Estimating the potential to prevent locally acquired HIV infections in a UNAIDS Fast-Track City, Amsterdam

Alexandra Blenkinsop, Mélodie Monod, Ard van Sighem, Nikos Pantazis, Daniela Bezemer, Eline Op de Coul, Thijs van de Laar, Christophe Fraser, Maria Prins, Peter Reiss, Godelieve de Bree, Oliver Ratmann

TL;DR

By combining clinical biomarkers with viral phylogenetics and Bayesian branching models, researchers have mapped the "hidden" side of HIV transmission in Amsterdam. The study reveals that while the city has made massive strides, a significant majority of new infections—particularly among foreign-born men who have sex with men (MSM)—are acquired locally, suggesting that intensified urban-level interventions could still prevent hundreds of cases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The UNAIDS "Fast-Track Cities" initiative aims for zero new HIV infections by 2030. Amsterdam is a frontrunner in this effort, yet new diagnoses persist. To reach zero, public health officials need to solve a difficult puzzle: Are people bringing HIV into the city from elsewhere (importation), or is it spreading silently within the city's own social networks (local transmission)?

This is difficult to answer because of "late presenters"—individuals who may have been infected for years before being diagnosed. These gaps in timing and the fact that not every person with HIV is sequenced or even diagnosed make it hard to reconstruct transmission chains accurately. This paper seeks to quantify the "undiagnosed fraction" and the "locally acquired fraction" to identify exactly where prevention efforts (like PrEP and testing) should be targeted.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-stage analytical pipeline:

  • Infection Dating: They used a bivariate linear mixed model based on longitudinal CD4 counts and viral load data to back-calculate the likely date of infection for individuals in the cohort.
  • Phylogenetic Reconstruction: By comparing HIV-1 pol sequences from Amsterdam residents against a massive background of Dutch and international sequences (>82,000), they reconstructed "transmission chains."
  • Bayesian Branching Process Model: This is the paper's core innovation. Because the phylogenetic trees are "incomplete" (due to undiagnosed or unsequenced individuals), the authors used a Bayesian model to estimate the actual growth of these chains. This allowed them to infer the existence of "unsampled" links in the chain and estimate the proportion of infections that originated from a source within Amsterdam.
  • Stratification: The analysis broke down results into nine risk groups based on transmission mode (MSM vs. heterosexual) and region of birth.

Datasets

  • ATHENA Cohort: A prospective clinical database of all people living with HIV (PLHIV) in care in the Netherlands.
  • CASCADE Collaboration: A large dataset of individuals with known infection dates used to calibrate the biomarker model for estimating infection timing.
  • Los Alamos HIV-1 Sequence Database: Used to provide the international context for phylogenetic analysis, helping distinguish local clusters from global ones.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "U=U" Validation: One of the most striking findings was that transmission almost entirely stopped in chains where all members were virally suppressed by 2014. This provides powerful population-level evidence that "Undetectable = Untransmittable" (U=U) works.
  • Local Acquisition in Migrants: A critical "aha moment" was the realization that the majority of infections in foreign-born MSM were acquired locally in Amsterdam, rather than being imported. This shifts the policy focus from "screening at the border" to "providing better local prevention for migrant communities."
  • The Heterosexual Gap: Heterosexual individuals are diagnosed much later than MSM (median time to diagnosis of ~2 years vs. ~0.8 years) and have a much higher undiagnosed fraction (44% vs. 20%). This suggests that HIV is often "off the radar" for both heterosexual residents and their healthcare providers.

Key Results

  • Undiagnosed Fraction: As of 2019, an estimated 20% of MSM and 44% of heterosexuals infected between 2014–2018 remained undiagnosed.
  • Locally Acquired Infections: Approximately 68% of new infections among MSM and 57% among heterosexuals were acquired from a source within Amsterdam.
  • Primary Risk Group: Foreign-born MSM represent the largest group of local transmissions, followed closely by Dutch-born MSM.
  • Declining Trends: While Amsterdam remains a "hotspot" compared to the rest of the Netherlands, annual diagnoses dropped from 300 in 2010 to 120 in 2018.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sequence Coverage: About 33% of MSM and 37% of heterosexual diagnoses lacked viral sequences, which increases uncertainty in the phylogenetic reconstructions.
  • Migrant Acquisition Timing: While the model suggests local acquisition, the authors acknowledge the difficulty in perfectly distinguishing between infection just before arrival vs. just after arrival without precise migration dates.
  • The COVID-19 Factor: The study covers the period up to 2018. The authors note that the COVID-19 pandemic significantly disrupted testing and PrEP services, meaning the dynamics of these transmission chains may have shifted in the years since.
  • Future Direction: The authors suggest that routine monitoring of the "suppression status" of entire transmission chains (rather than just individuals) could be a vital tool for the "last mile" of HIV elimination.

Summary updated

Abstract

Amsterdam and other UNAIDS Fast-Track cities aim for zero new HIV infections. Utilising molecular and clinical data of the ATHENA observational HIV cohort, our primary aims are to estimate the proportion of undiagnosed HIV infections and the proportion of locally acquired infections in Amsterdam in 2014-2018, both in MSM and heterosexuals and Dutch-born and foreign-born individuals. We located diagnosed HIV infections in Amsterdam using postcode data at time of registration to the cohort, and estimated their date of infection using clinical HIV data. We then inferred the proportion undiagnosed from the estimated times to diagnosis. To determine sources of Amsterdam infections, we used HIV sequences of people living with HIV (PLHIV) within a background of other Dutch and international sequences to phylogenetically reconstruct transmission chains. Frequent late diagnoses indicate that more recent phylogenetically observed chains are increasingly incomplete, and we use a Bayesian model to estimate the actual growth of Amsterdam transmission chains, and the proportion of locally acquired infections. We estimate that 20% [95% CrI 18-22%] of infections acquired among MSM between 2014-2018 were undiagnosed by the start of 2019, and 44% [37-50%] among heterosexuals, with variation by place of birth. The estimated proportion of MSM infections in 2014-2018 that were locally acquired was 68% [61-74%], with no substantial differences by region of birth. In heterosexuals, this was 57% [41-71%] overall, with heterogeneity by place of birth. The data indicate substantial potential to further curb local transmission, in both MSM and heterosexual Amsterdam residents. In 2014-2018 the largest proportion of local transmissions in Amsterdam are estimated to have occurred in foreign-born MSM, who would likely benefit most from intensified interventions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{blenkinsop2022estimating,
  author = {Alexandra Blenkinsop and Mélodie Monod and Ard van Sighem and Nikos Pantazis and Daniela Bezemer and Eline Op de Coul and Thijs van de Laar and Christophe Fraser and Maria Prins and Peter Reiss and Godelieve de Bree and Oliver Ratmann},
  title = {{Estimating the potential to prevent locally acquired HIV infections in a UNAIDS Fast-Track City, Amsterdam}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.76487},
}
Figure