TL;DR
This study uses a novel combination of HIV viral sequence data and clinical records to reconstruct HIV transmission chains in Amsterdam. The findings reveal that a significant portion of new HIV infections in Amsterdam are locally acquired and preventable through targeted interventions, particularly among men who have sex with men (MSM).
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Cities worldwide are participating in the UNAIDS Fast-Track Cities initiative, aiming to end the AIDS epidemic by 2030. A critical step in achieving this goal is understanding the extent to which HIV infections are acquired locally within a city, as these are the infections that can be directly impacted by local public health efforts. Amsterdam, a UNAIDS Fast-Track City, has a history of high HIV burden, particularly among men who have sex with men (MSM) and foreign-born individuals. This paper aims to quantify the proportion of HIV infections in Amsterdam that originated from within the city (locally acquired) and remained undiagnosed, providing crucial data for optimizing prevention strategies.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining epidemiological and phylogenetic methods.
- Estimating Infection Dates: They used clinical biomarker data (CD4 counts and viral load) from the ATHENA HIV cohort to estimate the time of HIV infection for each individual. This involved a Bayesian approach to model the joint evolution of these biomarkers over time since infection.
- Reconstructing Transmission Chains: HIV viral sequences (specifically the pol gene) were used to reconstruct phylogenetic trees. These trees, combined with the estimated infection dates and patient data (risk group, region of birth), allowed for the identification of phylogenetically distinct clusters of infections, interpreted as parts of transmission chains. A tool called "phyloscanner" was used to group sequences into these subgraphs.
- Modeling Transmission Chain Growth: A Bayesian Negative Binomial branching process model was developed to estimate the size, growth, and origins of both observed and unobserved transmission chains. This model accounts for undiagnosed infections and unsampled viral sequences.
- Estimating Locally Acquired Infections: By combining the reconstructed transmission chains with estimates of infection origins and the proportion of infections that were locally preventable (i.e., had an Amsterdam resident as the source), the study quantified the proportion of infections that could be averted by city-level interventions.
Datasets
The primary dataset used in this study was derived from the ATHENA observational HIV cohort, which includes longitudinal data on people living with HIV (PLHIV) in care in the Netherlands. This dataset contains:
- Patient demographics
- Clinical biomarker data (CD4 counts, viral load)
- Viral sequence data (HIV pol gene)
- Treatment data
Additionally, publicly available HIV viral sequences were retrieved from the Los Alamos HIV-1 sequence database to provide a broader phylogenetic context.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Power of Combined Data: This study highlights the immense value of integrating diverse data sources – clinical, epidemiological, and genetic – to gain a comprehensive understanding of HIV transmission dynamics.
- Local Prevention is Key: The findings strongly suggest that a substantial proportion of new HIV infections in Amsterdam are locally acquired, meaning they are directly preventable through targeted city-level interventions. This underscores the importance of the Fast-Track Cities initiative.
- MSM Remain a Priority: The burden of locally acquired infections is heavily concentrated among MSM, indicating that intensified prevention efforts for this group are crucial.
- Undiagnosed Infections are a Bottleneck: A significant proportion of infections, particularly among heterosexual individuals, remain undiagnosed for extended periods. This delays diagnosis and treatment, potentially fueling further transmission.
- Transmission Chains are Complex: The study reveals that while emerging chains are important, a considerable number of new infections still originate from pre-existing transmission chains, emphasizing the need for sustained efforts to interrupt ongoing transmission.
Key Results
- Between January 2014 and May 2019, there were 846 HIV diagnoses in Amsterdam residents.
- Of these, 516 (61%) were estimated to have been infected between 2014 and 2018.
- The rate of new Amsterdam diagnoses (104 per 100,000) remained higher than the national average (24 per 100,000), confirming Amsterdam as a HIV hotspot.
- An estimated 14% [12-16%] of infections in Amsterdam MSM in 2014-2018 remained undiagnosed by May 2019, compared to 41% [35–48%] in Amsterdam heterosexuals.
- An estimated 67% [60–74%] of Amsterdam MSM infections in 2014-2018 had an Amsterdam resident as the source (locally preventable).
- For Amsterdam heterosexuals, 56% [41–70%] of infections were locally preventable.
- Of the locally acquired infections, 43% [37-49%] were in foreign-born MSM, 41% [35–47%] in Dutch-born MSM, 10% [6-18%] in foreign-born heterosexuals, and 5% [2-9%] in Dutch-born heterosexuals.
Limitations and Future Work
- Exact Infection Location: The study acknowledges that the exact location of infection events cannot be definitively identified, but rather inferred from residence data. However, the authors argue that Amsterdam residents are within reach of local interventions regardless of the precise infection location.
- Time-to-Diagnosis Trends: The biomarker-based approach to estimating infection dates has limitations in accounting for time trends in time-to-diagnosis, particularly after 2015 when treatment guidelines changed.
- Undiagnosed Proportions: While the study provides estimates for undiagnosed infections, these are subject to assumptions about incidence trends and diagnostic delays. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to explore these impacts.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that these findings are relevant to other UNAIDS Fast-Track Cities and provide evidence-based support for targeted combination HIV prevention interventions in metropolitan areas. They emphasize the need for innovative and targeted HIV prevention approaches, especially given the disruption caused by COVID-19.
Summary updated