Estimating life-cycle energy payback ratio of overhead transmission line toward low carbon development

Xiaoming Dong, Chongqing Kang, Ning Zhang, Huaguang Yan, Meng Junxia, Xinsheng Niu, Xin TianJournal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Energy conservation plays a vital role in low-carbon development. To evaluate energy conservation across the full life-cycle of power infrastructure, this paper proposes a scheme to estimate the energy consumption—or "energy pay"—involved in constructing overhead transmission lines (OTLs). While construction is energy-intensive, the addition of new lines typically reduces power network losses, a benefit defined here as "energy payback." The proposed estimation scheme integrates load forecasting, production simulation for generating systems, load flow simulation, and power loss calculation. Case studies using the IEEE 24-bus test system demonstrate the efficacy of the scheme, comparing several presumptive scenarios to quantify the net energy benefits of grid expansion.

Introduction

In the pursuit of a low-carbon economy, the power sector often focuses on the carbon intensity of generation. However, the energy footprint of the physical infrastructure required to transport that power is equally significant. Building a transmission line requires mining, manufacturing, and transporting thousands of tons of steel, aluminum, and concrete.

This research addresses a fundamental question: Does the energy saved by improving grid efficiency (reducing operational power losses) outweigh the energy spent to build the new line? To answer this, the authors develop a methodology to quantify the "Energy Consumption of Construction" (ECC) versus the "Energy Consumption of Operation" (ECO), ultimately calculating an Energy Payback Ratio ($R_{PB}$).

Methodology

Quantifying Construction Energy (ECC)

The authors calculate the energy required to produce and install all components of a typical OTL project, including conductors, towers, and insulators. To create a universal metric, they use "kilograms of standard coal equivalent" (kgce) to sum the energy costs of disparate materials.

Analysis of a 33.8 km, 230 kV double-circuit transmission line reveals that the conductor is the most energy-expensive component, accounting for 56.69% of the total ECC. This high percentage is primarily due to the energy-intensive nature of aluminum production.

Simulating Operational Savings (ECO)

To determine the energy "payback," the authors utilize a four-step simulation framework:

  1. Load Forecasting: Predicting future power demand to set the baseline.
  2. Production Simulation: Employing a security-constrained Unit Commitment (UC) model to optimize generator outputs.
  3. Load Flow Simulation: Calculating the physical movement of power through the grid.
  4. Loss Calculation: Determining the total network power loss before and after the addition of the new line.

Results and Grid Topology

The core metric, the Energy Payback Ratio ($R_{PB}$), is defined as the ratio of annual energy saved to the total energy spent on construction. The study tested four presumptive connection scenarios on the IEEE 24-bus system to see how location affects efficiency.

Schematic representation of transmission line connection scenarios used in the energy payback analysis.

The results indicate that the energy payback is remarkably rapid. The calculated ratios ranged from 133% to 237%. A ratio of 237% implies that the energy cost of construction is recovered in roughly five months of operation. Furthermore, the study highlights that "location matters"; where a new line is integrated into the grid drastically changes its potential to reduce system-wide losses.

Conclusion

While the construction of overhead transmission lines represents a massive initial energy investment, the resulting improvements in network efficiency provide a rapid and substantial energy return. Given that OTLs typically have a service life exceeding 30 years, the life-cycle energy "profit" is enormous, supporting the role of strategic grid expansion in low-carbon development. Future work may expand this framework to include the dismantling and recycling phases and more explicitly link energy savings to $CO_2$ emission reductions based on regional grid carbon intensities.

Summary updated

Abstract

The energy conservation plays an important role for low carbon development. In order to evaluate the energy conservation in the full life-cycle, a scheme to estimate the energy consumption, or alternatively the energy pay, in constructing an overhead transmission line is proposed in this paper. The analysis of a typical projection is given for demonstration. With new additional overhead transmission lines, the energy consumption, known as the power loss in power network, is expected to be decline, which is defined in this paper as the energy payback. In order to estimate this kind of contribution, the scheme that consisted of load forecast, production simulation for generating systems, load flow simulation and power loss calculation has been proposed. Case studies, based on the IEEE 24-bus test system, are given to demonstrate the efficacy of the schemes. Moreover, several presumptive scenarios are deployed and analysed with the presented schemes for comparison.
BibTeX
@article{dong2014estimating,
  author = {Xiaoming Dong and Chongqing Kang and Ning Zhang and Huaguang Yan and Meng Junxia and Xinsheng Niu and Xin Tian},
  title = {{Estimating life-cycle energy payback ratio of overhead transmission line toward low carbon development}},
  journal = {Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/s40565-014-0082-y},
}
Figure