—less than half the space they would normally occupy (9.6 $\mu$s).
  • Successful Acceleration: The stacked beam was successfully recaptured by the main 53 MHz RF system and accelerated to 120 GeV.
  • Direct Momentum Measurement: Using the "barrier penetration" method, the team measured the Booster beam's energy spread at $\pm 6.1$ MeV.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation identified was beam loss at the start of acceleration. While there was no noticeable loss during the injection and stacking phases, some particles escaped during the transition to the main acceleration RF.

The authors attribute this to "dc beam"—particles that weren't properly captured into the 53 MHz RF buckets. They suggest that the RF recapture procedure needs to be refined and optimized through further simulation and experimentation to eliminate these losses and make the system viable for daily high-power operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Two barrier RF systems were fabricated, tested and installed in the Fermilab Main Injector. Each can provide 8 kV rectangular pulses (the RF barriers) at 90 kHz. When a stationary barrier is combined with a moving barrier, injected beams from the Booster can be continuously deflected, folded and stacked in the Main Injector, which leads to doubling of the beam intensity. This paper gives a report on the beam experiment using this novel technology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chou2007fast,
  author = {Weiren Chou and D. Capista and Jim E. Griffin and K.Y. Ng and D. Wildman},
  title = {{Fast beam stacking using rf barriers}},
  booktitle = {University},
  year = {2007},
}

Loading related content...

Figure