Abstract
A novel modulation scheme termed orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing with subcarrier number modulation (OFDM-SNM) has been proposed and regarded as one of the promising candidate modulation schemes for next generation networks. Although OFDM-SNM is capable of having a higher spectral efficiency (SE) than OFDM with index modulation (OFDM-IM) and plain OFDM under certain conditions, its reliability is relatively inferior to these existing schemes, because the number of active subcarriers varies. In this regard, we propose an enhanced OFDM-SNM scheme in this paper, which utilizes the flexibility of placing subcarriers to harvest a coding gain in the high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) region. In particular, we stipulate a methodology that optimizes the subcarrier activation pattern (SAP) by subcarrier assignment using instantaneous channel state information (CSI) and therefore the subcarriers with higher channel power gains will be granted the priority to be activated, given the number of subcarriers is fixed. We also analyze the proposed enhanced OFDM-SNM system in terms of outage and error performance. The average outage probability and block error rate (BLER) are derived and approximated in closed-form expressions, which are further verified by numerical results generated by Monte Carlo simulations. The high-reliability nature of the enhanced OFDM-SNM makes it a promising candidate for implementing in the Internet of Things (IoT) with stationary machine-type devices (MTDs), which are subject to slow fading and supported by proper power supply.
Introduction
In the quest for higher data rates in 5G and beyond, researchers have moved beyond standard Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing (OFDM). While Index Modulation (OFDM-IM) was a breakthrough—using the indices of active subcarriers to carry extra information bits—it relies on a fixed number of active subcarriers, which inherently limits its maximum spectral efficiency.
Subcarrier Number Modulation (OFDM-SNM) emerged as a solution to this limitation. Instead of relying on specific indices, SNM uses the number of active subcarriers to convey information. However, this flexibility comes at a cost: SNM typically suffers from lower reliability compared to IM because the varying number of active subcarriers can lead to patterns that are more prone to errors. This paper addresses this reliability gap by introducing a "channel-aware" enhancement to the SNM framework.
Proposed Methodology
The core innovation of this work is the introduction of CSI-based Subcarrier Assignment. By utilizing instantaneous channel state information (CSI), the transmitter can intelligently select which subcarriers to activate based on their current channel conditions.
As shown in the transmitter architecture, the incoming bitstream is split into "heading bits" and "subsequent bits." The heading bits determine the number of active subcarriers ($T$), while the subsequent bits are mapped to conventional M-PSK symbols. Unlike the original SNM, where subcarrier selection was fixed or arbitrary, the enhanced version ranks all $N$ subcarriers by their power gains and activates the $T$ "best" subcarriers.
To evaluate this system, the authors derived closed-form expressions for the Average Outage Probability and Average Block Error Rate (BLER) using order statistics. This mathematical framework describes the selection of the $T$-th best subcarrier out of $N$ available ones. At the receiver, a Maximum-Likelihood (ML) detector is employed to simultaneously identify the number of active subcarriers and the symbols they convey.
Performance Analysis and Results
The performance of the enhanced OFDM-SNM scheme was validated through extensive Monte Carlo simulations under slow Rayleigh fading channel models, typical for stationary IoT devices.
Key findings from the analysis include:
- Significant Reliability Gains: The enhanced scheme achieves a notable "coding shift" compared to the original SNM. For a system with $N=4$ subcarriers, a gain of approximately 2 dB is observed. This increases to ~4 dB for $N=8$, demonstrating that the benefits of subcarrier assignment scale with the number of subcarriers.
- Coding vs. Diversity Gain: While the subcarrier assignment provides a coding gain (shifting the error curve), it does not provide a diversity gain (the slope of the curve remains the same). This is because the system is still constrained by patterns that may require using all subcarriers, including those with poorer channel conditions.
- Mathematical Validation: The derived analytical expressions for BLER and outage probability show a near-perfect match with simulation results, confirming the robustness of the theoretical model.
Conclusion and Future Work
The enhanced OFDM-SNM scheme offers a promising balance between high spectral efficiency and improved reliability, making it particularly suitable for Internet of Things (IoT) applications involving stationary machine-type devices (MTDs). In such scenarios, the slow-fading nature of the channel makes the overhead of CSI feedback manageable.
Future research will focus on reducing the computational complexity of ML detection, perhaps through subcarrier grouping. Additionally, exploring non-uniform power allocation across active subcarriers and investigating performance in multi-user environments with interference remain key areas for further development.
Summary updated