Energy level of residual heat resources and its matching property with ORC working medium

Wei Liu, YuJia Bao, Pan Xie, Zhichun Liu, Yuan FangChinese 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Reducing energy consumption and improving energy utilization efficiency are inevitable measures to solve energy problems. This paper proposes "available potential" ($e$) and "available potential energy level" ($\omega$) to quantitatively appraise residual heat resources like flue gas and water vapor. These metrics account for sensible heat, latent heat, and pressure properties. The study calculates these values for various conditions and analyzes the matching properties between heat sources and Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) working fluids. Results indicate that $e$ and $\omega$ provide a more intuitive and comprehensive evaluation of energy level and utilization potential compared to traditional temperature-based or pinch analysis methods.

Introduction

Industrial sectors are major energy consumers, making efficient waste heat recycling critical for energy reduction strategies. Traditionally, temperature has been the primary metric for grading residual heat. However, temperature alone is insufficient as it ignores the energy stored in pressure and the latent heat released during phase changes. This paper introduces a more rigorous framework using thermodynamic state functions to characterize the "work-doing capacity" of waste heat, facilitating better selection of working fluids for ORC systems.

Methodology and Metrics

The authors transition from simple temperature assessments to two key thermodynamic metrics:

  1. Available Potential ($e$): Defined as $e = h - T_0s$, where $h$ is enthalpy, $s$ is entropy, and $T_0$ is a reference temperature. It represents the maximum work capacity at a specific state.
  2. Available Potential Energy Level ($\omega$): Defined as the ratio $\omega = e/h$, representing the "quality" or "grade" of the energy.

The study evaluates these metrics for water vapor across temperatures (150–500°C) and pressures (0.4–2 MPa), and five types of industrial flue gas with varying moisture and chemical compositions. Finally, eight organic working fluids (e.g., Butane, R123, R134a) were analyzed for matching performance in an ORC evaporator.

Analysis of Waste Heat Resources

For water vapor, both available potential ($e$) and energy level ($\omega$) increase linearly with temperature at constant pressure. Furthermore, increasing the pressure at a constant temperature significantly boosts the available potential, indicating a higher capacity for work.

Available potential (e) of water vapor as a function of temperature and pressure.

Industrial Flue Gas and the "Moisture Paradox"

The composition of flue gas, particularly water vapor content, heavily influences its energy grade. A key finding is the "moisture paradox": while higher moisture increases total enthalpy ($h$), it decreases the energy level ($\omega$) at a given temperature. This occurs because the entropy increase from water vapor offsets enthalpy gains, reducing the "quality" of the heat despite the higher energy quantity.

Available potential (e) and energy level (ω) for different industrial flue gases showing the impact of composition and moisture.

ORC Working Fluid Matching

Using $e$ as a quantitative index allows for a more intuitive matching of heat sources with ORC working fluids than traditional pinch analysis. The study found that fluids with high latent heat of vaporization are better at "lifting" their available potential. Specifically, Butane and R600a demonstrated the highest increase in available potential during evaporation, making them excellent matches for high-grade waste heat. Conversely, R134a showed a lower potential for work-capacity gain, suggesting it is less suited for these specific industrial recovery applications.

Conclusion

The available potential criteria provide a comprehensive way to reflect sensible heat, latent heat, and pressure potential in waste heat resources. While this study focuses on the evaporator stage, it establishes a foundation for more efficient ORC system design. Future work should expand this analysis to include expander and condenser efficiencies, as well as economic and environmental factors like fluid cost and global warming potential.

Summary updated

Abstract

Reducing energy consumption and improving energy utilization efficiency are the inevitable measures to solve the energy problems in China. It is of great significance to achieve the strategic objectives of energy reduction that industrial sector, as a major energy- consuming areas, improves its energy efficiency and waste heat recycling level, follows the principle of maching temperature requirement and cascaded utilization, evaluates reasonably and makes full use of the waste heat, especially the one in low temperature. Considering certain limitations of using temperature as the grade evaluation of residual heat resources, available potential <italic>e</italic> and available potential energy level <italic>ω</italic> were proposed to quantitatively appraise the residual heat resources (such as flue gas, water vapor) which with sensible heat, latent heat and pressure properties. This paper details physical significance of available potential and available potential energy level and derivation process of their formulas, and calculates the available potential and the available potential energy level of water vapor and industrial flue gas in different temperature and pressure conditions to quantitative analysis the energy level grade of these two kinds of waste heat resources. Meaning while, due to <italic>e</italic> can represent the working capacity of working medium in a system, taking it as a quantitative evaluation index, is a tentative way to match the residual heat resources and the working medium of the system, and can provide guidance for efficient utilization of residual heat resources. On the basis of e, this paper analyses the matching properties between heat source and working medium of the ORC (Organic Rankine Cycle) system and puts forward some approaches for the increase of working performance in the evaporator of the ORC system. The results show that the enthalpy and available potential of water vapor increase with the rising of temperature when pressure is constant and the available potential on the point of the isotherm increase with the increasing of pressure, and the change regularity of available potential level along with the change of temperature and pressure has the same trend with available potential; Besides, the composition of industrial flue gas has a great influence on its enthalpy and available potential, especially the content of water vapor. The available potential level of specified flue gas decreases with the increasing of temperature when pressure is constant, and the available potential level of different kinds of industrial flue gas those who have the same temperature decreases with the increasing of the content of water vapor, in other words, the higher content of water vapor of industrial flue gas lead to the lower proportion of available potential of enthalpy. In general, the available potential criteria could quantitative reflect the sensible heat, latent heat and pressure potential of residual heat resources and comprehensive evaluate the energy level and utilization potential of residual heat resources; comparing with the pinch analysis method, the available potential analysis method was more intuitive to assess the matching properties between resource and working medium of the ORC system, which could be an alternative reference for choosing working medium of an ORC system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2015energy,
  author = {Wei Liu and YuJia BAO and Pan Xie and Zhichun Liu and Yuan Fang},
  title = {{Energy level of residual heat resources and its matching property with ORC working medium}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1360/n972015-00455},
}
Figure