TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel method for generating high-quality arguments by integrating argumentation knowledge graphs (AKGs) into the GPT-2 language model. By encoding structured knowledge about concepts and their relationships, the model produces more relevant, content-rich, and plausible arguments compared to standard GPT-2.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Generating compelling arguments automatically is a challenging but valuable task for applications like writing assistants and argument search engines. While existing neural models can generate arguments, they often lack factual grounding and struggle to incorporate external knowledge. This paper addresses the gap of integrating structured knowledge, specifically from argumentation knowledge graphs, into neural argument generation to improve the quality and controllability of the generated text.
Methods
The core of the approach involves fine-tuning the GPT-2 language model using a dataset augmented with knowledge from argumentation knowledge graphs.
- Knowledge Graph Construction: The authors construct three types of knowledge graphs:
- Ground-truth AKG: Based on existing work, this graph models concepts and their positive/negative effects on each other.
- Generated AKG: A larger graph automatically constructed from argumentative texts from online debate portals (args.me and kialo.com).
- Causality Graph: Leverages a pre-existing graph focused on causal relationships.
- Text-Knowledge Encoding: Argumentative texts from various sources (debate portals, Wikipedia) are preprocessed. For each text, concepts found in the knowledge graphs are identified. Pairs of concepts connected by a relation in the graph are then prepended to the text as keyphrases (e.g., "conceptA»positive»conceptB").
- Neural Language Model Fine-tuning: The preprocessed texts, now containing encoded knowledge, are used to fine-tune the GPT-2 model. This process biases the model to generate arguments that are grounded in the encoded knowledge.
- Argument Generation Models: Several models are evaluated:
- GPT-2: The baseline raw model.
- ArgData: GPT-2 fine-tuned on argumentative texts without graph knowledge.
- AB-ArgData: Fine-tuned on argumentative texts with knowledge from the ground-truth and generated AKGs combined.
- ABC-ArgData: Further incorporates knowledge from the causality graph.
- ABC-FullData: Uses the ABC-ArgData approach but also includes Wikipedia data.
Datasets
- Argumentative Texts: Collected from online debate portals:
args.me(debate.org, debatewise.org, debatepedia.org) andkialo.com. - Wikipedia: A subset of articles relevant to concepts in the ground-truth AKG was used.
- Knowledge Graphs:
- Al-Khatib et al. (2020) for the ground-truth AKG.
- Heindorf et al. (2020) for the causality graph.
- A new "Generated AKG" was constructed by the authors from the collected argumentative texts.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Structured Knowledge is Key: Integrating structured knowledge from argumentation graphs significantly improves argument generation quality, moving beyond what standard language models can achieve.
- Controllability and Specificity: The use of AKGs allows for more controlled generation, enabling arguments to elaborate on specific "talking points" or relationships.
- Causality Matters: Incorporating causal knowledge (from the causality graph) appears to be particularly beneficial for generating arguments with depth.
- Bias is a Persistent Challenge: Even with knowledge grounding, generated arguments can still exhibit social bias, highlighting the need for careful post-processing and ethical considerations.
- Wikipedia's Role: While Wikipedia data can enrich the dataset, it might also introduce topic shifts, suggesting a need for careful integration.
Key Results
- Manual Evaluation: Models incorporating graph knowledge (ABC-ArgData, AB-ArgData) consistently outperformed the baseline GPT-2 and ArgData models across relevance, argumentativeness, and content richness. ABC-ArgData achieved the highest scores overall.
- Automatic Evaluation: Similar trends were observed, with ABC-ArgData and AB-ArgData showing superior performance in relevance, argumentativeness, and content richness compared to GPT-2 and ArgData.
- Bias: A significant portion of generated arguments (up to 13% in some models) were flagged for bias, particularly concerning topics like illegal immigration and multiculturalism.
Limitations and Future Work
- Noise in Automatically Generated Graphs: The authors acknowledge that automatically generated graphs can contain noisy, overly specific, or abstract knowledge. Future work could involve more sophisticated noise filtering and knowledge ranking.
- Simple Text Matching: The current method relies on simple string matching for text-knowledge encoding. Future research could explore semantic similarity methods for more accurate matching.
- Encoding Representation: Investigating alternative representations for encoding graph knowledge beyond keyphrases is suggested.
- Model Size and Parameters: Using larger language models and exploring different parameter settings could further improve argument quality.
- Bias Mitigation: The authors explicitly mention the need for careful post-processing to filter out biased content and suggest further research into understanding and mitigating social bias in argument generation.
- Factuality: The generated arguments are not guaranteed to be factually correct, necessitating caution in their deployment.
Summary updated