Abstract
The Solar Energy Research Institute (SERI) was funded by the Department of Energy's Office of Buildings and Community Systems (DOE OBCS) in FY 1987 and 1988 to investigate cost-effective ways to weatherize mobile homes constructed prior to the enactment of HUD Thermal Standards in 1976. In FY 1987, SERI studied the effectiveness of a variety of infiltration-reducing retrofits by monitoring 20 units in the field before, during, and after applications of air tightening measures. In FY 1988, the study expanded to include measures intended to reduce envelope conduction losses, such as storm windows, insulated skirting, and wall, roof, and floor insulation. This research resulted in the development of a short-term testing method for measuring the thermal impact of individual conduction-reducing retrofits.
Introduction
By the late 1980s, approximately 3 to 5 million mobile homes in the United States predated the 1976 HUD Thermal Standards. These dwellings were significantly less energy-efficient than contemporary site-built homes, often consuming up to twice the energy per square foot. A primary obstacle to improving their efficiency was a "knowledge gap" among weatherization crews, who frequently applied standard residential techniques that proved ineffective in the unique structural context of mobile homes.
Mobile homes feature distinct construction details, such as "belly" cavities housing ductwork and plumbing, which create unconventional leak sites and thermal bridges. This study sought to provide a data-driven roadmap for weatherizing these units by identifying the most significant energy loss mechanisms and evaluating the cost-effectiveness of specialized retrofits.
Methodology
The researchers employed a dual-method approach to capture both air infiltration and thermal conduction data.
Infiltration Study
SERI monitored 20 mobile homes in Denver, Colorado. Blower doors were utilized as both a measurement tool and a diagnostic instrument to locate hidden leaks. Following the field audits, the researchers used the SERIRES building energy simulator to model a "typical" unit across four distinct climates—Denver, Madison, Miami, and Phoenix—to project long-term energy savings and economic payback periods.
Conduction Study
To isolate the impact of insulation measures (walls, roof, and floor/belly), the team developed a short-term warehouse testing method. Two specific units, located in Jackson, Wyoming, and Glenwood Springs, Colorado, were moved into warehouses to maintain a constant temperature differential (quasi-steady state). This "co-heating" variant allowed for the precise measurement of the unit's effective conductance (UA) before and after individual retrofits in a controlled environment.
Key Insights and Results
Air Sealing and Infiltration
The study revealed that mobile homes leak differently than site-built homes. The most significant leaks were not found around windows and doors, but rather in furnace closets, water heater compartments, swamp cooler chases, and the junctions where ductwork meets floor registers. Targeted infiltration-reducing measures, guided by blower door diagnostics, achieved an average 40% reduction in air leakage. In the Denver climate, this translated to a 15% reduction in annual heating energy use.
Conduction-Reducing Retrofits
Thermal performance tests in the warehouse environment demonstrated that adding belly insulation, wall insulation, and storm windows each provided approximately 10-11% savings in thermal conductance (UA). Notably, site-fabricated plexiglass storm windows emerged as one of the most cost-effective retrofits, with simple payback periods as low as 1.5 to 3.5 years in cold climates.
The Importance of the "Belly"
The space beneath the floor, or the "belly," was identified as a major source of heat loss due to the presence of uninsulated ductwork. Insulating this area was found to be as effective as air-tightening the entire shell of the home.
Economic Viability
Climate was found to be the primary determinant of cost-effectiveness. While measures were highly effective in heating-dominated regions like Denver or Madison, they were often ineffective in cooling-dominated climates like Miami or Phoenix. In cold climates, a comprehensive package including infiltration sealing, storm windows, and belly insulation yielded a simple payback period of approximately 4 to 6.5 years.
Conclusion and Future Work
While the warehouse testing method proved promising for isolating thermal impacts, it was limited by "noise" caused by imperfectly insulated warehouse facilities, which challenged the maintenance of strict steady-state conditions.
Future research should focus on developing highly controlled testing facilities to increase measurement precision. Additionally, further investigation is required into the interactive effects of furnace tune-ups and duct sealing, as well as specialized strategies for hot and humid climates where solar gain and latent cooling loads are the dominant energy drivers.
Summary updated