Experimental investigation of maldistribution characteristics of gas‐liquid two-phase flow in a horizontal pipeline

Na Wei, Lin Jiang, Shuanshi Fan, Anqi Liu, Haitao Li, Shenghui Zhang, Chao Zhang, Jin XueFrontiers in Earth Science 2022 · DOI

Abstract

In oil and gas gathering and transportation systems, factors such as flow pattern, inertia, and gravity often lead to uneven flow distribution across outlet pipes, impacting economic efficiency and safety. This study develops an experimental device to analyze gas-liquid two-phase flow maldistribution in horizontal pipelines under stratified, slug, and annular flow patterns. Results indicate that slug flow is most conducive to controlling liquid maldistribution in manifolds without flute pipes, while annular flow is optimal for gas distribution control. Surprisingly, the inclusion of internal "flute pipes" often exacerbated maldistribution. These findings provide a reference for field control of multi-phase flow in transportation systems.

Introduction

Efficiently splitting gas-liquid mixtures into multiple branches is a critical challenge in pipeline engineering. Ideally, a manifold should distribute phases proportionally to the branch outlets. However, the inherent differences in density and velocity between gas and liquid phases, coupled with gravitational and inertial forces, lead to "maldistribution." This phenomenon results in downstream processing inefficiencies and potential equipment damage. While hardware solutions like internal perforated "flute pipes" are commonly employed, their effectiveness across different horizontal flow regimes remains poorly understood.

Experimental Methodology

To investigate these dynamics, a specialized experimental rig was constructed. The setup featured a transparent 50mm diameter plexiglass manifold to allow for high-definition visual recording of flow patterns. A key component of the study was the "flute pipe"—a 20mm diameter internal distributor with multiple perforations.

Schematic of the experimental rig (A) and the internal flute pipe design (B).

The experiments utilized air and dyed water to simulate multi-phase flow. Liquid distribution was measured using electronic scales, while gas distribution was tracked via anemometers at the outlets. The researchers tested 18 distinct flow conditions, with gas flow rates ranging from 2.09 to 26.64 L/s and liquid flow rates from 0.10 to 0.65 L/s.

The physical experimental setup showing the gas and liquid inlets and the manifold containing the flute pipe.

Results and Discussion

The study quantified the "maldistribution degree"—the percentage deviation from a perfect split. The data revealed several key insights:

The Flute Pipe Paradox

Contrary to conventional wisdom, adding a flute pipe often worsened distribution. In slug flow, liquid maldistribution jumped from 5.16% to 25.29% upon the addition of the flute pipe. This is attributed to the reduced cross-sectional area within the main pipe, which increases fluid velocity and induces higher turbulence and instability.

Impact of Flow Patterns

Flow regimes played a dominant role in distribution stability:

  • Slug Flow: Proved most stable for liquid distribution when no flute pipe was present (average 5.16% maldistribution).
  • Annular Flow: Offered the best gas distribution control without a flute pipe (average 3.02% maldistribution).

Maldistribution does not follow a linear path relative to gas-liquid ratios. Instead, it exhibits a "zigzag" pattern. For instance, in stratified flow, liquid maldistribution may remain stable before peaking sharply as flow conditions shift, reflecting the complex interplay of forces at the gas-liquid interface.

Conclusion

This research suggests that for horizontal manifolds, the most effective control strategy may be to avoid internal distributors like flute pipes and instead manage flow velocities to maintain favorable regimes (slug for liquid, annular for gas). While these results provide a strong foundation, future work should address the limitations of using air-water mixtures versus real-world hydrocarbons, as well as the effects of pipeline inclination and larger industrial scales.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the flow distribution of oil and gas gathering and transportation system, the flow pattern, inertia force, gravity, and other factors will lead to uneven flow distribution of each outlet pipe, which will seriously affect the economy and safety of the gathering and transportation system. Therefore, it is of great significance to analyze the characteristics of gas–liquid two-phase flow in horizontal pipelines. For this reason, an experimental device for maldistribution control of gas–liquid two-phase flow is developed in this article. In order to solve the problem of flow maldistribution in gas–liquid two-phase flow pipe, the test experiments of maldistribution control under the conditions of three flow patterns (stratified flow, slug flow, and annular flow) are carried out. Through experiments, we revealed the control law of flow pattern to liquid maldistribution and gas maldistribution with or without flute pipes and formed the maldistribution control scheme of gas–liquid two-phase flow in the horizontal pipeline. It is found that it is more beneficial to the control of average liquid maldistribution degree under the condition of slug flow pattern in horizontal manifold without flute pipe, and it is more beneficial to the control of average gas maldistribution degree under the condition of annular flow pattern without flute pipe. Without the function of the flute pipe and in the annular flow pattern, it is beneficial to the control of average maldistribution degree of gas–liquid two-phase flow. The findings of this research can be used as a reference for the field maldistribution control of oil and gas gathering and transportation systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2022experimental,
  author = {Na Wei and Lin Jiang and Shuanshi Fan and Anqi Liu and Haitao Li and Shenghui Zhang and Chao Zhang and Jin Xue},
  title = {{Experimental investigation of maldistribution characteristics of gas‐liquid two-phase flow in a horizontal pipeline}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2022.853809},
}
Figure