Experimental investigation on granite cutting by means of diamond frame saw

Junjie Wu, Jinsheng Zhang, Heng Zhang, Peiyu Dong, Congsen Ouyang, Kaida Wang

Abstract

A great quantity of granite sawing experiments was carried out to explore the cutting performance of a frame sawing machine with the horizontal reciprocating cutting mode. A model of average thickness of cutting chip was established, and characteristics of cutting forces were analyzed. The mechanism of wear was revealed by analyzing the width of the saw kerf and the wear morphology of the diamond segments. The results showed that the wear resistance and the cutting forces increase with the feed speed. The cutting forces change abruptly at the reversing point during granite cutting. At the same time, the proportion of macro-fractured and pulled-out particles and the mean wear rate of segments increase with the feed speed, and the mean protrusion height of the grits is less than 100 μm. The width of the saw kerf is gradually reduced as the sawing progresses, forming an inverted cone with a large upper side and a small lower side. Besides, the studies found that the wear of the segments remains consistent in two directions. The prominent phenomenon of the diamond particles on the side surface is more obvious as the feed speed increases. The research can provide certain data support for granite cutting and lay the foundation for the subsequent optimization of the structure and equipment.

Introduction

Granite is a staple of modern architecture and precision machinery, but its extreme hardness and brittleness make it notoriously difficult to process efficiently. While diamond circular saws and wire saws are well-studied, the diamond frame saw—which utilizes a horizontal reciprocating (back-and-forth) motion—remains less understood in research.

The challenge with frame saws lies in the harsh environment where diamond segments are subjected to constant impact and reversing directions, leading to rapid tool wear and decreased accuracy. This study investigates the cutting performance of these machines by modeling chip thickness and analyzing tool wear at the microscopic level to understand force spikes and the formation of non-uniform cut slots (kerfs).

Overview of the diamond frame saw machine (a) and the schematic diagram of the reciprocating cutting process (b).

Methodology

The researchers conducted experiments using a full-scale diamond frame saw. The workpiece was Brazilian gold granite, characterized by a Shore hardness of 97 and a high compressive strength of 166 MPa. The tooling consisted of diamond segments with an Iron-Copper-Cobalt matrix and a 40/50 mesh diamond particle size.

The experimental approach combined theoretical modeling with high-precision physical measurements:

  • Mathematical Modeling: A new model was developed to calculate the average thickness of a cutting chip, a critical factor influencing the forces acting on the tool.
  • Force Measurement: Cutting forces ($F_n$, $F_t$, and $F_z$) were measured using a Kistler dynamometer integrated into the work table setup.
  • Microscopic Analysis: Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and 3D imaging were used to categorize diamond wear into six distinct states. A laser scanning confocal microscope measured the protrusion height of the diamond grits.
Schematic of the experimental setup for measuring cutting forces using a dynamometer and data acquisition system.

Results and Discussion

Force Dynamics and the Reversing Point Spike

Cutting forces were found to increase significantly with feed speed, reaching a peak of approximately 164.124 N at a feed speed of 80 mm/h. A key observation was the abrupt force spike at the "reversing points" of the stroke. As the horizontal speed of the blade drops to zero to change direction, the vertical feed motor continues at a constant rate, creating a momentary "crunch" that places immense stress on the diamond segments.

Kerf Morphology: The Inverted Cone

The study revealed that the saw kerf is not perfectly rectangular but forms an inverted cone—wider at the top and narrower at the bottom. This phenomenon is attributed to blade vibration as forces increase and the progressive wear of the sides of the diamond segments, which narrows the effective cutting width as the blade penetrates deeper.

Diamond Wear and Self-Sharpening

Effective diamond tooling relies on the metal matrix wearing away at a rate that exposes new diamonds (self-sharpening). However, at higher feed speeds (80 mm/h), the proportion of macro-fractured and pulled-out diamond particles reached 40%. The mean protrusion height remained below 100 μm; exceeding this limit causes the forces to overcome the matrix's holding power, leading to particle loss. The mean wear rate of the segments jumped to 919.19 μm/m² at the highest tested feed rate.

Conclusion

The standard horizontal reciprocating frame saw faces fundamental challenges when processing granite due to blade instability and force spikes. Future improvements should focus on optimizing the mechanical structure to reduce blade "swing," developing metal matrices with higher holding forces, and exploring alternative reciprocating trajectories to mitigate stress at reversing points.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2021experimental,
  author = {Junjie Wu and Jinsheng Zhang and Heng Zhang and Peiyu Dong and Congsen Ouyang and Kaida Wang},
  title = {{Experimental investigation on granite cutting by means of diamond frame saw}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-855683/v1},
}
Figure