Identification and analysis of odor-active compounds from Choerospondias axillaris (Roxb.) Burtt et Hill with different moisture content levels and lacquer treatments

Qifan Wang, Jun Shen, Bin Zeng, Huiyu WangScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

The problem of indoor odors can greatly affect a room's occupants. To identify odorants and comprehensively evaluate emissions from wooden materials, emissions and odors from Choerospondias axillaris (Roxb.) Burtt et Hill with different moisture content percentages and lacquer treatments were investigated in this study. Thermal desorption-gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy/olfactometry was used to analyze the release characteristics. In total, 11 key odor-active compounds were identified as moisture content gradually decreased, concentrating between 15 and 33 min. Total volatile organic compounds, total very volatile organic compounds, and total odor intensity decreased as moisture content decreased. In addition, 35 odor-active compounds, including aromatics, alkenes, aldehydes, esters, and alcohols, were identified in the odor control list. Polyurethane (PU), ultraviolet (UV), and waterborne coatings had a good inhibitory effect on eight odor characteristics, but some scents arose after lacquer treatment. For equilibrium moisture content, the major characteristics of Choerospondias axillaris were fragrant (9.4) and mint-like (3.0) compared with the fragrant (8.2), fruity (7.8), and pleasant (5.8) characteristics of PU coating; the flowery (5.9), fragrant (5.0), glue-like (4.3), and pineapple-like (4.3) characteristics of UV coating; and the antiseptic solution (3.6), fragrant (2.9), cigarette-like (2.8), and fruity (2.5) characteristics of waterborne coating. Based on multicomponent evaluation, a Choerospondias axillaris board with waterborne coating was suggested for use indoors.

Introduction

Solid wood furniture is highly valued for its natural aesthetic and perceived environmental benefits. However, wood is not chemically inert; it naturally emits volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and very volatile organic compounds (VVOCs) derived from its extractives, such as resins, terpenes, and phenols. During processing, drying, and coating, these emissions change, often creating indoor odor problems that can impact occupant comfort or health. While many studies focus on general VOC emission limits, fewer address specific odor characteristics and how physical factors like moisture content interact with chemical treatments like lacquers. This study provides a comprehensive profile of the emissions from Choerospondias axillaris wood under varying conditions.

Methods

The researchers combined analytical chemistry with human sensory evaluation to build a comprehensive profile of the wood's emissions:

  • Sample Preparation: Wood samples were dried to specific moisture contents ranging from 60% down to 5%. Equilibrium samples (10% moisture) were then treated with three common lacquers: Polyurethane (PU), Ultraviolet-curable (UV), and Waterborne.
  • TD-GC-MS/O: Thermal Desorption–Gas Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry/Olfactometry was used to separate and identify compounds. Simultaneously, a trained human assessor at a "sniffing port" recorded odor characteristics and intensities on a 0-5 scale.
  • Multicomponent Risk Assessment: Health risks were evaluated using the European LCI (Lowest Concentration of Interest) framework, calculating an $R$ value (the sum of hazard ratios for all detected chemicals) to assess overall safety.

Results and Discussion

The Impact of Moisture Content

A significant finding was the "30% moisture tipping point," representing the fiber saturation point of the wood. VOC and VVOC emissions dropped drastically as moisture content decreased from 60% to 30%. Specifically, TVOCs dropped by 93.28% and VVOCs by 97.67% in this range. This is primarily due to the evaporation of free water, which carries volatile compounds out of the wood structure. Below 30%, the decline in emissions slows significantly.

Figure 3: Mass concentration and odor intensity as a function of moisture content.

Lacquer Treatments and Odor Profiles

The study identified 35 distinct odor-active compounds, primarily aromatics, alkenes, aldehydes, esters, and alcohols. While coatings successfully sealed off natural wood odors (like almond, pine, and fishy smells), they introduced new chemical scents.

  • Untreated Wood: Dominated by "fragrant" (9.4) and "mint-like" (3.0) notes.
  • PU Coating: Maintained a "fragrant" (8.2) and "fruity" (7.8) profile.
  • UV Coating: Introduced "glue-like" (4.3) and "pineapple-like" (4.3) smells, driven by high concentrations of ethyl acetate.
  • Waterborne Coating: Left a mild "antiseptic" (3.6) and "cigarette-like" (2.8) odor.
Figure 4: Detailed emission profiles across various compound classes and moisture levels.

Safety and Risk Assessment

Relying solely on Total VOCs (TVOC) to judge indoor air quality can be misleading. The UV coating had the highest total concentration of emissions, overwhelmingly driven by VVOCs (6,696.97 $\mu g/m^3$), and the highest hazard ratio ($R = 2.4246$), making it the least safe option. The waterborne coating emerged as the safest overall, with the lowest hazard ratio ($R = 0.3338$) and low TVOC (593 $\mu g/m^3$) and VVOC (452 $\mu g/m^3$) levels.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that both moisture content and lacquer treatments significantly influence the odor and safety profile of Choerospondias axillaris wood. Waterborne coatings are recommended for indoor use due to their superior safety profile. The methodology established here can serve as a framework for building a standardized odor database for various wood species, helping manufacturers mitigate indoor air quality issues.

Summary updated

Abstract

The problem of indoor odors can greatly affect a room's occupants. To identify odorants and comprehensively evaluate emissions from wooden materials, emissions and odors from Choerospondias axillaris (Roxb.) Burtt et Hill with different moisture content percentages and lacquer treatments were investigated in this study. Thermal desorption-gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy/olfactometry was used to analyze the release characteristics. In total, 11 key odor-active compounds were identified as moisture content gradually decreased, concentrating between 15 and 33 min. Total volatile organic compounds, total very volatile organic compounds, and total odor intensity decreased as moisture content decreased. In addition, 35 odor-active compounds, including aromatics, alkenes, aldehydes, esters, and alcohols, were identified in the odor control list. Polyurethane (PU), ultraviolet (UV), and waterborne coatings had a good inhibitory effect on eight odor characteristics, but some scents arose after lacquer treatment. For equilibrium moisture content, the major characteristics of Choerospondias axillaris were fragrant (9.4) and mint-like (3.0) compared with the fragrant (8.2), fruity (7.8), and pleasant (5.8) characteristics of PU coating; the flowery (5.9), fragrant (5.0), glue-like (4.3), and pineapple-like (4.3) characteristics of UV coating; and the antiseptic solution (3.6), fragrant (2.9), cigarette-like (2.8), and fruity (2.5) characteristics of waterborne coating. Based on multicomponent evaluation, a Choerospondias axillaris board with waterborne coating was suggested for use indoors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020identification,
  author = {Qifan Wang and Jun Shen and Bin Zeng and Huiyu Wang},
  title = {{Identification and analysis of odor-active compounds from Choerospondias axillaris (Roxb.) Burtt et Hill with different moisture content levels and lacquer treatments}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-71698-0},
}
Figure