ECCENTRIC LOADING BEHAVIOR OF L-SHAPED COLUMNS COMPOSED OF CONCRETE-FILLED STEEL TUBES

T. Zhou, M.y. Xu, Z.h. Chen, Xiaodong Wang, Y.w. WangOpenalex Unknown 2016 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

In modern urban residential design, "special-shaped" columns (L, T, or X-shaped) are preferred for their ability to be concealed within wall intersections, thereby increasing usable floor area. However, traditional reinforced concrete special-shaped columns often exhibit poor seismic performance. This research investigates a novel structural solution: L-shaped columns composed of multiple concrete-filled steel tubes (SCFT). This paper presents an experimental and numerical study on the behavior of these columns under axial and eccentric loading, focusing on failure modes, component cooperation, and the development of a simplified design formula.

The Challenge of Special-Shaped Columns

Traditional rectangular columns often protrude into living spaces, creating architectural constraints. While special-shaped columns solve this, standard concrete-filled steel tubular (CFST) designs often require internal tie rods to ensure proper interaction between the steel shell and concrete core, which can be difficult to fabricate. The proposed SCFT design utilizes several smaller "mono-columns" connected by steel plates and stiffeners to achieve high strength and ductility while maintaining a clean architectural profile.

Cross-section of the L-shaped SCFT column showing mono-columns, connection plates, and stiffeners.

Methodology

The study employed a three-pronged approach to validate the SCFT design:

  1. Experimental Testing: Three L-shaped specimens were fabricated and tested under different loading conditions: pure axial compression (S-3), uniaxial bending (S-1), and biaxial bending (S-2). The specimens were instrumented with 92 strain gauges and 16 dial meters to monitor deformation and stress distribution.
  2. Finite Element Analysis (FEA): 3D models were developed using ANSYS, employing SHELL 181 elements for steel and SOLID 65 for concrete. The models accounted for complex contact mechanics, including friction and potential separation between the steel and concrete.
  3. Analytical Derivation: A simplified calculation formula was derived by treating the multi-tube assembly as a lattice structure, simplifying connection plates into equivalent lacing bars for easier engineering application.
Experimental test setup showing the specimen within the reaction frame and the hydraulic loading system.

Key Findings

Structural Synergy

The experimental results confirmed that the mono-columns work together effectively as a single unit. The connection plates ensured the assembly acted as a single unit, preventing individual tubes from failing prematurely and ensuring the assembly reached its full structural potential.

Impact of Eccentric Loading

Eccentric loading—where the load is applied off-center—was found to be the critical design condition. The ultimate bearing capacity for specimens under eccentric load (S-1 and S-2) was approximately 57% lower than the axial control specimen (S-3). This reduction is primarily due to instability and buckling rather than material failure.

Predictive Accuracy

The proposed simplified formula demonstrated high accuracy when compared to experimental results, with errors ranging from 0.87% for axial loads to approximately 5.21% for biaxial bending. This validates the formula as a reliable tool for practical structural design.

Conclusion

L-shaped SCFT columns offer a robust and space-efficient alternative to traditional column designs. While eccentric loading significantly impacts their bearing capacity, the predictable nature of their failure and the accuracy of the proposed design formulas make them a viable option for high-performance residential structures. Future research will focus on long-term effects such as creep and fire performance to further refine the design guidelines.

Summary updated

Abstract

Concrete special-shaped columns have been studied and used in China for twenty years, and can be incorporated into walls to widen indoor areas. However, concrete special-shaped columns do not perform well under seismic action. In addition, special-shaped concrete-filled steel tubular columns were put forward and researched as well because of their high strength and ductility, but the interaction between steel and inner concrete is small. Tie rods are often set to solve the problem, which in turn affect the architectural appearance. To solve the above problems, a special-shaped column composed of concrete-filled steel tubes (SCFT) was proposed and studied. Axial loading behavior, seismic behavior, and whole structure behavior were studied. This type of special-shaped column has been used in residential buildings, and the structural behavior performed well. This paper experimentally investigated the biaxial loading behavior of L-shaped SCFT columns. Failure modes, cooperation of mono-columns, and the effects of eccentric angle and distance on column behavior were studied. Test results were compared with those of finite element analysis. A reasonable simplified calculating formula was proposed based on the study and was proved effectively through the comparison with test results. Mono-columns of SCFT columns proved to work well together. This kind of special-shaped column proved to be a good structure type.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2016eccentric,
  author = {T. Zhou and M.Y. Xu and Z.H. Chen and Xiaodong Wang and Y.W. Wang and Zhipeng Chen},
  title = {{ECCENTRIC LOADING BEHAVIOR OF L-SHAPED COLUMNS COMPOSED OF CONCRETE-FILLED STEEL TUBES}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.18057/ijasc.2016.12.3.2},
}
Figure