Analysis of flow uniformity of parallel pipe group with axial inlet

Si Qin, Xiaojun ZhouVibroengineering 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the flow distribution characteristics within parallel pipe systems featuring an axial inlet, a common configuration in industrial heat exchangers and boilers. Using the FLUENT fluid simulation module in ANSYS WORKBENCH, we performed numerical simulations to evaluate the impact of mass flow rates, main pipe diameter, and branch spacing on flow uniformity. Our results indicate that the diameter of the main intake pipe is the primary determinant of flow distribution, whereas branch spacing has a negligible effect.

Introduction

In engineering applications like heat exchangers, solar collectors, and industrial boilers, "parallel pipe groups" are used to distribute fluids across multiple channels. Ideally, every branch should receive the exact same amount of fluid to ensure even heat exchange and prevent mechanical issues. However, fluid dynamics are rarely that cooperative. Due to the geometry of the headers and the complexity of turbulent flow, some pipes often receive significantly more fluid than others. This "flow unevenness" can lead to uneven thermal stresses, increased noise, and harmful vibrations. This paper identifies which design variables—flow velocity, pipe diameter, or branch spacing—actually dictate this uniformity.

Methods

The researchers employed a numerical simulation approach using the FLUENT module within ANSYS WORKBENCH. A simplified 3D model of a purge air path was created, consisting of a main intake manifold, five branch pipes, and ten total outlets.

Figure 2: 3D model of the parallel pipe group used for CFD simulation, showing the main intake pipe and branch outlets.

The fluid domain was divided into a high-resolution mesh with approximately 1.39 million nodes to ensure calculation accuracy. The study used the Standard $k-\epsilon$ turbulence model to simulate air flow. Boundary conditions were set as "Mass-Flow-inlet" for the intake and a default pressure boundary for the outlets. The study systematically varied the intake mass flow (0.01 to 0.1 kg/s), the main pipe diameter (40mm to 80mm), and the interval length between branches (300mm to 1000mm).

Key Results and Discussion

The authors used a non-dimensional "unevenness coefficient" to quantify their findings. The most significant insight is the dramatic impact of the manifold diameter on flow distribution.

Figure 6: Comparison of flow unevenness coefficients across five pipes. Plot (a) demonstrates high unevenness under restricted geometry (40mm diameter), while plot (c) shows improved uniformity as the diameter is increased (60mm).

Diameter is the Dominant Factor

Increasing the diameter of the main intake pipe reduces internal pressure gradients and velocity, allowing the fluid to distribute itself much more naturally across the branches. When the main pipe diameter was only 40mm (Figure 6a), the flow was highly uneven, with the maximum flow in a branch being roughly 8 times higher than the minimum flow. When the diameter was increased to 80mm, the flow became almost perfectly uniform across all five pipes.

The Velocity Penalty

The study confirms that higher gas velocities exacerbate distribution problems. As the mass flow rate increases, the momentum of the air makes it harder for the fluid to "turn" into the early branches, leading to a higher concentration of flow in the branches furthest from the inlet.

The Spacing Myth

Interestingly, the researchers found that the interval length between branch pipes has almost no impact on flow uniformity. Changing the interval length from 300mm to 1000mm resulted in nearly identical flow curves. This suggests that designers have significant flexibility in branch placement without compromising flow balance.

Conclusion

To achieve uniform air distribution in parallel pipe systems with axial inlets, increasing the diameter of the main intake pipe is the most effective strategy. While higher flow rates negatively impact uniformity, the physical spacing between branches is a negligible factor. Future research should explore non-isothermal conditions and different fluid types to broaden the applicability of these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper analyzes the flow uniformity based on the parallel pipe group model with an axial inlet. This paper is mainly based on the FLUENT fluid simulation module in ANSYS WORKBENCH, numerical simulation analysis of the established parallel pipe group model, and the law of uniformity of flow distribution under different mass flow conditions is obtained. The diameter of the main intake pipe of the parallel pipe group and the interval length of the branch intake pipes are changed. Under a large number of simulation conditions, the law of uniformity of flow distribution under different conditions is explored.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qin2021analysis,
  author = {Si Qin and Xiaojun Zhou},
  title = {{Analysis of flow uniformity of parallel pipe group with axial inlet}},
  booktitle = {Vibroengineering},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21595/vp.2021.22241},
}
Figure