Effect of Selected Moisture Reference Year on the Durability Assessment of Wall Assemblies under Future Climates

Sahar Sahyoun, Hua Ge, Chetan Aggarwal, Maurice Defo, Terrence J. MooreXV 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Hygrothermal simulations are commonly used to evaluate the moisture damage risk of building envelopes over the long-term. For such assessment to be accurate, a proper selection of representative climate data is required. A common method is the selection of a moisture reference year (MRY) from a set of available long-term climate data. This paper compares two approaches for selecting MRYs—the Moisture Index (MI) and the ASHRAE 160 Severity Index ($I_{sev}$)—against full 31-year simulations for historical and future climates. The study evaluates two wall assemblies in three Canadian cities. In general, higher mold index values were obtained by the long-term simulation and MRYs using $I_{sev}$. Comparing the results of different models under future climates, the three methods were in good agreement, except for a brick wall facing wind-driven rain (WDR) in Ottawa and Vancouver. This study highlights that considering both WDR and North orientations is essential for accurate performance evaluation.

Introduction: The Challenge of Climate Selection

To design durable buildings, engineers use hygrothermal simulations to predict moisture movement through walls over decades. However, running hourly simulations for 30+ years is computationally expensive and data-heavy. To simplify this, the industry typically selects a single "representative" year—a Moisture Reference Year (MRY)—to stand in for the long-term climate.

The challenge lies in selecting a year that accurately represents the long-term risk. If the chosen year is too mild, the simulation will underestimate the risk of mold and rot. This paper compares the established Moisture Index (MI) approach against the newer ASHRAE Severity Index ($I_{sev}$) to see which better predicts the actual damage observed in a full 31-year simulation, particularly under the shifting conditions of future climate change.

Methodology

The researchers performed hygrothermal simulations using DELPHIN software on two common Canadian wall types: a stucco-clad wood frame and a brick-veneer wood frame.

The general configuration of the wall assemblies used in the simulations, including sheathing, OSB, and vapor barriers.

The study compared three approaches:

  1. Moisture Index (MI): Based on a balance of wetting (rain) and drying (evaporation) functions.
  2. Severity Index ($I_{sev}$): A regression-based approach from ASHRAE 160 incorporating solar radiation, humidity, wind-driven rain, and temperature.
  3. Long-term Simulation (31-Y): A full 31-year hourly simulation used as the "ground truth" benchmark.

Simulations were conducted for Ottawa, Vancouver, and Calgary using historical data (1986–2016) and future projections (2062–2092). Performance was measured using the Viitanen Mold Index, which rates mold growth from 0 (none) to 5 (heavy).

Key Insights and Results

The analysis demonstrated that the method of selecting a reference year significantly impacts the predicted durability of the wall.

$I_{sev}$ as a Conservative Predictor

In almost all scenarios, the Severity Index ($I_{sev}$) predicted higher mold risks than the Moisture Index (MI), aligning much more closely with the "worst-case" results found in the full 31-year simulations. For example, in Ottawa's stucco walls, MI predicted a mold index of only 1.0, while the long-term simulation showed a much more dangerous 4.5. $I_{sev}$ closely matched the benchmark with a prediction of 4.0.

Comparison of Maximum Mold Index for Brick (a) and Stucco (b) assemblies across different cities and selection methods.

Material and Orientation Sensitivities

The $I_{sev}$ formula was originally developed based on North-facing stucco walls. The researchers found that while it works well for stucco, it can behave unexpectedly for brick walls facing wind-driven rain (WDR). In Vancouver, North-facing walls showed zero mold risk due to local rain patterns, but risk spiked when oriented toward WDR. This highlights that orientation is just as critical as the selection of the weather year itself.

Future Climate Escalation

As expected, future climate loads generally increased the mold index across the board. A "severe" year in the 2080s is projected to be significantly more damaging than a severe year today, necessitating more robust selection methods for future-proofing designs.

Conclusion

The ASHRAE Severity Index ($I_{sev}$) provides a more accurate and conservative basis for selecting moisture reference years than the traditional Moisture Index. However, its performance varies with cladding type and orientation. Future work will involve refining the $I_{sev}$ method for a wider variety of wall systems and orientations to ensure reliable durability assessments across diverse climates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hygrothermal simulations are commonly used to evaluate the moisture damage risk of building envelopes over the long-term. For such assessment to be accurate, a proper selection of representative climate data is required. A common method is the selection of a moisture reference year from a set of available long-term climate data. For instance, the IRC-led research consortium MEWS (Moisture Management of Exterior Wall Systems) developped the Moisture Index (MI) approach, which consists of a wetting and a drying function. Therefore, the reference year selection would be based on the MI ranking. ASHRAE 160 is adopting a procedure named “the severity index” for the selection of moisture reference year. Combining climate loads and durability criteria, this method allows to select more “severe” weather years, thus providing a more representative ranking of the weather data. The objective of this paper is two-fold. First, to compare the selection of the moisture reference year based on two different approaches for both historical and future climate loads. Second, the effect of chosen representative years is evaluated and compared to long-term simulation periods (of 31-years) based on the durability of building assemblies. The methodology includes hygrothermal simulations of two different types of wall assemblies located in three different Canadian cities under a changing climate. In general, higher mold index values were obtained by the long-term simulation and MRYs using Isev. Comparing the results of different models under future climates, the three methods were in good agreement, except for a brick wall facing WDR in Ottawa and Vancouver. This might be due to the Isev correlations were developed based on a north-facing stucco wall. In addition, for a north-facing wall, an extremely low mold index was predicted for Vancouver, compared to WDR direction. Thus, considering a north-facing wall as a criterion for performance evaluation might misrepresent the reality in some locations. Hence, both WDR and North orientations should be considered. A further study will be carried out to investigate the performance evaluation of Isev method for different types of wall systems and orientations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sahyoun2020effect,
  author = {Sahar Sahyoun and Hua Ge and Chetan Aggarwal and Maurice Defo and Terrence J. Moore},
  title = {{Effect of Selected Moisture Reference Year on the Durability Assessment of Wall Assemblies under Future Climates}},
  booktitle = {XV},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.23967/dbmc.2020.056},
}
Figure