Failure analysis of 650 tons tension rod of cold cast anchor

Jianfeng Lu, Yihong Luo, Yi‐Ling Chen, Jianbing LiangPrestress 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Tension rods are critical components in the construction of cable-stayed bridges. Through mechanical and structural inspection, along with strength verification of a fractured tension rod, this study analyzes the root cause of failure. Based on these findings, we propose key considerations for the design and manufacture of high-capacity tension rods.

Introduction

In cable-stayed bridge construction, tension rods must withstand immense loads and cyclic stresses. This paper investigates a catastrophic failure of a tension rod designed for a 625-ton maximum capacity. Despite its high theoretical rating, the rod fractured during its 100th use at a load of only 400 tons. Standard inspections showed the rod's surface hardness was within specification, necessitating a deeper forensic analysis to understand why it failed well below its limit.

Fracture location on the threaded tension rod

Methodology

A multi-disciplinary approach was used to diagnose the failure:

  • Macroscopic Inspection: The fracture surface was examined for signs of plastic deformation versus brittle cleavage.
  • Mechanical Property Testing: Tensile tests (yield strength, elongation) and HRC hardness mapping were performed across the rod's cross-section.
  • Metallurgical Analysis: Microscopic examination checked for inclusions, grain size, and microstructure (pearlite and proeutectoid ferrite).
  • Impact Toughness Testing: Charpy V-notch tests ($A_k$) were conducted across various tempering temperatures (200°C to 500°C) to identify brittle transition zones.
  • Theoretical Verification: Stress at the thread root was calculated to determine the actual safety factor at the time of failure.

Results and Analysis

Fracture Characteristics

The macroscopic inspection revealed a flat fracture surface with no evidence of necking or plastic deformation. This confirms a classic brittle failure mode, where the material snaps suddenly rather than yielding under load.

Macroscopic view of the brittle fracture surface

The Strength Paradox

Mechanical testing showed that the 40Cr steel rod met the required yield strength (~840 MPa) and hardness (28–35 HRC). Theoretical calculations indicated a safety factor of 2.3 at the 400-ton failure load. This suggests the failure was not due to a lack of nominal strength, but a critical deficiency in fracture toughness.

Identification of Temper Brittleness

The core issue was identified as "second-class temper brittleness." Impact toughness testing revealed a significant "valley" in energy absorption when the 40Cr steel was tempered between 350°C and 370°C, where impact energy dropped to just 9.0J. Even if tempered at higher temperatures, slow cooling through this critical range can cause impurities like phosphorus to migrate to grain boundaries, embrittling the material. Experimental re-tempering at 500°C followed by rapid cooling restored the impact toughness to 70.5J, confirming the heat treatment process was flawed.

Geometric Stress Concentration

The fracture was physically triggered at the thread roots (Tr170 x 16). These sharp notches acted as stress concentrators. In a tough material, micro-cracks at these points might be arrested; however, in the embrittled 40Cr steel, these cracks propagated instantaneously across the entire cross-section because the material lacked the toughness to arrest them.

Conclusion and Recommendations

The failure of the 650-ton tension rod highlights that high tensile strength and hardness are insufficient for safety if impact toughness is compromised. To prevent similar failures, the following practices are recommended:

  • Enhanced Process Control: Implement rapid cooling (water or oil quenching) after high-temperature tempering to bypass the brittle temperature zone.
  • Design Optimization: Increase the radius of thread roots to minimize stress concentrations.
  • Mandatory Toughness Testing: Include Charpy impact testing as a standard quality control requirement for all high-load tension rods, rather than relying solely on hardness and tensile strength.
  • Material Selection: Evaluate alternative alloys that are less susceptible to temper brittleness for critical infrastructure applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tension rod is an important part in the construction of cable-stayed bridge. Through the mechanical and structural inspection and strength check of a broken tension rod, the cause of the fracture is analyzed, and on this basis, the problems worth attention in the design and manufacture of this kind of tension rod are put forward.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2014failure,
  author = {Jianfeng Lu and Yihong Luo and Yi‐Ling Chen and Jianbing Liang},
  title = {{Failure analysis of 650 tons tension rod of cold cast anchor}},
  booktitle = {Prestress},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.59238/j.pt.2014.02.008},
}
Figure