Abstract This study experimentally evaluates the effect of open-grid ceilings on the water-spraying effectiveness of upright sprinkler heads. The work procedure guidelines of the National Fire Agency uniformly stipulate a separation distance of at least 450 mm between open grid ceilings and upright sprinkler heads. However, the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) specifies different separation distances depending on hazard classifications (light: 450 mm and ordinary: 600 mm). This difference in standards necessitated the verification of the effective spraying performance of sprinkler heads. Therefore, in this study, water distribution and spray volume were measured by varying the separation distances to 300, 450, and 600 mm through spray distribution experiments. The experimental results showed that the 600 mm separation distance met all performance criteria, whereas the 450 mm separation distance failed to meet the standard for the average water collection distribution curve. Notably, the amount of water collected in the 7th collection container decreased by approximately 45% compared to that at the 600 mm distance. These findings suggest that the current National Fire Agency guidelines, which specify a separation distance of 450 mm, may be insufficient to prevent spray obstruction and should be reconsidered.
Introduction
Open grid ceilings—lattice-like structures common in modern architecture—are favored for their aesthetic appeal and air circulation benefits. However, they present a significant physical barrier to upright sprinkler heads, potentially obstructing water spray during a fire. Currently, regulatory standards for the required separation distance between the sprinkler and the grid vary. The Korean National Fire Agency (NFA) mandates a uniform 450 mm gap, while the US National Fire Protection Association (NFPA 13) requires 450 mm for "light hazards" and 600 mm for "ordinary hazards." This study investigates whether the 450 mm standard provides sufficient coverage or if it creates "dry zones" that could facilitate fire spread.
Experimental Methodology
To evaluate the impact of separation distance, researchers conducted spray distribution experiments using a standardized setup. The hardware included upright sprinkler heads and a 100 cm x 100 cm open grid ceiling with an 81% opening ratio. The primary variable was the separation distance, tested at 300 mm, 450 mm, and 600 mm, with a 1200 mm control.
Tests were performed at discharge pressures of 0.1, 0.4, and 0.7 MPa. Water collection was measured using seven concentric containers placed on the floor to map the spray distribution. Performance was benchmarked against Korea Fire Institute (KFI) standards, which require specific distribution curves and at least 60% discharge within a 3-meter radius.
Results and Discussion
The experimental data revealed a "center-heavy" distribution problem at shorter separation distances. When the sprinkler is too close to the grid, the lattice bars cause water to pool and fall directly beneath the head, significantly reducing coverage in peripheral zones.
Key findings include:
- 600 mm Performance: This distance was the only one to pass all performance criteria across all tested pressures, aligning with NFPA 13's "ordinary hazard" requirements.
- 450 mm Limitations: At the current NFA legal standard of 450 mm, the system failed the average water collection distribution test at higher pressures (0.4 and 0.7 MPa). Water collection in the outermost container decreased by 45% compared to the 600 mm setup.
- 300 mm Critical Failure: At a 300 mm gap, peripheral water collection plummeted by over 91%, effectively neutralizing the sprinkler's wide-area effectiveness.
Interestingly, higher water pressure exacerbated the obstruction at shorter distances, as the increased force led to more significant redirection by the grid bars.
Conclusion
The study confirms that the NFPA’s 600 mm requirement for ordinary hazards is scientifically robust, whereas the Korean NFA’s 450 mm blanket rule may leave buildings under-protected. Future research will explore the effects of different grid geometries, including varying vertical depths and opening ratios, as well as the performance of pendent (downward) sprinklers. For current fire safety engineering, a 600 mm separation distance is recommended for ordinary hazard areas with open grid ceilings to ensure adequate spray distribution.
Summary updated