Elements Allocation for Joint Active and Passive IRS Aided Wireless Communications: A Rate-Maximization Perspective

Chaoying Huang, Wen Chen, Qingqing Wu, Nan Cheng

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel system that combines Active Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (AIRS) and Passive Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (PIRS) to boost wireless communication rates. By optimizing how elements are allocated between AIRS and PIRS, the system achieves significantly higher data rates than existing single-IRS or double-PIRS solutions, especially in challenging wireless environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless communication systems are constantly seeking ways to improve data rates and signal quality, especially in complex environments where direct communication paths are blocked or weak. Traditional Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (IRS), or Passive IRS (PIRS), can steer signals but suffer from path loss, limiting their effectiveness. Active IRS (AIRS) can amplify signals, overcoming path loss, but introduce noise and require more power. This paper addresses the challenge of optimally combining the strengths of both PIRS and AIRS to maximize communication rates. Specifically, it tackles the problem of how to best allocate the limited "budget" of reflecting elements between an AIRS and a PIRS in a point-to-point wireless system, considering two distinct deployment configurations.

Methods

The authors propose a rate-maximization framework for a wireless system employing both an AIRS and a PIRS. They consider two deployment schemes: Tx → AIRS → PIRS → Rx (TAPR) and Tx → PIRS → AIRS → Rx (TPAR). The core of their approach involves optimizing the allocation of reflecting elements (i.e., deciding how many elements go to AIRS and how many to PIRS) and the beamforming design (phase shifts and amplitudes) for both IRSs.

To handle the complex optimization problem, they employ several techniques:

  • Mathematical Formulation: They formulate the problem as a rate maximization objective subject to constraints on total element budget and amplification power.
  • Convex Relaxation and Transformation: Non-convex optimization problems are transformed into convex ones using slack variables and logarithmic transformations, allowing for efficient solutions using interior-point methods.
  • Alternating Optimization (AO): An AO algorithm is proposed to iteratively optimize element allocation and IRS placement in 3D space.
  • Closed-Form Analytical Expressions: For practical scenarios, they derive closed-form expressions for near-optimal element allocations, providing valuable insights into system design.
  • Suboptimal Solutions: They also derive suboptimal solutions that offer a good trade-off between performance and complexity, making the system easier to implement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulated data based on defined system parameters and channel models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of AIRS and PIRS: The combination of AIRS and PIRS is crucial for overcoming the limitations of each individual technology. AIRS compensates for path loss and amplification noise, while PIRS provides a significant beamforming gain.
  • PIRS Dominance in Element Allocation: For optimal rate maximization, the PIRS should generally be allocated more reflecting elements than the AIRS. This is because PIRS elements contribute quadratically to beamforming gain, while AIRS elements contribute linearly to amplification gain.
  • Cubic SNR Scaling: Under certain conditions (e.g., large distance between AIRS and PIRS), the received Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) scales asymptotically with the cube of the total number of reflecting elements ($O(M^3)$). This is a significant improvement over single-IRS systems.
  • Deployment Scheme Matters: The TAPR scheme (Tx → AIRS → PIRS → Rx) generally offers better performance than TPAR (Tx → PIRS → AIRS → Rx), especially when the AIRS amplification power is high. This is attributed to the AIRS being closer to the transmitter, allowing its amplification to mitigate path loss more effectively before reaching the PIRS.
  • Suboptimal Solutions are Effective: The derived suboptimal element allocation strategies closely match the performance of optimal solutions, offering a practical approach for real-world deployment.

Key Results

  • The proposed joint AIRS-PIRS system significantly outperforms existing benchmarks, including single PIRS, single AIRS, hybrid IRS, and double PIRS systems, in terms of achievable rate.
  • The TAPR scheme consistently achieves higher rates than the TPAR scheme, particularly when the amplification power budget is substantial.
  • The optimal element allocation favors PIRS over AIRS, with the ratio of elements depending on deployment costs and system parameters.
  • Simulation results validate the analytical findings, showing that the proposed methods achieve near-optimal performance and provide substantial rate improvements. For instance, in Figure 3a, the proposed architecture shows a greater growth rate than single PIRS and AIRS due to the higher received SNR scaling order.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 3D Deployment Optimization: While the paper considers 3D space, the optimization of IRS placement is mentioned as a part of the AO algorithm but not deeply detailed in terms of analytical closed-form solutions for placement itself.
  • Channel State Information (CSI): The analysis assumes perfect CSI is available. In real-world scenarios, CSI acquisition can be challenging and may impact performance.
  • Energy Efficiency: The paper focuses on rate maximization. The authors suggest that future work could explore energy efficiency with limited deployment budgets in this joint AIRS-PIRS system.
  • Practical Constraints: While practical constraints like element budget and amplification power are considered, other real-world factors like hardware imperfections, interference, and mobility are not explicitly addressed.

Summary updated

Abstract

Unlike previous works that focused solely on passive intelligent reflecting surface (PIRS) or active IRS (AIRS), a novel joint AIRS and PIRS architecture has been developed to flexibly utilize their combined advantages in mitigating multiplicative path loss cost-effectively. In this paper, we consider the AIRS-PIRS jointly aided wireless point-to-point communication system with two different deployment schemes in three-dimensional (3D) space. To balance the trade-off between the square-order beamforming gain of PIRS and the unique power amplification gain of AIRS, we optimize the elements allocation and beamforming design of the two IRSs under various practical constraints from a rate-maximization perspective. Moreover, we derive a series of element-related closed-form analytical expressions and compare the performance of the two schemes. Our analysis shows that in both schemes, PIRS should be allocated more elements than AIRS, and the received signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) increases asymptotically with the cube of the number of reflecting elements, when the distance between AIRS and PIRS is sufficiently large. Last, simulation results validate our analysis and indicate that both schemes can achieve superior rate performance over various benchmarks.
BibTeX
@article{huang2025elements,
  author = {Chaoying Huang and Wen Chen and Qingqing Wu and Nan Cheng},
  title = {{Elements Allocation for Joint Active and Passive IRS Aided Wireless Communications: A Rate-Maximization Perspective}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=lHPlTntK9v},
}
Figure