Effect of lacquer decoration on VOCs and odor release from P. neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble

Qifan Wang, Bin Zeng, Jun Shen, Huiyu WangScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

The problem of odor caused by solid wood and its lacquer finish is increasingly serious. In this study, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry/olfactometry is used to analyze the volatile organic compounds and odor-active substances released from Phoebe neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble lacquered with three types of lacquers, which is helpful in solving furniture's odor problem. The results show that olefin emission of the three types of lacquer coating for P. neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble decreases by more than 90% but that total volatile organic compound release increases. Among these, polyurethane (PU) lacquer could lead to a sharp increase of ester and aromatic hydrocarbons. Waterborne lacquer also releases numerous esters and alcohol compounds. Ultraviolet (UV)-curable lacquer has the greatest inhibitory effect on alcohols, aldehydes, and ketones and does not release esters or other compounds, but the release of toluene increases sharply. Benzaldehyde, toluene, and 1,3-dimethylbenzene are identified as key odor characteristic compounds of P. neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble. Aromatic and fruity are the main odor characteristics of P. neurantha and three types of lacquer decoration studied. The overall odor intensity increases with lacquer treatment, especially PU lacquer. Among them, UV lacquer has the lowest overall odor intensity.

Introduction

As indoor air quality becomes a primary health concern, the "new furniture smell" is being scrutinized as a complex mixture of potentially harmful Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs). While the emissions of raw wood are well-documented, there is a lack of comparative data on how different industrial finishes—Polyurethane (PU), Waterborne Acrylic, and UV-curable lacquers—interact with specific wood species like Phoebe neurantha. This study bridges the gap between chemical concentration and olfactory perception to assist manufacturers in creating low-odor and low-emission products.

Methodology

The researchers employed a dual-pronged analytical approach to capture both the chemistry and the sensory experience:

  • GC-MS (Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry): Used to identify and quantify specific chemical compounds.
  • GC-O (Gas Chromatography-Olfactometry): Trained panelists rated the intensity and described the odor of compounds as they eluted from the chromatograph.
  • Sampling: Wood samples (raw wood control, PU-treated, Waterborne-treated, and UV-treated) were analyzed using a microchamber thermal extractor and Tenax-TA adsorption tubes.

Key Insights and Ideas

Lacquering solid wood furniture fundamentally alters its chemical "scent signature." While lacquers effectively block natural wood emissions, they often trigger a surge in synthetic VOCs.

  • The "Sealing" Paradox: All three lacquers reduced the wood’s natural olefin emissions by over 90%. However, the lacquers themselves release significantly more VOCs than they trap.
  • PU as an Odor Powerhouse: Polyurethane radically increased the release of esters and aromatic hydrocarbons, nearly doubling the overall odor intensity compared to raw wood.
Radar chart comparing odor characteristic compounds of solid wood and Polyurethane (PU) coatings.
  • The Toluene Trade-off in UV Lacquers: UV-curable lacquer was the "cleanest" in terms of perceived odor but caused a massive spike in toluene—reaching levels nearly 33.5 times higher than raw wood, exceeding several international safety standards.
  • Odor Markers: Benzaldehyde, toluene, and 1,3-dimethylbenzene were identified as the key compounds defining the smell of decorated P. neurantha.

Key Results

The study quantified significant shifts in chemical emissions following lacquer application.

Relative concentration of VOCs (ug·m⁻³) for raw wood and three lacquer types.
  • TVOC Increases: Compared to raw wood, TVOC emissions increased by 227.9% for PU, 51.78% for waterborne, and 9.95% for UV coatings.
  • Odor Intensity: Raw wood rated 17.5 on the sensory scale. PU lacquer spiked this to 32.7, while UV lacquer remained relatively stable at 18.7.
  • Specific Chemical Spikes:
    • PU: Significant increase in 1,3-dimethylbenzene (633.85 µg·m⁻³) and butyl acetate.
  • UV: Released 403.36 µg·m⁻³ of toluene, well above the Chinese national limit of 100 µg·m⁻³.
  • Waterborne: Showed a 12.5x increase in alcohol emissions.

Conclusion

While lacquer decoration is essential for protection, it significantly impacts the indoor environment's chemical and olfactory profile. PU coatings present the highest risk for odor and VOC emissions. UV coatings, while having the lowest overall odor impact, require better control of toluene emissions to be a truly viable environmental choice. Future research should investigate the long-term decay of these emissions in residential settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

The problem of odor caused by solid wood and its lacquer finish is increasingly serious. In this study, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry/olfactometry is used to analyze the volatile organic compounds and odor-active substances released from Phoebe neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble lacquered with three types of lacquers, which is helpful in solving furniture's odor problem. The results show that olefin emission of the three types of lacquer coating for P. neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble decreases by more than 90% but that total volatile organic compound release increases. Among these, polyurethane (PU) lacquer could lead to a sharp increase of ester and aromatic hydrocarbons. Waterborne lacquer also releases numerous esters and alcohol compounds. Ultraviolet (UV)-curable lacquer has the greatest inhibitory effect on alcohols, aldehydes, and ketones and does not release esters or other compounds, but the release of toluene increases sharply. Benzaldehyde, toluene, and 1,3-dimethylbenzene are identified as key odor characteristic compounds of P. neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble. Aromatic and fruity are the main odor characteristics of P. neurantha and three types of lacquer decoration studied. The overall odor intensity increases with lacquer treatment, especially PU lacquer. Among them, UV lacquer has the lowest overall odor intensity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020effect,
  author = {Qifan Wang and Bin Zeng and Jun Shen and Huiyu Wang},
  title = {{Effect of lacquer decoration on VOCs and odor release from P. neurantha (Hemsl.) Gamble}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-66724-0},
}
Figure