Effect of COVID-19 response policies on walking behavior in US cities

Ruth F. Hunter, Leandro García, Thiago Hérick de Sá, Belén Zapata-Diomedi, Christopher Millet, James Woodcock, Alex Pentland, Esteban Moro

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused mass disruption to our daily lives. Mobility restrictions implemented to reduce the spread of COVID-19 have impacted walking behavior, but the magnitude and spatio-temporal aspects of these changes have yet to be explored. Walking is the most common form of physical activity and non-motorized transport, and so has an important role in our health and economy. Understanding how COVID-19 response measures have affected walking behavior of populations and distinct subgroups is paramount to help devise strategies to prevent the potential health and societal impacts of declining walking levels. In this study, we integrated mobility data from mobile devices and area-level data to study the walking patterns of 1.62 million anonymous users in 10 metropolitan areas in the United States (US). The data covers the period from mid-February 2020 (pre-lockdown) to late June 2020 (easing of lockdown restrictions). We detected when users were walking, measured distance walked and time of the walk, and classified each walk as recreational or utilitarian. Our results revealed dramatic declines in walking, especially utilitarian walking, while recreational walking has recovered and even surpassed the levels before the pandemic. However, our findings demonstrated important social patterns, widening existing inequalities in walking behavior across socio-demographic groups. COVID-19 response measures had a larger impact on walking behavior for those from low-income areas, of low education, and high use of public transportation. Provision of equal opportunities to support walking could be key to opening up our society and the economy.

Introduction

Walking is a fundamental pillar of urban mobility and public health. As the most accessible form of physical activity, it plays a critical role in reducing the risk of chronic diseases and serves as a vital "first and last mile" connection for public transit systems. Despite its importance, walking behavior is often overlooked in large-scale mobility analyses that prioritize vehicular traffic.

The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent stay-at-home orders triggered a massive shift in how people move through cities. While early reports noted a general decline in mobility, they lacked the granularity to distinguish between why people were walking. This study addresses this gap by analyzing high-resolution mobility data to understand how pandemic response measures affected different types of walking (utilitarian vs. recreational) and how these impacts varied across socio-demographic groups.

Methodology

To capture a comprehensive picture of urban walking, researchers utilized a data-fusion approach involving 1.62 million anonymous users across 10 major US metropolitan areas (New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Boston, Miami, Dallas, San Francisco, Seattle, Philadelphia, and Washington DC).

  • Walking Detection and Classification: Using GPS data, the study identified walking "bouts" based on speed and distance. These bouts were classified as utilitarian (ending at Points of Interest like shops or workplaces) or recreational (leisure-focused, typically in residential areas or parks) using a database of 1.5 million POIs.
  • Socio-Demographic Mapping: Users were aggregated by their home census tracts and linked to US Census Bureau data (income, education, race), CDC obesity prevalence, and park access metrics.
  • Temporal Analysis: The researchers examined diurnal patterns to see how the timing of walks changed before and after the implementation of COVID-19 response measures.

The Divergence of Walking Behavior

The most immediate impact of the pandemic was a dramatic collapse in total walking activity. Following the national emergency declaration in March 2020, the number of walking bouts plummeted by 75%, and the average distance walked fell by 55%. However, as the initial shock subsided, a clear divergence emerged between utilitarian and leisure walking.

Figure 2: Trends in walking bouts and distances across 10 US cities, showing the sharp decline in March and the uneven recovery by city and walk type.

Utilitarian walking, which includes commuting and errands, saw a massive 72.3% drop in distance and remained nearly 40% below baseline levels even as restrictions eased in June. In contrast, recreational walking proved far more resilient. While it also dipped initially, it recovered quickly and, in many areas, eventually surpassed pre-pandemic levels. This shift also altered the temporal rhythm of cities; the traditional "commuter peaks" at 7 AM and 3 PM flattened, with weekday walking patterns beginning to mirror the more distributed activity of weekends.

Widening Socio-Demographic Inequalities

Perhaps the most significant finding of the study is the emergence of a "walking gap" that mirrors existing socio-economic divides. Before the pandemic, residents of low-income areas typically engaged in more walking activity, often out of necessity for transport. The pandemic inverted this relationship.

Figure 6: Socio-demographic disparities in walking recovery, highlighting how high-income groups increased leisure walking while low-income and high-transit-use areas saw sustained declines.

High-income individuals were able to substitute lost utilitarian walks with a surge in recreational activity—increasing their leisure walking distance by approximately 48%. Conversely, low-income groups and those in areas with high public transit reliance saw their total walking levels crash without a corresponding recreational recovery. The strongest predictor of a sustained decline in walking was a neighborhood's dependence on public transportation, as the reduction in transit use eliminated the associated "first and last mile" walks.

Conclusion and Implications

The COVID-19 pandemic has fundamentally reshaped the landscape of urban walking. While the recovery of recreational walking is a positive sign for public health in some sectors, the sustained decline in utilitarian walking—particularly in vulnerable, low-income, and transit-dependent neighborhoods—poses a long-term risk for physical inactivity and social inequality.

These findings suggest that urban planning must move beyond general mobility targets and focus on equitable access to walkable environments. Strategies such as "tactical urbanism"—including pop-up parks, widened sidewalks, and improved pedestrian infrastructure in underserved areas—are essential to ensure that the benefits of walking are available to all citizens, regardless of socio-economic status.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT The COVID-19 pandemic has caused mass disruption to our daily lives. Mobility restrictions implemented to reduce the spread of COVID-19 have impacted walking behavior, but the magnitude and spatio-temporal aspects of these changes have yet to be explored. Walking is the most common form of physical activity and non-motorized transport, and so has an important role in our health and economy. Understanding how COVID-19 response measures have affected walking behavior of populations and distinct subgroups is paramount to help devise strategies to prevent the potential health and societal impacts of declining walking levels. In this study, we integrated mobility data from mobile devices and area-level data to study the walking patterns of 1.62 million anonymous users in 10 metropolitan areas in the United States (US). The data covers the period from mid-February 2020 (pre-lockdown) to late June 2020 (easing of lockdown restrictions). We detected when users were walking, measured distance walked and time of the walk, and classified each walk as recreational or utilitarian. Our results revealed dramatic declines in walking, especially utilitarian walking, while recreational walking has recovered and even surpassed the levels before the pandemic. However, our findings demonstrated important social patterns, widening existing inequalities in walking behavior across socio-demographic groups. COVID-19 response measures had a larger impact on walking behavior for those from low-income areas, of low education, and high use of public transportation. Provision of equal opportunities to support walking could be key to opening up our society and the economy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hunter2021effect,
  author = {Ruth F. Hunter and Leandro García and Thiago Hérick de Sá and Belén Zapata-Diomedi and Christopher Millet and James Woodcock and Alex Pentland and Esteban Moro},
  title = {{Effect of COVID-19 response policies on walking behavior in US cities}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-23937-9},
}
Figure