Energy Harvesting Communication Using Finite-Capacity Batteries With Internal Resistance

Rajshekhar Vishweshwar Bhat, Mehul Motani, Teng Joon Lim

This paper, titled "Energy Harvesting Communication Using Finite-Capacity Batteries with Internal Resistance," provides a rigorous look at how the physical imperfections of batteries—specifically internal resistance—change the game for green, self-powered communication systems.

TL;DR

Most energy harvesting models assume "ideal" batteries, but real-world internal resistance causes significant power loss during fast charging and discharging. This paper develops new optimization policies that account for these rate-dependent losses, showing that traditional "ideal battery" strategies fail when applied to real hardware.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Energy harvesting (EH) is the "holy grail" for IoT and remote sensors, promising near-perpetual operation. However, sources like solar or vibration are erratic. To handle this, devices use batteries to "buffer" energy.

The standard academic assumption is that batteries are either 100% efficient or have a constant loss factor. In reality, batteries have internal resistance ($r$). When you charge or discharge a battery quickly, more energy is wasted as heat ($I^2r$ losses). This means battery efficiency is rate-dependent.

The authors tackle a fundamental question: How should a device split its time and power between harvesting energy, storing it, and transmitting data to maximize the communication rate, given that the battery itself is a source of inefficiency?

Methods

The authors model a dual-path architecture: harvested energy can either be used directly by the transmitter (zero-loss path) or stored in a finite-capacity battery for later use (lossy path).

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Efficiency Modeling: They derive tractable, non-linear models for charging and discharging efficiency based on equivalent circuit diagrams (voltage source + series resistor).
  • Single-Frame Optimization: They solve for the optimal "Time-Splitting Ratio" (TSR) and "Power-Splitting Ratio" (PSR) within a single communication block.
  • Off-line Optimization: For scenarios where future energy arrivals are known (a theoretical upper bound), they propose an iterative algorithm to solve a non-convex optimization problem.
  • On-line Policies: For real-world use where the future is unknown, they use Stochastic Dynamic Programming (SDP) to find the optimal policy and propose three practical heuristics:
  • Greedy: Use all available energy in the current frame.
  • Statistical Algorithm (SA): Uses mean values of future arrivals to make decisions.
  • Constant Splitting: Uses a pre-computed, fixed ratio regardless of fluctuations.

Datasets

As a theoretical communication theory paper, it does not use a standard external dataset. Instead, it evaluates the models using:

  • Synthetic Energy Profiles: Harvested power is modeled as a random variable (e.g., representing solar fluctuations).
  • Fading Channel Models: They assume an AWGN channel with Rayleigh fading (exponentially distributed power gains).
  • Hardware Parameters: Simulations use realistic values for micro-batteries and ultra-capacitors (internal resistance ranging from micro-ohms to tens of ohms).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Death of the "Double Threshold": In ideal battery models, the optimal transmit power follows a "double threshold" structure (it stays constant over certain ranges of harvested power). With internal resistance, this disappears. The optimal transmit power becomes strictly monotonic—it should almost always increase as harvested power increases to balance the rising internal losses.
  • Dedicated Charging Phases: The authors prove that in a single frame, it is often optimal to have a period where the device only charges and does not transmit. This minimizes the "circuit power" waste that occurs when running the transmitter on a weak, fluctuating energy stream.
  • Direct Path Preference: When harvested power is high, the system should prioritize the "direct path" to the transmitter. Cycling high power through the battery is inefficient due to the $I^2r$ heat losses.

Key Results

  • Efficiency Gaps: The study shows that charge efficiency can vary by up to 15 percentage points and discharge efficiency by up to 30 percentage points depending on the power rate.
  • Heuristic Performance: The proposed Statistical Algorithm (SA) performs remarkably well, achieving results very close to the optimal (but computationally expensive) SDP policy.
  • The Cost of Ignorance: Policies designed for "ideal" batteries perform poorly in real simulations. They tend to over-use the battery, leading to excessive resistive losses that significantly reduce the overall data throughput.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rate-Capacity Effect: The authors did not account for the "Peukert effect" (where the total available capacity of a battery changes based on how fast you drain it), though they argue this effect is negligible at the low power levels typical of IoT.
  • Battery Aging: The model assumes internal resistance is constant. In reality, $r$ increases as a battery ages, which would require an adaptive model over long time horizons.
  • Complexity: While the heuristics are fast, the optimal SDP approach suffers from the "curse of dimensionality" as the number of frames increases.

The authors suggest that future work could involve more advanced analysis of the proposed sub-optimal policies and incorporating more complex battery chemistry behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Modern systems will increasingly rely on energy harvested from their environment. Such systems utilize batteries to smooth out the random fluctuations in harvested energy. These fluctuations induce highly variable battery charge and discharge rates, which affect the efficiencies of practical batteries that typically have non-zero internal resistance. In this paper, we study an energy harvesting communication system using a finite battery with non-zero internal resistance. We adopt a dual-path architecture, in which harvested energy can be directly used, or stored and then used. In a frame, both time and power can be split between energy storage and data transmission. For a single frame, we derive an analytical expression for the rate optimal time and power splitting ratios between harvesting energy and transmitting data. We then optimize the time and power splitting ratios for a group of frames, assuming non-causal knowledge of harvested power and fading channel gains, by giving an approximate solution. When only the statistics of the energy arrivals and channel gains are known, we derive a dynamic programming-based policy and propose three sub-optimal policies, which are shown to perform competitively. In summary, this paper suggests that battery internal resistance significantly impacts the design and performance of energy harvesting communication systems and must be considered.
BibTeX
@article{bhat2017energy,
  author = {Rajshekhar Vishweshwar Bhat and Mehul Motani and Teng Joon Lim},
  title = {{Energy Harvesting Communication Using Finite-Capacity Batteries With Internal Resistance}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uZAa50K4X-},
}

Loading related content...

Figure