Spreading behavior of firefighting foam solutions on typical liquid fuel surfaces

Youjie Sheng, Yang Li, Kui WuResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the spreading dynamics of firefighting foam solutions on various liquid fuel surfaces, challenging the traditional reliance on the static spreading coefficient ($S$) as the sole predictor of performance. Using high-speed imaging, researchers analyzed six aqueous film-forming foam (AFFF) solutions and one fluorine-free foam (FfreeF) across four fuels: cyclohexane, diesel, n-heptane, and ethanol. The results identified four distinct spreading phenomena—spreading, suspension, dissolution, and sinking—and demonstrated that a positive $S$ does not guarantee film formation. Instead, dynamic factors such as spreading rate and total spreading amount are critical for evaluating foam effectiveness.

Introduction

Aqueous Film-Forming Foams (AFFFs) are essential for suppressing liquid fuel fires by creating a barrier that excludes oxygen and suppresses fuel vapors. Historically, the effectiveness of these foams has been predicted using the spreading coefficient ($S$), calculated from surface and interfacial tensions. However, practical applications often reveal a discrepancy where foams with positive $S$ values fail to form stable films. This research aims to bridge this gap by examining the dynamic spreading behavior, including spreading area, rate, and the maximum amount of foam a fuel surface can support.

Methodology

The experimental setup utilized a high-speed camera to capture the impact and subsequent behavior of single foam solution droplets (2.6 mm diameter) on fuel pools.

Materials

The study tested seven commercial firefighting foams against four common liquid fuels. The physical properties of the fuels, including density and surface tension, are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1: Physical properties of the liquid fuels used in the study.

The foam solutions included six AFFF variants and one fluorine-free alternative. Their chemical and physical properties, including the calculated spreading coefficients for different fuels, are detailed in Table 2.

Table 2: Physical properties and calculated spreading coefficients of the foam solutions.

Analysis

Image analysis was performed using ImageJ and MATLAB to determine instantaneous spreading area and rates. Dynamic surface tension was also measured to understand how quickly surfactants migrate to the interface.

Results and Discussion

Four Typical Spreading Phenomena

The researchers categorized droplet behavior into four types:

  1. Spreading: The droplet forms a thin, continuous film.
  2. Suspension: The droplet remains as a bead on the surface.
  3. Dissolution: The droplet mixes directly into the fuel (common with ethanol).
  4. Sinking: The droplet breaks the surface tension and sinks due to higher density.

The Inadequacy of the Spreading Coefficient

A key finding was that $S > 0$ is a necessary but insufficient condition for film formation. For instance, some foams with positive coefficients failed to spread effectively due to dynamic forces during impact. Furthermore, the spreading rate was not proportional to the magnitude of $S$. AFFF-5# exhibited the highest spreading rate on diesel (247.98 mm²/s) despite not having the highest $S$ value, suggesting that the speed at which surfactants reach equilibrium is more influential.

Spreading Amount and Sinking

Because foam solutions are denser than fuels, they eventually sink. The "spreading amount"—the volume of solution a surface can hold before sinking—was identified as a vital metric. On diesel, AFFF-5# supported up to 0.25 ml, significantly higher than other samples (0.04–0.06 ml), indicating superior film stability.

Performance of Fluorine-Free Foams

The fluorine-free foam (FfreeF) consistently underperformed, showing negative spreading coefficients on most fuels and failing to form a film. This underscores the current technical challenge in replacing fluorinated surfactants without compromising film-forming capabilities.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that evaluating firefighting foams requires a multi-faceted approach. While the spreading coefficient remains a fundamental parameter, it must be supplemented by dynamic measurements of spreading rate and spreading amount. Future work should focus on the molecular structure of surfactants and the impact of high temperatures on these dynamic properties to better simulate real-world fire conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract A series of experiments was performed to investigate the spreading behavior of firefighting foam solutions on liquid fuel surfaces. The spreading coefficients of six kinds of aqueous film-forming foam solutions and one fluorine-free foam solution on the surface of four liquid fuels, namely, cyclohexane, diesel, n-heptane, and ethanol, were calculated on the basis of surface and interfacial tension. Spreading behavior was studied systematically using a high-speed camera, and then the relationship between spreading behavior and spreading coefficient was analyzed. Furthermore, the spreading area and spreading rate of different foam solution droplets on liquid fuel surfaces were studied in depth. The spreading amount of the foam solution droplets on the liquid fuel surfaces was measured. Four typical spreading phenomena, namely, spreading, suspension, dissolution, and sinking, of AFFF solutions on liquid fuel surfaces were identified. Moreover, a positive spreading coefficient did not necessarily lead to the formation of an aqueous film. The spreading area, spreading rate, and spreading amount were not proportional to the spreading coefficient. During the evaluation of the spreading property of firefighting foam, the spreading coefficient, spreading rate, and spreading amount must be focused on instead of only the spreading coefficient.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sheng2021spreading,
  author = {Youjie Sheng and Yang Li and Kui Wu},
  title = {{Spreading behavior of firefighting foam solutions on typical liquid fuel surfaces}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-208743/v1},
}
Figure