Experimental study on square RC short columns strengthened with corrugated steel jacket under axial compression

Fan Yang, Ligui Yang, Yuyin Wang, Yong Fan, Shuangshuang Jin, Yunwen Chen, Qilong XiaarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

The global infrastructure network is aging, with many reinforced concrete (RC) columns suffering from environmental degradation, seismic damage, or construction defects. Retrofitting these structures is often more sustainable and cost-effective than demolition. However, square RC columns are notoriously difficult to strengthen effectively because traditional flat-plate jackets tend to bulge under pressure, losing confinement efficiency. This research explores the use of corrugated steel jackets to provide superior transverse stiffness for columns that have already sustained significant "pre-damage."

Common types of damage in RC columns requiring retrofitting, including natural aging, earthquake damage, and construction defects.

Methodology

The study involved axial compression testing of ten RC short columns. To simulate real-world conditions, specimens were "pre-damaged" by loading them to 40%, 60%, or 100% of their ultimate capacity before the retrofit was applied. The experimental variables included jacket thickness (ranging from 1.6 mm to 2.7 mm), preloading levels, and connection methods (bolted assemblies versus fully welded corners). A theoretical model was also developed, incorporating a strength degradation factor ($k_d$) to account for internal micro-cracking from the initial damage.

Key Insights

The "Damage Paradox"

A significant discovery of the study was that higher levels of pre-damage can actually improve the efficiency of the steel jacket. Severely damaged concrete exhibits greater lateral expansion (dilation) when re-compressed. This expansion activates the passive confinement of the corrugated jacket earlier and more intensely, which significantly boosts the column's ductility and load-bearing capacity.

Structural Efficiency of Corrugation

The corrugated geometry functions as a series of integrated beams. While the "troughs" contribute to axial load resistance, the "crests" provide high transverse stiffness, effectively preventing the outward buckling common in flat-plate retrofits. Interestingly, thinner plates (1.6 mm) were found to be remarkably efficient, suggesting that engineers can save material without compromising structural safety.

Results and Performance

  • Capacity Enhancement: The corrugated steel jackets increased the ultimate bearing capacity of the RC columns by 34.6% to 67.3%.
  • Ductility Gains: Even columns damaged to 100% of their capacity showed massive improvements in peak deformation capacity after retrofitting.
  • Connection Performance: Fully welded corner connections provided the most rigid confinement, resulting in nearly 10% higher capacity than bolted connections.
  • Model Precision: The proposed theoretical model achieved an average error of only 0.4%, whereas standard international codes like Eurocode 4 were found to overestimate capacity in these specific retrofit scenarios.

Conclusion and Future Work

Corrugated steel jackets represent a high-efficiency solution for retrofitting damaged square RC columns. While the results are promising, the authors note that future research should focus on the effects of applying these jackets under sustained loads (strengthening under load) and the long-term durability of the grout-steel interface in various environmental conditions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{yang2025experimental,
  author = {Fan Yang and Ligui Yang and Yuyin Wang and Yong Fan and Shuangshuang Jin and Yunwen Chen and Qilong Xia},
  title = {{Experimental study on square RC short columns strengthened with corrugated steel jacket under axial compression}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2502.11529},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.11529},
}
Figure