Cost calculation method and application of GIS equipment in substation based on asset life cycle management theory

Shan Jiang, Ran Chen, Yingbo Zhou, Zhu Li, Qi JianAtlantis 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

With the continuous advancement of the construction of smart grids, new situations, new demands and new development models have put forward higher requirements for substations, which are important supporting nodes of the power grid. In this paper, the implementation of asset life cycle management in substation engineering projects is to conduct overall and entire process management of all stages and activities in the asset life cycle of substation engineering projects. Starting from the overall project, reflecting the requirements of the entire life cycle of the project, it not only includes the goals of the construction period, but also pays more attention to the operation phase of the project, and highlights the overall efficiency and benefits of project management. Life cycle cost theory can indeed achieve good effects such as reducing the life cycle cost of substation engineering and improving reliability.

Introduction

Traditionally, substation projects have been evaluated based on their initial investment and construction costs. However, as smart grids evolve, power companies face a more complex reality: equipment load, geographical environment, and varying supplier quality drastically affect long-term reliability and maintenance workloads. This paper addresses the challenge of Asset Life Cycle Management (LCAM) by providing a rigorous mathematical method to calculate the total cost of ownership for Gas-Insulated Switchgear (GIS) equipment, specifically comparing indoor versus outdoor configurations.

Methodology and Data

The authors define a total Life Cycle Cost (LCC) formula: $$LCC = CI + CO + CM + CF + CD$$ Where $CI$ represents investment, $CO$ operating, $CM$ maintenance, $CF$ failure, and $CD$ decommissioning costs.

To calculate the "Failure Cost" ($CF$), the study moves beyond local substation impacts. Using an IEEE 5-node test network, the authors employ a nonlinear primal-dual interior point algorithm in MATLAB to simulate how a failure at one node causes load reductions across the entire grid.

The IEEE 5-node test network used to simulate grid-wide failure impacts.

The study utilizes historical cost data from ERP systems (2015–2019) and long-term data from substations with over 40 years of operating history to model degradation and failure trends.

Key Insights and Results

The most significant finding is the "20-Year Crossover" between indoor and outdoor GIS. While indoor GIS requires a higher initial investment, its protection from environmental stressors leads to much lower maintenance and failure costs over time.

Comparison of cumulative LCC for indoor vs. outdoor GIS over 40 years.

As shown in the figure above, the cumulative cost of an outdoor substation overtakes that of an indoor one around the 20-year mark. This is largely due to the increasing probability of failure as outdoor equipment ages under environmental exposure. By treating reliability as a quantifiable financial risk, the authors demonstrate that the initial "sticker price" is a poor indicator of long-term value.

Limitations and Future Work

While recent data is robust, historical data for older substations is often estimated. Additionally, the "Electricity Production Ratio" used to translate power loss into economic loss varies by region, making global standardization difficult. Future work will focus on integrating Building Information Modeling (BIM) and cloud-based platforms for real-time LCC management.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the continuous advancement of the construction of smart grids, new situations, new demands and new development models have put forward higher requirements for substations, which are important supporting nodes of the power grid.In this paper, the implementation of asset life cycle management in substation engineering projects is to conduct overall and entire process management of all stages and activities in the asset life cycle of substation engineering projects.Starting from the overall project, reflecting the requirements of the entire life cycle of the project, it not only includes the goals of the construction period, but also pays more attention to the operation phase of the project, and highlights the overall efficiency and benefits of project management.Life cycle cost theory can indeed achieve good effects such as reducing the life cycle cost of substation engineering and improving reliability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2023cost,
  author = {Shan Jiang and Ran Chen and Yingbo Zhou and Zhu Li and Qi Jian},
  title = {{Cost calculation method and application of GIS equipment in substation based on asset life cycle management theory}},
  booktitle = {Atlantis},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-056-5\_100},
}
Figure