Energy-Efficient Beamforming Design for Integrated Sensing and Communications Systems

Jiaqi Zou, Songlin Sun, Christos Masouros, Yuanhao Cui, Ya-Feng Liu, Derrick Wing Kwan Ng

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of making Integrated Sensing and Communications (ISAC) systems energy-efficient by optimizing beamforming for both data transmission and radar-like target estimation. The authors introduce a novel "sensing-centric" energy efficiency metric and provide a mathematical framework to navigate the non-trivial tradeoff between communication performance and sensing accuracy per Joule of energy spent.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we move toward 6G, Integrated Sensing and Communications (ISAC) has emerged as a flagship technology, allowing base stations to simultaneously serve cellular users and "see" the environment (e.g., tracking UAVs or vehicles) using the same hardware and frequency bands. However, the high power consumption of modern 5G/6G networks makes energy efficiency (EE) a critical concern.

While previous research has focused on maximizing data rates or minimizing sensing errors (measured by the Cramér-Rao Bound, or CRB), the "bits-per-Joule" aspect of ISAC is under-explored. Specifically, how do you design a waveform that maximizes the ratio of performance to power consumption when the system has two competing goals? The problem is mathematically "thorny" because the objective functions are non-convex and fractional, making them difficult to solve with standard optimization tools.

Methods

The authors split the problem into three parts:

  1. Communication-Centric EE: Maximizing the data rate per Joule while meeting a minimum sensing accuracy requirement. They use the Dinkelbach method and Quadratic Transform to turn the difficult fractional objective into a series of manageable sub-problems.
  2. Sensing-Centric EE: The authors propose a brand-new metric: the reciprocal of the CRB divided by the total power. This essentially measures "sensing information per Joule." To solve this, they employ Successive Convex Approximation (SCA) and the Schur Complement to transform complex sensing constraints into Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMIs).
  3. Pareto Optimization: To find the optimal balance between the two, they formulate a Pareto boundary search. This allows a network operator to see exactly how much communication efficiency they must sacrifice to gain a certain level of sensing efficiency.

The study covers two physical scenarios: point-like targets (unstructured objects far away, like a drone) and extended targets (larger objects nearby that act as reflecting surfaces, like a car).

Datasets

As is standard for theoretical beamforming papers in signal processing, the authors do not use a "dataset" in the machine-learning sense. Instead, they evaluate their algorithms using numerical simulations based on standard channel models.

  • Parameters: A dual-functional base station with 20 receiving antennas, a maximum transmit power of 30 dBm, and a frame length of 30 time slots.
  • Baselines: They compare their work against traditional schemes that only maximize communication sum-rates or minimize power without considering the efficiency ratio.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Information-per-Joule" Metric: The paper’s most significant conceptual contribution is defining sensing efficiency as $1 / (CRB \cdot \text{Power})$. This puts radar performance on the same footing as communication "bits-per-Joule."
  • The Non-Trivial Tradeoff: The Pareto boundary reveals that you can maintain high communication efficiency while adding a baseline level of sensing. However, once you demand extremely high sensing accuracy, the communication efficiency drops precipitously.
  • Spatial Degrees of Freedom: Increasing the number of antennas improves both metrics, but the benefit to energy efficiency eventually plateaus because the "circuit power" (the energy needed just to keep the electronics running) starts to dominate the total power budget.
  • Interference as a Tool: In the extended target case, the authors show that dedicated "probing signals" (which might normally be seen as interference) can actually be optimized to help sensing without ruining the communication link.

Key Results

  • Convergence: The proposed iterative algorithms are computationally efficient, typically converging within 12 iterations.
  • Performance Gain: The proposed energy-efficient design significantly outperforms "sum-rate maximization" baselines. In some scenarios, the baseline's energy efficiency drops as transmit power increases (because it wastes power for marginal rate gains), whereas the proposed algorithm finds the "sweet spot" on the power curve.
  • User Impact: The number of communication users ($K$) has a severe effect on the tradeoff. As more users are added, the "spatial degrees of freedom" are consumed by data transmission, leaving less room to optimize for sensing efficiency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Static Scenarios: The paper assumes a relatively static environment where the target angle is known or roughly estimated. In highly dynamic 6G environments, the beamforming would need to adapt much faster.
  • Hardware Impairments: The model assumes ideal hardware. Real-world power amplifiers have non-linearities that could affect the waveform's sensing performance.
  • Future Direction: The authors suggest that extending this framework to Cell-Free Massive MIMO or Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) would be a logical next step to further boost the energy efficiency of ISAC.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the design of energy-efficient beamforming for an ISAC system, where the transmitted waveform is optimized for joint multi-user communication and target estimation simultaneously. We aim to maximize the system energy efficiency (EE), taking into account the constraints of a maximum transmit power budget, a minimum required signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) for communication, and a maximum tolerable Cramer-Rao bound (CRB) for target estimation. We first consider communication-centric EE maximization. To handle the non-convex fractional objective function, we propose an iterative quadratic-transform-Dinkelbach method, where Schur complement and semi-definite relaxation (SDR) techniques are leveraged to solve the subproblem in each iteration. For the scenarios where sensing is critical, we propose a novel performance metric for characterizing the sensing-centric EE and optimize the metric adopted in the scenario of sensing a point-like target and an extended target. To handle the nonconvexity, we employ the successive convex approximation (SCA) technique to develop an efficient algorithm for approximating the nonconvex problem as a sequence of convex ones. Furthermore, we adopt a Pareto optimization mechanism to articulate the tradeoff between the communication-centric EE and sensing-centric EE. We formulate the search of the Pareto boundary as a constrained optimization problem and propose a computationally efficient algorithm to handle it. Numerical results validate the effectiveness of our proposed algorithms compared with the baseline schemes and the obtained approximate Pareto boundary shows that there is a non-trivial tradeoff between communication-centric EE and sensing-centric EE, where the number of communication users and EE requirements have serious effects on the achievable tradeoff.
BibTeX
@article{zou2024energy,
  author = {Jiaqi Zou and Songlin Sun and Christos Masouros and Yuanhao Cui and Ya-Feng Liu and Derrick Wing Kwan Ng},
  title = {{Energy-Efficient Beamforming Design for Integrated Sensing and Communications Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tcomm.2024.3369696},
}

Loading related content...

Figure