Assessment of Moisture Performance of National Building Code Canada Compliant Wall Assemblies under Climate Change

M. Junginger, Maurice Defo, Terrence J. Moore, Michael Lacasse, Vanderley Moacyr JohnXV 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Due to climate change, higher temperatures and rainfalls are expected in some areas of Canada, potentially increasing climate loads on buildings and leading to premature degradation of moisture-sensitive materials. This study investigates the durability of code-compliant wood-frame walls in Ottawa, Vancouver, and Calgary using Delphin 5.9 hygrothermal simulations. Two climate datasets were compared: historical (1986–2016) and future (2062–2092) under a 3.5°C global warming scenario. Results indicate that while future mould risk increases significantly for stucco walls in Ottawa, it may decrease in Calgary due to higher drying potential. Brick cladding consistently demonstrated superior resilience across all scenarios.

Introduction

Building codes, such as the National Building Code of Canada (NBC), currently prescribe wall assembly requirements based on historical climate data. However, climate change is shifting these environmental loads, with rising temperatures and more extreme rainfall patterns. In Canada’s standard wood-frame residential construction, moisture is the primary driver of structural decay and mould growth. This research evaluates whether current code-compliant assemblies can withstand the projected climate loads of the late 21st century, focusing on wind-driven rain (WDR) and interior air leakage.

Methodology

The researchers employed hygrothermal modeling to simulate the simultaneous transport of heat and moisture through building envelopes. Simulations were conducted using Delphin 5.9 for 3.5-storey wood-frame walls featuring two common claddings: brick masonry (with a drainage cavity) and stucco.

Schematic of the modeled wall assembly layers, showing the sequence from exterior cladding (1) to interior gypsum board (8).

The study accounted for several critical variables:

  • Air Leakage: Modeled as exfiltration of warm, moist indoor air into the wall cavity.
  • Wind-Driven Rain (WDR): Calculated based on ASHRAE 160 standards.
  • Performance Metric: The VTT Mould Index (0–6 scale), where values above 3 indicate visible mould growth.

Three Canadian cities—Ottawa, Vancouver, and Calgary—were analyzed across two 31-year periods: Historical (1986–2016) and Future (2062–2092, +3.5°C warming). Within these periods, "median" and "wettest" years were selected to represent typical and worst-case moisture loads.

Key Insights and Results

Regional Divergence

The impact of climate change is highly regional. In Ottawa, increased future rainfall drives up moisture risk. Conversely, in Calgary, the rise in temperature outweighs the change in precipitation, enhancing the wall's "drying potential" and actually reducing the risk of mould growth in the future.

Cladding Performance

Brick cladding consistently outperformed stucco. The air cavity behind the brick and the material's moisture-buffering capacity help protect sensitive inner layers, such as the OSB sheathing. In Ottawa and Calgary, brick assemblies maintained a mould index of 0 across all scenarios.

Mould index evolution over time for Vancouver, Ottawa, and Calgary. Panels show the divergent impacts of future climate (F) versus historical (H) data on different cladding types.

Summary of Findings by City

  • Vancouver: Remains the highest-risk environment. Both historical and future scenarios showed high mould indices (above 3.0) for both brick and stucco. Future risks were slightly lower in average years due to projected decreases in rainfall.
  • Ottawa: Stucco walls experienced a dramatic increase in risk, with the maximum mould index jumping from 2.25 (historical) to 4.13 (future).
  • Calgary: Stucco performance improved in future projections, with the mould index dropping from 2.36 to 1.68 as warmer air facilitated faster drying.

Conclusion

This study highlights a "moisture balance" shift: while air leakage remains a risk factor, its relative impact may decrease as external climate loads or drying potentials become more dominant. The findings suggest that current building codes may need to be updated to account for non-stationary climate data, particularly for moisture-sensitive claddings like stucco in regions expecting higher rainfall. Future work should expand this analysis to more diverse geographic locations and consider the effects of material aging on hygrothermal performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to climate change, higher temperatures and rainfalls are expected to happen in some areas of Canada, which might increase the climate loads on buildings and lead to premature degradation of moisture-sensitive materials in wall assemblies. To investigate potential durability issues in three cities across Canada (Ottawa, Vancouver and Calgary), code-compliant wood-frame walls with two types of claddings, stucco and brick, were simulated using Delphin 5.9. Two different climate data sets, historical and future when a global warming of 3.5ºC is expected to be reached were used. The hygrothermal performance in terms of mold growth risk was analysed with respect to cladding types, considering air leakage. All the three cities are similarly warmer in the future. However, wind-driven rain (WDR) is higher in Vancouver than in Ottawa and Calgary. With brick cladding the relative humidity is kept below the threshold for mould development only in Ottawa and Calgary. With stucco in future, while Ottawa shows greater mould indices than historical, Calgary shows opposite behavior. The results suggest that the risk of mould growth due to air leakage may decrease in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{junginger2020assessment,
  author = {M. Junginger and Maurice Defo and Terrence J. Moore and Michael Lacasse and Vanderley Moacyr John},
  title = {{Assessment of Moisture Performance of National Building Code Canada Compliant Wall Assemblies under Climate Change}},
  booktitle = {XV},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.23967/dbmc.2020.012},
}
Figure