Enhanced Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing With Subcarrier Number Modulation

Shuping Dang, Guoqing Ma, Basem Shihada, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

TL;DR

This paper introduces an "enhanced" version of Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing with Subcarrier Number Modulation (OFDM-SNM). By using instantaneous channel state information (CSI) to prioritize the strongest subcarriers for activation, the authors achieve significant reliability improvements (coding gains of 2–4 dB) over the original SNM scheme without sacrificing its high spectral efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the quest for higher data rates in 5G and beyond, researchers have moved beyond standard OFDM. Index Modulation (OFDM-IM) was a breakthrough, using the indices of active subcarriers to carry extra information bits. However, OFDM-IM uses a fixed number of active subcarriers, which limits its maximum spectral efficiency.

Subcarrier Number Modulation (OFDM-SNM) was proposed as a "sibling" to IM. Instead of looking at which subcarriers are active, it uses the number of active subcarriers to convey bits. While SNM can reach higher data rates than IM, it suffers from lower reliability because the number of active subcarriers varies, and some patterns are more prone to errors than others. The authors aim to bridge this reliability gap by making the system "channel-aware."

Methods

The core innovation is the introduction of CSI-based Subcarrier Assignment.

  1. The Mapping: Like standard SNM, the incoming bitstream is split. "Heading bits" determine how many subcarriers ($T$) will be active. "Subsequent bits" are mapped to conventional M-PSK symbols.
  2. The Enhancement: In the original SNM, the specific subcarriers chosen to be active were essentially arbitrary or fixed. In this enhanced version, the transmitter uses instantaneous CSI to rank all $N$ subcarriers by their power gains. It then activates the $T$ "best" subcarriers.
  3. Analytical Modeling: The authors don't just simulate; they derive closed-form expressions for the Average Outage Probability and Average Block Error Rate (BLER). They utilize order statistics to mathematically describe the behavior of selecting the $T$-th best subcarrier out of $N$ available ones.
  4. Detection: The receiver uses a Maximum-Likelihood (ML) detector to simultaneously determine the number of active subcarriers (the bits) and the symbols they carry.

Datasets

As a theoretical communication theory paper, no external real-world datasets were used. The results were validated using:

  • Monte Carlo Simulations: Extensive numerical simulations were conducted to verify the mathematical derivations.
  • Standard Fading Models: The system was tested under a slow Rayleigh fading channel model, which is standard for analyzing stationary or slow-moving wireless devices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Coding Gain vs. Diversity Gain: A crucial finding is that while subcarrier assignment provides a "coding gain" (shifting the error performance curve to the left, meaning you need less power for the same error rate), it does not provide "diversity gain" (it doesn't change the slope of the curve). This is because, in some bit patterns, the system is still forced to use all subcarriers, including the "bad" ones.
  • The "Worst-Case" Bottleneck: The system's outage performance is dominated by the "worst" active subcarrier in any given pattern. By picking the best $T$ subcarriers, the authors effectively raise the floor of the "worst" subcarrier.
  • IoT Suitability: The authors argue this scheme is particularly well-suited for the Internet of Things (IoT). Stationary devices (like smart meters) experience "slow fading," meaning the channel doesn't change rapidly. This makes the overhead of obtaining and using CSI manageable.

Key Results

  • Reliability Boost: The enhanced scheme showed a constructive "coding shift" compared to original SNM. For a system with 4 subcarriers ($N=4$), they achieved a ~2 dB gain. For $N=8$, the gain increased to ~4 dB.
  • Throughput Convergence: At high Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR), the throughput of the enhanced scheme converges to the theoretical maximum, outperforming both plain OFDM and OFDM-IM in specific configurations.
  • Mathematical Accuracy: The derived closed-form approximations for BLER and outage probability matched the Monte Carlo simulation results almost perfectly, providing a robust tool for future system design.

Limitations and Future Work

  • CSI Overhead: The system relies on the transmitter having accurate, instantaneous CSI. While the authors argue this is fine for slow-fading IoT scenarios, it could become a bottleneck in high-mobility environments (like V2X communications) where the channel changes faster than feedback can be sent.
  • Detection Complexity: ML detection is optimal but computationally expensive as the number of subcarriers $N$ or the modulation order $M$ increases. The authors suggest that subcarrier grouping is necessary to keep $N$ small for practical implementation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring Power Allocation (distributing power non-uniformly across active subcarriers) and investigating how this scheme behaves in multi-user scenarios with significant interference.

Summary updated

Abstract

A novel modulation scheme termed orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing with subcarrier number modulation (OFDM-SNM) has been proposed and regarded as one of the promising candidate modulation schemes for next generation networks. Although OFDM-SNM is capable of having a higher spectral efficiency (SE) than OFDM with index modulation (OFDM-IM) and plain OFDM under certain conditions, its reliability is relatively inferior to these existing schemes, because the number of active subcarriers varies. In this regard, we propose an enhanced OFDM-SNM scheme in this paper, which utilizes the flexibility of placing subcarriers to harvest a coding gain in the high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) region. In particular, we stipulate a methodology that optimizes the subcarrier activation pattern (SAP) by subcarrier assignment using instantaneous channel state information (CSI) and therefore the subcarriers with higher channel power gains will be granted the priority to be activated, given the number of subcarriers is fixed. We also analyze the proposed enhanced OFDM-SNM system in terms of outage and error performance. The average outage probability and block error rate (BLER) are derived and approximated in closed-form expressions, which are further verified by numerical results generated by Monte Carlo simulations. The high-reliability nature of the enhanced OFDM-SNM makes it a promising candidate for implementing in the Internet of Things (IoT) with stationary machine-type devices (MTDs), which are subject to slow fading and supported by proper power supply.
BibTeX
@article{dang2019enhanced,
  author = {Shuping Dang and Guoqing Ma and Basem Shihada and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Enhanced Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing With Subcarrier Number Modulation}},
  journal = {IEEE Internet of Things Journal},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=cFyqY0Q2k4V},
}

Loading related content...

Figure